Fern agreed to buy a lorry from Grove Motors, the order form stating that 'the balance of the purchase price can be had on hire-purchase terms over two years'. No hire-purchase company was named and hire-purchase terms varied widely in the market. Grove later refused to deliver, and Fern sued. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a contract, because the court will imply standard hire-purchase terms.
- There is no contract, because the hire-purchase term was too vague.Correct answer
- There is a contract, because the price and the subject matter were agreed.
- There is no contract, because sales of vehicles require a written contract of sale.
- There is a contract, but Fern must pay the full price on delivery instead.
A contract will fail for uncertainty where an essential term is so vague that the court cannot give it a definite meaning. Since hire-purchase arrangements varied widely in their terms, the words 'on hire-purchase terms' could not be given a precise meaning, and there was no usual form to imply. No contract was concluded. The tempting answer has the court imply terms, but the court will not make a contract for the parties where they have not agreed an essential term in sufficiently certain language.
Law basis: G Scammell and Nephew Ltd v Ouston [1941] AC 251