A quarry's blasting operations send dust and vibration across a wide area, affecting many homes in the surrounding district. The local authority seeks an injunction in public nuisance. The quarry argues that only a few residents complained, so the nuisance is not public. Which of the following best describes the test?
- It is public only if every person living in the district has been affected.
- It is public only if at least one resident has suffered special damage.
- It is public only if the activity has been prosecuted as a criminal offence.
- It is public only if it occurs on or affects a public highway in the area.
- It is public if it affects a class of His Majesty's subjects.Correct answer
In Attorney-General v PYA Quarries Ltd the Court of Appeal held that a public nuisance is one which materially affects the reasonable comfort and convenience of life of a class of His Majesty's subjects, and that it is a question of fact whether a sufficiently large section of the public is affected. It is not necessary to show that every member of the class has been affected, nor that there has been a prosecution. Special damage is required only for an individual to sue for damages, not to establish a public nuisance. The highway is a common, but not exclusive, setting.
Law basis: Attorney-General v PYA Quarries Ltd [1957] 2 QB 169