Law covered in these questions
- Nettleship v Weston [1971] 2 QB 691
- Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582
- Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232
- Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11
- Mullin v Richards [1998] 1 WLR 1304
- Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority [1987] QB 730 (CA)
- Phillips v William Whiteley Ltd [1938] 1 All ER 566
- Wells v Cooper [1958] 2 QB 265
- Bolton v Stone [1951] AC 850
- Paris v Stepney BC [1951] AC 367
- Latimer v AEC Ltd [1953] AC 643
- Watt v Hertfordshire CC [1954] 1 WLR 835
- Roe v Minister of Health [1954] 2 QB 66
- Compensation Act 2006 s 1
All 19 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Lena, a learner driver with two lessons behind her, drives into a parked car because she brakes too late. The parked car's owner sues. Lena says she was doing her best for a beginner. Which statement best describes the standard of care applied?
- No standard of care, because a learner driver owes no duty to parked cars.
- A subjective standard, so she is not liable if she did her best.
- A standard that is lower because she was being supervised.
- The standard of a reasonable learner driver of her experience.
- The standard of a reasonably competent driver, so her inexperience is not a defence.Correct answer
The standard is objective. A driver, including a learner, must reach the standard of a reasonably competent and experienced driver, because the victim's protection should not depend on the driver's skill.
Law basis: Nettleship v Weston [1971] 2 QB 691Question 2 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Dr Rees, an orthopaedic surgeon, uses a technique accepted as proper by a responsible body of surgeons, though another body of surgeons prefers a different approach. The patient, Carys, suffers a known complication and claims that Dr Rees was negligent in not using the alternative. Which of the following best describes the test for breach?
- He is negligent if the court prefers the alternative approach used by the other surgeons.
- He is negligent if most surgeons in his specialty would have used the alternative approach.
- He is not negligent if a responsible body of surgeons supports his approach.Correct answer
- He is not negligent if he honestly believed that his technique was the best available.
- He is negligent because a known complication arose, which raises a presumption of fault.
Under the Bolam test, a doctor is not negligent if he acts in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical opinion skilled in that particular art, merely because there is a body of opinion that would take a contrary view. The court does not choose between two responsible schools of thought, and the defendant's practice need not be the majority view. The test is objective, so honest belief is not enough. The occurrence of a known complication does not of itself prove negligence; Carys must prove breach on the balance of probabilities.
Law basis: Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582Question 3 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
A child is admitted to hospital with breathing difficulties. The registrar fails to attend when called and the child suffers brain damage. The registrar argues that even had she attended she would not have intubated, and calls expert evidence that a body of doctors would also not have intubated. The claimant's experts say no logical doctor would fail to intubate. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- The court must accept the defence opinion, as a responsible body of doctors supports it.
- The court must prefer the claimant's experts, as their opinion favours greater caution.
- The court must decide which group of experts is the larger and follow the majority view.
- The court may reject the defence opinion only if the defendant's doctors acted dishonestly.
- The court may reject the defence opinion if it cannot withstand logical analysis.Correct answer
In Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority the House of Lords qualified Bolam: the body of professional opinion relied on must have a logical basis, meaning that the experts have weighed the risks and benefits and reached a defensible conclusion. In rare cases the court may conclude that an opinion is not reasonable or responsible and reject it. The court does not simply follow the majority, prefer the more cautious view, or require dishonesty. In Bolitho itself the defence opinion was accepted as logical, so the claim failed on causation.
Law basis: Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232Question 4 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Nadine, who is diabetic and of small stature, is pregnant. Her obstetrician knows there is a 9-10% risk of a serious complication during vaginal birth for women like her but does not mention it, believing that if told she would ask for a caesarean. Nadine's baby is injured by the complication. Which of the following best describes the test for whether the doctor was negligent in not telling her?
- Whether a responsible body of obstetricians would also have withheld the information.
- Whether disclosing the risk would have been contrary to Nadine's medical best interests.
- Whether the risk was greater than 10%, the threshold above which disclosure is required.
- Whether a reasonable patient in her position would attach significance to the risk.Correct answer
- Whether Nadine had expressly asked about the risks of a vaginal birth beforehand.
In Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board the Supreme Court held that a doctor must take reasonable care to ensure the patient is aware of any material risks of the recommended treatment and of reasonable alternatives. A risk is material if a reasonable person in the patient's position would be likely to attach significance to it, or if the doctor is or should reasonably be aware that this patient would do so. The Bolam test no longer governs disclosure. There is no percentage threshold, and the patient need not ask. The therapeutic exception is narrow and cannot be used to steer the patient.
Law basis: Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11Question 5 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Two 15-year-old schoolgirls, Ellie and Hana, are play-fencing with plastic rulers during a lesson. A ruler snaps and a fragment enters Ellie's eye, causing a serious injury. Ellie sues Hana. Which of the following best describes the standard of care applied to Hana?
- The standard of an ordinarily careful and reasonable 15-year-old.Correct answer
- The standard of a reasonable adult, as the risk of eye injury was obvious.
- No standard, as a child under 16 cannot be liable in negligence.
- The standard of a reasonable 15-year-old with Hana's own intelligence and experience.
- The standard of a reasonable adult, reduced by a fixed proportion for her age.
In Mullin v Richards the Court of Appeal held that a child defendant is judged by the standard of an ordinarily prudent and reasonable child of the same age, not that of an adult. The question was whether a reasonable 15-year-old would have foreseen that playing with rulers in this way carried a risk of injury; on the facts it was not foreseeable, so there was no breach. Children can be liable in negligence. The test remains objective, so it is not adjusted for the individual child's own intelligence, and there is no fixed percentage reduction.
Law basis: Mullin v Richards [1998] 1 WLR 1304Question 6 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Dr Okafor, a junior doctor three months into a post in a specialist neonatal unit, makes an error in inserting a catheter that a more experienced doctor would not have made. A premature baby is harmed. Dr Okafor argues that she should be judged by the standard of a doctor of her limited experience. Which of the following best describes the standard applied?
- The standard of a reasonably competent doctor of her own limited experience.
- The standard of the most experienced consultant working in the neonatal unit.
- A lower standard, because she was working under the supervision of a consultant.
- No liability, because the hospital, not the junior doctor, is responsible for errors.
- The standard of a reasonably competent doctor holding the post she occupied.Correct answer
In Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority the Court of Appeal held that the standard of care relates to the post the doctor occupies, not to the individual's experience. A junior doctor in a specialist unit must show the skill of a reasonably competent doctor in that post, though she may discharge the duty by seeking help from a senior colleague. The standard is not that of the most senior consultant. Supervision does not lower the standard. The hospital may be vicariously or directly liable, but that does not mean the junior doctor's conduct is not negligent.
Law basis: Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority [1987] QB 730 (CA)Question 7 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Mira, a jeweller, pierces Kate's ears in her shop using sterilised equipment and a method appropriate for jewellers. Kate develops an abscess and argues that Mira should have used the full aseptic technique a surgeon would use. Which of the following best describes the standard Mira must meet?
- The standard of a reasonably competent surgeon, as piercing is a medical procedure.
- The standard of a reasonably competent nurse, as piercing involves breaking the skin.
- The standard of a reasonably competent jeweller carrying out ear piercing.Correct answer
- A subjective standard, judged by Mira's own skill and training as a jeweller.
- Strict liability, as Mira supplied a service involving the risk of infection.
The standard of care is that of the reasonable person carrying out the activity in question. In Phillips v William Whiteley Ltd a jeweller who pierced ears was held to the standard of a reasonably competent jeweller doing that work, not that of a surgeon. Kate, having chosen to go to a jeweller, could not expect surgical standards, and the jeweller had taken appropriate precautions. The standard remains objective, not dependent on Mira's personal skill, and negligence liability is fault-based, not strict. Anyone holding themselves out as carrying out a task must meet the standard reasonably expected for it.
Law basis: Phillips v William Whiteley Ltd [1938] 1 All ER 566Question 8 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Cole, a competent amateur DIY enthusiast, fits a new handle to the back door of his house. Months later the handle comes away when Liam, a visiting delivery driver, pulls it, and Liam falls and is injured. A professional carpenter would have used longer screws. Which of the following best describes the standard of care applied to Mr Cole?
- The standard of a reasonably competent professional carpenter doing the same job.
- The standard of a reasonably competent amateur doing that kind of job.Correct answer
- The standard of an average householder with no DIY experience at all.
- No standard, as an occupier owes no duty in respect of his own DIY work.
- The standard of a professional, because Liam was on the premises as a worker.
In Wells v Cooper the Court of Appeal held that a householder doing a minor job himself must show the skill of a reasonably competent amateur carpenter doing that work, not that of a professional. The task was one that a householder might reasonably do himself, and he had done it competently by amateur standards. For more complex or dangerous work, however, a reasonable person would employ a professional, and doing it oneself may itself be negligent. Mr Cole owed Liam the common duty of care as occupier, and the status of Liam as a worker does not alter the standard.
Law basis: Wells v Cooper [1958] 2 QB 265Question 9 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
A cricket ball is hit out of a village ground and injures Selma, who is standing outside her house. Balls have left the ground about six times in 30 years and nobody has been hurt before. The pitch is protected by a high fence and is well away from the road. Which of the following best describes whether the club was in breach?
- It was in breach, as it was foreseeable that a ball could leave the ground and injure someone.
- It was in breach, as cricket clubs are strictly liable for balls landing outside their grounds.
- It was probably not in breach, as the risk was small enough to disregard.Correct answer
- It was not in breach, as Selma accepted the risk by living close to a cricket ground.
- It was in breach, as the club could have stopped playing cricket at that ground altogether.
In Bolton v Stone the House of Lords held that a cricket club was not negligent when a ball struck a passer-by, because the risk was so small that a reasonable person would not have taken further precautions. Foreseeability of harm is necessary but not sufficient for breach; the court weighs the likelihood and seriousness of harm against the cost and practicability of precautions and the utility of the activity. A reasonable club need not abandon the activity to eliminate a very small risk. There is no strict liability here, and living near a ground is not consent.
Law basis: Bolton v Stone [1951] AC 850Question 10 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Dev, a garage fitter who has already lost the sight of one eye, is hammering a rusty bolt. His employer does not provide goggles, because the risk of a metal chip entering the eye is small and goggles are not usually supplied for this work. A chip enters Dev's good eye, blinding him. Which of the following best describes whether the employer was in breach?
- It was in breach, as the grave consequences for Dev called for extra precautions.Correct answer
- It was not in breach, as it was not general practice to supply goggles for this work.
- It was not in breach, as the risk of injury was the same for Dev as for other workers.
- It was in breach, as an employer is strictly liable for injuries to disabled employees.
- It was not in breach, as Dev should have provided his own goggles in the circumstances.
In Paris v Stepney BC the House of Lords held that the seriousness of the potential harm is relevant to the standard of care, and that the employer knew of the worker's particular vulnerability. Although the likelihood of an eye injury was the same for all workers, the consequences for a one-eyed man were far graver, as he risked total blindness. The employer was negligent in not providing goggles to him. Common practice is relevant but not conclusive. There is no strict liability, and it is the employer's responsibility to provide necessary safety equipment.
Law basis: Paris v Stepney BC [1951] AC 367Question 11 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Heavy rain floods a factory and leaves the floor slippery with oil. The managers spread all the sawdust they have over most of the floor, but some areas remain untreated. Zoltan, a worker, slips on an untreated patch and is injured. He argues that the factory should have been closed until the floor was safe. Which of the following best describes whether the employer was in breach?
- It was in breach, as it should have shut the factory until every patch was treated.
- It was in breach, as an employer must remove every risk that it knows to be present.
- It was not in breach, as it took reasonable precautions proportionate to the risk.Correct answer
- It was not in breach, as an employer owes no duty in respect of flooding from rain.
- It was in breach, as the injury itself shows that the precautions were inadequate.
In Latimer v AEC Ltd the House of Lords held that an employer who had spread sawdust on a flooded floor was not negligent in failing to close the factory. The standard of care requires the defendant to take precautions proportionate to the risk, weighing its likelihood and seriousness against the cost and practicability of eliminating it. Closing the factory was out of proportion to the relatively small risk that remained. An employer need not eliminate all risk, and the mere fact that an injury occurred does not establish breach. Employers do owe a duty to maintain a safe workplace.
Law basis: Latimer v AEC Ltd [1953] AC 643Question 12 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Firefighters are called to rescue a woman trapped under a heavy vehicle. The only lorry available is not equipped to secure a heavy jack. On the journey the jack slips and injures Fergus, a firefighter. He sues the fire authority, which argues that it was an emergency. Which of the following best describes the position?
- It was in breach, as an employer can never send staff out with unsecured equipment.
- It was not in breach, as firefighters are taken to accept all risks of their job.
- It was in breach, as the emergency increases the standard of care owed to staff.
- It was not in breach, as emergency services owe no duty to their own employees.
- It was probably not in breach, given the value of saving life.Correct answer
In Watt v Hertfordshire CC the Court of Appeal held that the fire authority was not negligent. In assessing breach the court weighs the risk against the end to be achieved, and saving life justifies taking risks that would be unacceptable in a commercial context. The authority still owed a duty to its employee, and the risk to Fergus was not ignored, but it was reasonable in the emergency. There is no rule that firefighters accept all risks. An emergency does not raise the standard; if anything it is a factor tending against a finding of breach.
Law basis: Watt v Hertfordshire CC [1954] 1 WLR 835Question 13 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
In 1950 two patients were paralysed after spinal anaesthetics, because a disinfectant in which the glass ampoules were stored had seeped in through microscopic cracks. This risk was not known to anaesthetists at the time but later became well known. The patients sue the hospital. Which of the following best describes the test for breach?
- The hospital is liable, as the risk is now well known in medical practice.
- The hospital is liable, as anaesthetists are strictly liable for contaminated drugs.
- The hospital's conduct is judged by the knowledge available at the date of trial.
- The hospital's conduct is judged by the knowledge available at the time.Correct answer
- The hospital is liable, as the patients would not otherwise have been paralysed.
In Roe v Minister of Health the Court of Appeal held that the hospital was not negligent because, at the time, the risk of invisible cracks allowing contamination was not known and could not reasonably have been foreseen. Denning LJ said that one must not look at the 1947 accident with 1954 spectacles. Breach is assessed according to the state of knowledge when the defendant acted, not with hindsight at the date of trial. Liability in negligence is fault-based, not strict, and the fact that the injury would not otherwise have happened goes to causation, not breach.
Law basis: Roe v Minister of Health [1954] 2 QB 66Question 14 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
A scout troop leader, Fen, takes children on a supervised woodland hike. A child trips on a tree root and breaks her arm. Her parents allege that Fen should have chosen a flat route. Fen argues that requiring that level of caution would discourage worthwhile outdoor activities. Which of the following best describes the relevance of her argument?
- The court may consider whether such steps would deter desirable activities.Correct answer
- It provides a complete defence, as voluntary activities with social value are exempt.
- It is irrelevant, as breach depends only on whether the injury was foreseeable.
- It applies only to professional organisations rather than voluntary groups like scouts.
- It reverses the burden, so Fen must prove that the route was reasonably safe.
Section 1 of the Compensation Act 2006 provides that a court considering whether a defendant should have taken particular steps to meet the standard of care may have regard to whether requiring those steps might prevent a desirable activity from being undertaken, or discourage people from undertaking functions connected with it. This largely restates the common law approach of weighing social utility. It is not a complete defence and does not reverse the burden of proof. It applies to anyone, including volunteers. Foreseeability is necessary but not the only consideration in deciding breach.
Law basis: Compensation Act 2006 s 1 ↗Question 15 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Kemal sees a cyclist collapse in the road. He rushes to help, and while moving her to the pavement he aggravates her neck injury. She sues him. Kemal says he was only trying to help in an emergency. Which of the following best describes the effect of the Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Act 2015?
- It gives him complete immunity from liability for any act of rescue in an emergency.
- The court must have regard to whether he was acting heroically in an emergency.Correct answer
- It applies only if Kemal had a recognised first aid qualification at the time.
- It means that the standard of care is lowered to that of an untrained bystander.
- It applies only where the person helping is acting on behalf of a charity.
Section 4 of the Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Act 2015 requires the court, in deciding whether the defendant was negligent, to have regard to whether he was acting heroically by intervening in an emergency to assist an individual in danger. Sections 2 and 3 require regard to whether the defendant acted for the benefit of society and had demonstrated a predominantly responsible approach to safety. The Act does not create an immunity or a new standard of care; it lists factors to consider. No qualification or charitable connection is required.
Law basis: Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Act 2015 ss 2-4 ↗Question 16 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Gary, a lorry driver, suffers a gradual drop in blood sugar caused by an undiagnosed medical condition. He is unaware of it, and his driving becomes erratic until he crashes into Hamid's shop. Hamid argues that Gary must be judged by the standard of a competent driver in full health. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- Gary is in breach, as the standard of care ignores any medical condition of the driver.
- Gary is not in breach, as he is judged as a competent driver unaware of the condition.Correct answer
- Gary is in breach, as any driver who crashes is presumed to have fallen below the standard.
- Gary is not in breach, as the standard is subjective and he did his best in the circumstances.
- Gary is in breach, as a driver is strictly liable for any damage caused by his vehicle.
In Mansfield v Weetabix Ltd the Court of Appeal held that a driver whose ability was impaired by a condition of which he was unaware, and could not reasonably have been aware, was judged by the standard of a reasonably competent driver unaware of the condition. Because he did not know and could not reasonably have known of his impairment, he was not in breach. The test remains objective but takes account of what the driver knew or ought to have known. A driver who continues driving knowing he is unwell would be negligent. There is no strict liability or presumption.
Law basis: Mansfield v Weetabix Ltd [1998] 1 WLR 1263Question 17 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Wendy slips on a pool of spilt yoghurt on the floor of a supermarket aisle and is injured. She cannot show how long it had been there or who spilt it. The supermarket gives no evidence about its cleaning system or how often the aisle was checked. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- She is likely to fail, as she cannot prove how long the yoghurt had been on the floor.
- She is likely to succeed, as a supermarket is strictly liable for spills in its aisles.
- She is likely to succeed, as the facts call for an explanation which it has not given.Correct answer
- She is likely to fail, as the spill was probably caused by another customer.
- She is likely to succeed, but only if she proves that staff knew of the spill.
In Ward v Tesco Stores Ltd the Court of Appeal held that where an accident of this kind occurs in premises under the defendant's control and would not normally happen if proper care were taken, the facts speak for themselves (res ipsa loquitur). This raises an inference of negligence, and the evidential burden shifts to the defendant to show it had a reasonable system for preventing and clearing spills. Tesco failed to do so. Wendy need not prove how long the spill had been there or who caused it. Liability remains fault-based, not strict.
Law basis: Ward v Tesco Stores Ltd [1976] 1 WLR 810; Scott v London and St Katherine Docks Co (1865) 3 H & C 596Question 18 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Bruno is convicted in the magistrates' court of careless driving arising from a collision with Clara's car. He does not appeal. Clara now sues him in negligence for her injuries. Bruno intends to deny that he drove carelessly. Which of the following best describes the effect of his conviction in the civil claim?
- It is inadmissible, as civil proceedings must be decided entirely on fresh evidence.
- It is conclusive, so he is prevented from denying negligence in any way at trial.
- It is admissible, and he must now prove that he was not careless.Correct answer
- It is admissible, but Clara must still prove the offence beyond reasonable doubt.
- It is relevant only to the amount of damages, not to whether he was negligent.
Under section 11 of the Civil Evidence Act 1968, the fact that a person has been convicted of an offence is admissible in civil proceedings to prove that he committed it, and he is taken to have committed the offence unless the contrary is proved. The conviction therefore shifts the burden to Bruno to prove, on the balance of probabilities, that he was not careless. It is not conclusive, and Clara does not have to prove the offence to the criminal standard. In practice a conviction for careless driving makes it very difficult to deny breach.
Law basis: Civil Evidence Act 1968 s 11 ↗Question 19 · Breach of dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
At a national horse show, Ollie, a competitor, is galloping his horse round a tight corner at speed. He misjudges the bend and the horse plunges into the arena edge, injuring Tess, a photographer standing at the boundary. Which of the following best describes whether Ollie was in breach?
- He was probably not in breach, as an error of judgement in competition is not negligent.Correct answer
- He was in breach, as a competitor must always guarantee the safety of spectators.
- He was in breach, as spectators are owed a higher standard of care than other competitors.
- He was not in breach, as a competitor owes no duty at all to people watching the event.
- He was in breach, as misjudging the bend shows a lack of the skill of a reasonable rider.
In Wooldridge v Sumner the Court of Appeal held that a competitor who made an error of judgement in the agony of competition was not negligent towards a spectator. The duty is to take reasonable care in all the circumstances, which include the speed and pressures of competition. Later cases, such as Caldwell v Maguire, confirm that the threshold for liability in a fast-moving sporting context is high, and a mere error of judgement does not amount to breach. Competitors do owe a duty to spectators, but it is not a guarantee of safety or a higher standard.
Law basis: Wooldridge v Sumner [1963] 2 QB 43; Caldwell v Maguire [2001] EWCA Civ 1054More Tort Law topics
Back to all Tort Law questions, or sit a timed mock.