A colliery company appoints a fully qualified and competent manager and leaves him to organise a safe system of work underground, as it is required to do. The manager negligently allows haulage to run during a shift change, and Wyn, a miner, is crushed. The company argues that it discharged its duty by appointing a competent manager. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The company is liable, as an employer's personal duty of safety cannot be delegated.Correct answer
- The company is not liable, as it took reasonable care in appointing a competent manager.
- The company is liable only if the manager was not an employee but a contractor.
- The company is not liable, as the manager is personally liable instead of the company.
- The company is liable only if it knew that haulage would run during the shift change.
In Wilsons & Clyde Coal Co Ltd v English the House of Lords held that an employer's duty to provide competent staff, adequate plant and equipment, a safe place of work and a safe system of work is personal and non-delegable. The employer may delegate the performance of the duty, but remains liable if it is not properly performed, however competent the person chosen. Appointing a competent manager is therefore not a defence. The manager may also be liable, and the employer may also be vicariously liable, but those are separate routes. Actual knowledge of the specific danger is not required.
Law basis: Wilsons & Clyde Coal Co Ltd v English [1938] AC 57