Law covered in these questions
- Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013 s 69
- Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 s 47
- Cutler v Wandsworth Stadium Ltd [1949] AC 398
- Gorris v Scott (1874) LR 9 Ex 125
- Groves v Lord Wimborne [1898] 2 QB 402
- X (Minors) v Bedfordshire CC [1995] 2 AC 633
- Close v Steel Co of Wales Ltd [1962] AC 367
- Highways Act 1980 ss 41, 58
- Atkinson v Newcastle and Gateshead Waterworks Co (1877) 2 Ex D 441
All 8 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Breach of statutory dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
In 2025 Dilys is injured at work when she falls from a ladder that her employer failed to inspect as required by the Work at Height Regulations 2005. She wishes to sue for breach of statutory duty, relying on the regulations, rather than in negligence. Which of the following best describes her position?
- She can sue for breach of the regulations, as they impose strict duties on employers.
- She cannot sue for breach of the regulations, and must sue in negligence.Correct answer
- She can sue for breach of the regulations, provided she was a member of the protected class.
- She can sue for breach of the regulations, but only if her employer was prosecuted.
- She cannot sue at all, as health and safety breaches give rise only to criminal liability.
Section 69 of the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013 amended section 47 of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 so that breach of a duty imposed by health and safety regulations is not actionable in civil proceedings, except so far as the regulations provide otherwise. This applies to breaches occurring on or after 1 October 2013. Dilys must therefore sue in negligence, though the regulations may be relevant evidence of the standard of care expected. She is not left without a remedy, and a prosecution is irrelevant to her civil claim.
Law basis: Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013 s 69; Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 s 47 ↗Question 2 · Breach of statutory dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
A statute requires greyhound track operators to provide space at the track for bookmakers to carry on business. A track operator refuses to give Basil, a bookmaker, a pitch, and he loses income. The statute provides for criminal penalties but is silent on civil claims. Basil sues for breach of statutory duty. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It fails, as the statute did not intend a private right of action.Correct answer
- It succeeds, as Basil is within the class of persons the statute was meant to benefit.
- It succeeds, as any breach of a statutory duty causing loss is actionable in tort.
- It fails, as only personal injury caused by a statutory breach can be actionable.
- It succeeds, as the criminal penalty is too small to be an adequate remedy for him.
In Cutler v Wandsworth Stadium Ltd the House of Lords held that a bookmaker had no civil action against a track operator which failed to provide space for him under the betting legislation. Whether a breach of statutory duty is actionable depends on the construction of the statute and Parliament's intention. The duty was imposed for the regulation of betting for the benefit of the public, not to protect a limited class of bookmakers, and the statute provided its own criminal sanction. Not every statutory breach causing loss is actionable, and the tort is not confined to personal injury.
Law basis: Cutler v Wandsworth Stadium Ltd [1949] AC 398Question 3 · Breach of statutory dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Regulations require livestock carried on ships to be kept in pens, to reduce the spread of contagious disease between animals. A shipowner fails to pen Farmer Ewan's sheep, and they are washed overboard in a storm. They would not have been lost had they been penned. Ewan sues for breach of statutory duty. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It succeeds, as the breach of statutory duty caused the loss of his sheep.
- It succeeds, as the regulations were intended to protect owners of livestock.
- It fails, as a storm is an act of God which is a complete defence.
- It succeeds, but only for the sheep that were not already diseased.
- It fails, as the duty was imposed to prevent disease, not loss at sea.Correct answer
In Gorris v Scott the court held that a claim for breach of statutory duty failed because the damage suffered was not of the kind the statute was intended to prevent. The duty to pen animals was imposed to prevent the spread of disease, not to protect them from being washed overboard. It is not enough that the breach caused the loss, or that the claimant was within the protected class; the harm must also fall within the mischief at which the duty was aimed. The storm was not the basis of the decision.
Law basis: Gorris v Scott (1874) LR 9 Ex 125Question 4 · Breach of statutory dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Under an old Factory Act, an employer must securely fence dangerous machinery. Breach is a criminal offence punishable by a fine, part of which may be paid to the injured worker. A boy employed in the factory catches his arm in an unfenced cogwheel. He sues for breach of statutory duty. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome under the traditional approach?
- It fails, as the statute provides its own criminal penalty for the breach.
- It fails, as the fine payable to the worker is his exclusive remedy.
- It succeeds, as the duty was to protect a limited class of which he is a member.Correct answer
- It succeeds only if he also proves the employer was negligent in failing to fence.
- It fails, as factory legislation is passed for the benefit of the public at large.
In Groves v Lord Wimborne the Court of Appeal held that a young worker injured by unfenced machinery could sue for breach of the statutory duty to fence. The duty was imposed to protect a limited class, factory workers, and the small fine was not intended to be their only remedy. Liability for breach of statutory duty does not require proof of negligence, as the duty to fence was strict. Today, breaches of health and safety regulations occurring after 1 October 2013 are generally not actionable, but the traditional test from this case remains relevant to other statutes.
Law basis: Groves v Lord Wimborne [1898] 2 QB 402Question 5 · Breach of statutory dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Several children who suffered abuse sue their local authority, alleging that it breached its statutory duties under child welfare legislation by failing to take them into care. They claim damages for breach of statutory duty, separately from any claim in negligence. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome of the breach of statutory duty claim?
- It succeeds, as the children were within the class the legislation was meant to protect.
- It fails, as general welfare statutes are not intended to create private rights.Correct answer
- It succeeds, as a public body's breach of a statutory duty is always actionable.
- It fails, as only a claim for judicial review can be brought against a council.
- It succeeds, but only if the council's failure was also irrational in public law.
In X (Minors) v Bedfordshire CC the House of Lords held that statutory duties imposed on local authorities for the protection of children were not actionable as breaches of statutory duty. Duties of a general social welfare character, involving the exercise of administrative discretion for the benefit of society, are unlikely to be intended to give individuals a right to damages, even where they benefit an identifiable class. Public bodies' breaches are not automatically actionable, and judicial review is not the only route, but there is no private law action for breach of these duties.
Law basis: X (Minors) v Bedfordshire CC [1995] 2 AC 633Question 6 · Breach of statutory dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
A statute requires dangerous parts of machinery to be securely fenced. A piece of a drilling machine, which was properly fenced against workers reaching in, flies out of the machine and hits Siân, a worker, in the eye. She sues for breach of statutory duty, arguing that the fence should have been designed to keep flying parts in. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It succeeds, as the statute's duty to fence securely is absolute.
- It fails, as the duty was to keep workers out, not to keep parts in.Correct answer
- It succeeds, as the machine injured a worker within the protected class.
- It fails, as the employer did not know that parts could fly out of the machine.
- It succeeds, as the injury would not have occurred had the fence been enclosed.
In Close v Steel Co of Wales Ltd the House of Lords held that the statutory duty to fence dangerous machinery was intended to keep workers away from the machine, not to keep the machine or its parts from flying out. A claim for breach of statutory duty requires that the duty was breached and that the harm is of the type the duty was meant to prevent. Being within the protected class is necessary but not sufficient. The employer's lack of knowledge was not the basis, and the fact that a fuller enclosure would have prevented the injury does not mean the duty required one.
Law basis: Close v Steel Co of Wales Ltd [1962] AC 367Question 7 · Breach of statutory dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
Gemma, a cyclist, is thrown from her bike by a deep pothole on a road maintainable at public expense and is injured. The highway authority shows that it inspected the road every month under a reasonable inspection policy, and the pothole developed only after the last inspection. Gemma sues under the Highways Act 1980. Which of the following best describes the authority's position?
- It is strictly liable, as the pothole was a failure to maintain the highway.
- It is not liable, as highway authorities owe no private law duties to road users.
- It has a defence if it proves it took reasonable care to keep the road safe.Correct answer
- It is liable unless Gemma was cycling too fast for the conditions on that road.
- It is not liable, as Gemma must prove the authority was negligent in common law.
Section 41 of the Highways Act 1980 imposes a duty on the highway authority to maintain a highway maintainable at public expense, and a failure to do so is actionable by an injured road user without proof of negligence. However, section 58 provides a defence if the authority proves that it had taken such care as in all the circumstances was reasonably required to secure that the part of the highway was not dangerous for traffic. A reasonable inspection regime may satisfy this. The burden is on the authority, not on Gemma. Her own speed would be relevant to contributory negligence, not to the defence.
Law basis: Highways Act 1980 ss 41, 58 ↗Question 8 · Breach of statutory dutyDraft, pending solicitor review
A statute requires a water company to keep its pipes, to which fire hydrants are attached, charged with water at a specified pressure, and imposes a modest fine for breach. A fire breaks out at Dora's house, and firefighters cannot put it out because the pressure is too low. Dora sues the company for breach of statutory duty. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- It succeeds, as Dora's house was destroyed because the statutory duty was breached.
- It succeeds, as householders are a limited class protected by the statute.
- It fails, as Parliament did not intend liability to householders.Correct answer
- It fails, as a water company owes duties only to its paying customers.
- It succeeds, as the fine is payable to the Crown and is no remedy for Dora.
In Atkinson v Newcastle and Gateshead Waterworks Co the Court of Appeal held that the statutory duty to maintain water pressure was not actionable by a householder whose house burned down. The statute provided its own penalty, and Parliament could not have intended to make the company, in effect, an insurer against fire for every householder in its area. Whether a statutory breach gives a private right of action depends on Parliament's intention, read from the statute as a whole. Causation of loss by the breach is not enough, and the fact that the fine is not payable to the claimant is not decisive.
Law basis: Atkinson v Newcastle and Gateshead Waterworks Co (1877) 2 Ex D 441More Tort Law topics
Back to all Tort Law questions, or sit a timed mock.