A petrol station worker, Joe, is asked by a customer to leave the premises, and he follows the customer to his car, swearing and attacking him. The customer sues Joe's employer. Which statement best describes the employer's position?
- The employer is not liable, because an employer is never liable for an employee's intentional wrong.
- The employer is liable only if it had authorised the assault.
- The employer is likely to be liable, because there was a close connection between what Joe was employed to do and the wrong, so it was in the course of his employment.Correct answer
- The employer is not liable, because Joe was acting on his own initiative.
- The employer is liable only if the customer can sue Joe successfully first.
The test is whether there is a sufficiently close connection between the employee's job and the wrongdoing, so that it is fair to hold the employer liable. Dealing with customers was Joe's job, even though he abused it.
Law basis: Mohamud v WM Morrison Supermarkets plc [2016] UKSC 11