Law covered in these questions
- Sky Petroleum Ltd v VIP Petroleum Ltd [1974] 1 WLR 576
- Cohen v Roche [1927] 1 KB 169
- Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 52
- Co-operative Insurance Society Ltd v Argyll Stores (Holdings) Ltd [1998] AC 1
- Warner Bros Pictures Inc v Nelson [1937] 1 KB 209
- Senior Courts Act 1981, s 50
- Attorney General v Blake [2001] 1 AC 268
- Cavendish Square Holding BV v Makdessi [2015] UKSC 67
- ParkingEye Ltd v Beavis [2015] UKSC 67
- Triple Point Technology Inc v PTT Public Co Ltd [2021] UKSC 29
- Fibrosa Spolka Akcyjna v Fairbairn Lawson Combe Barbour Ltd [1943] AC 32
- Workers Trust and Merchant Bank Ltd v Dojap Investments Ltd [1993] AC 573
- FSHC Group Holdings Ltd v GLAS Trust Corp Ltd [2019] EWCA Civ 1361
- Limitation Act 1980, ss 5 and 8
All 14 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
During a national fuel shortage, Kix Garages had a long-term contract with Lux Petroleum for all its petrol. Lux, wrongly claiming Kix was in breach, stopped supplies. No other supplier would take on a new customer, and without petrol Kix would have to close. Kix seeks an interim injunction requiring Lux to continue supplying. Which of the following best describes the position?
- An injunction will be refused, because petrol is not unique goods.
- An injunction may be granted only if Kix pays the whole contract price upfront.
- An injunction will be refused, because it would amount to specific performance.
- An injunction may be granted, as damages would not be an adequate remedy.Correct answer
- An injunction will be refused, because Kix can always claim damages later.
Specific performance, and injunctions having a similar effect, are not normally ordered for the sale of commercially available goods, because damages are adequate. But that is not an absolute rule. Where, as in a supply crisis, the claimant cannot obtain substitute goods and would be forced out of business, damages are inadequate and an injunction restraining the supplier from withholding supplies may be granted. The court granted such an injunction in a case on similar facts. The tempting answer treats the non-unique nature of petrol as decisive.
Law basis: Sky Petroleum Ltd v VIP Petroleum Ltd [1974] 1 WLR 576Question 2 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mira bought a set of eight Hepplewhite-style chairs at auction from Noah. They were of a type readily available from dealers and had no special features. Noah refused to deliver them. Mira wants an order requiring Noah to hand over the chairs. Which of the following best describes the court's likely response?
- It will order delivery, because a buyer of specific goods is always entitled to them.
- It will award damages only, as the chairs are ordinary articles of commerce.Correct answer
- It will order delivery, because the chairs were bought at auction.
- It will award nominal damages only, because the price was low.
- It will order delivery, provided Mira pays the price into court first.
Specific performance is a discretionary remedy granted only where damages would be inadequate. For the sale of goods, the court may order delivery of specific or ascertained goods, but it will not do so where they are ordinary articles of commerce of no special value or interest, as damages enable the buyer to buy equivalent goods. The chairs were readily available, so Mira's remedy is damages. The tempting answer treats specific goods as automatically attracting the remedy, but the court retains its discretion.
Law basis: Cohen v Roche [1927] 1 KB 169; Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 52 ↗Question 3 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ora Stores was the anchor tenant of a shopping centre under a lease with a covenant to keep its supermarket open during usual hours. The store was losing money, and Ora closed it, in breach of covenant. The landlord sought specific performance to compel Ora to reopen and keep trading for the remaining 19 years. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The order will be granted, because damages are hard to quantify.
- The order will be granted, because Ora acted deliberately in closing.
- The order will be refused, as courts do not compel trading.Correct answer
- The order will be refused, because covenants in leases are never enforceable.
- The order will be granted for a limited period of three years.
The House of Lords held that, save in exceptional circumstances, specific performance will not be ordered to compel a party to carry on a business. Such an order would require constant supervision by the court, could lead to repeated applications for contempt, and would force a defendant to run a business at a loss, causing it greater hardship than the claimant's loss from the breach. The landlord was left to its claim for damages. The tempting answer focuses on the difficulty of quantifying loss, which does not outweigh these considerations.
Law basis: Co-operative Insurance Society Ltd v Argyll Stores (Holdings) Ltd [1998] AC 1Question 4 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Pia, a famous actor, contracted to act exclusively for Quad Films for a period, and not to act for any other studio. In breach, she agreed to make films for a rival. Quad seeks an injunction restraining her from acting for anyone else during the contract. Pia argues that such an injunction would effectively force her to work for Quad. Which of the following best describes the position?
- An injunction may be granted to stop her acting for other studios.Correct answer
- The injunction will be refused, as it would amount to compelling personal service.
- The injunction will be refused, because negative covenants are never enforced.
- Specific performance will be ordered requiring Pia to act for Quad.
- An injunction will be granted preventing Pia from working in any capacity.
The court will not order specific performance of a contract of personal service, but it may enforce an express negative covenant by injunction, provided this does not in effect compel performance of the positive obligations. An injunction restraining Pia from acting for any other studio was granted in a case on similar facts, because she could still earn a living in other ways. The court would not prohibit her from working in any capacity, since that would effectively force her to perform. The tempting answer treats any such injunction as compelling service.
Law basis: Warner Bros Pictures Inc v Nelson [1937] 1 KB 209Question 5 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Raf agreed to buy a house from Sia. Sia refused to complete, and Raf sought specific performance in the High Court. Owing to exceptional hardship that the order would cause Sia, the court decided not to grant specific performance. Raf argues that, as he sued only for specific performance, he will be left with no remedy. Which of the following best describes the court's power?
- The court cannot award damages, because Raf did not claim them separately.
- The court may award damages in substitution for specific performance.Correct answer
- The court must grant specific performance, as land is always unique.
- The court can award damages only if Raf starts fresh proceedings.
- The court cannot award damages, because Sia acted in good faith.
Where the High Court has jurisdiction to entertain an application for specific performance or an injunction, it may award damages in addition to, or in substitution for, that remedy. Specific performance is discretionary and may be refused for reasons such as severe hardship, but the court can still compensate the claimant by damages in lieu. The tempting answer assumes the claimant is left without a remedy because damages were not separately claimed. Although land is treated as unique, that does not make specific performance automatic.
Law basis: Senior Courts Act 1981, s 50 ↗Question 6 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Tam, a former intelligence officer, signed an undertaking not to disclose official information. After defecting abroad he wrote an autobiography in breach of that undertaking. His publisher still owed him substantial royalties. The Crown could show no financial loss, so ordinary damages would be nominal. The Crown seeks the royalties. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The Crown recovers nominal damages only, because it suffered no financial loss.
- The Crown recovers nothing, because the undertaking was not a contract.
- The Crown recovers the royalties, because profits are always recoverable for breach.
- The Crown may obtain an account of profits in this exceptional case.Correct answer
- The Crown recovers a reasonable licence fee for the use of the information.
The House of Lords held that, in exceptional circumstances, where the normal remedies are inadequate and the claimant has a legitimate interest in preventing the defendant's profit-making activity, the court may order the defendant to account for the profits made from a breach of contract. The Crown had such an interest in the confidentiality of intelligence work, and damages would be nominal, so an account of the royalties was ordered. The tempting answer states that profits are always recoverable, but the remedy is exceptional.
Law basis: Attorney General v Blake [2001] 1 AC 268Question 7 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Uri sold a controlling stake in his advertising business to Vero plc. The contract provided that, if Uri breached his non-compete covenants, he would not receive the final instalments of the price and Vero could buy his remaining shares at a price excluding goodwill. Uri breached the covenants and argues that the clauses are unenforceable penalties. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clauses are enforceable, as they protect a legitimate interest.Correct answer
- The clauses are penalties, because they exceed a genuine pre-estimate of loss.
- The clauses are penalties, because any payment triggered by breach is penal.
- The clauses are enforceable, because penalties are allowed between businesses.
- The clauses are penalties, because they deprive Uri of the price he bargained for.
The Supreme Court restated the penalty rule: the test is whether the provision is a secondary obligation which imposes a detriment on the contract-breaker out of all proportion to any legitimate interest of the innocent party in the enforcement of the primary obligation. The buyer had a legitimate interest in protecting the goodwill it had paid for, and the clauses, negotiated by advised parties, were not out of proportion to that interest. They were enforceable. The tempting answer applies the older 'genuine pre-estimate of loss' test, which is no longer decisive.
Law basis: Cavendish Square Holding BV v Makdessi [2015] UKSC 67Question 8 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Wade parked in a retail park car park managed by Xanth Parking. Large signs stated that parking was free for two hours, after which an £85 charge applied. Wade stayed for almost three hours. Xanth suffered no financial loss from his overstay, as it was paid by the landowner. Wade argues that the £85 charge is an unenforceable penalty. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The charge is a penalty, because Xanth suffered no financial loss.
- The charge is a penalty, because consumers cannot be charged for breach.
- The charge is a penalty, because it is higher than the cost of enforcement.
- The charge is enforceable only if Wade agreed to it in writing.
- The charge is enforceable, as it serves a legitimate interest.Correct answer
A clause is not a penalty merely because it exceeds the innocent party's financial loss. The question is whether it is out of all proportion to a legitimate interest in performance. The Supreme Court held that a parking charge of £85 served legitimate interests of the operator and the landowner in managing the efficient use of parking spaces, and was not extravagant or unconscionable. It was also not unfair under consumer protection legislation. The tempting answer insists on a financial loss, which the court held is not required.
Law basis: ParkingEye Ltd v Beavis [2015] UKSC 67Question 9 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Yael Ltd engaged Zinc Systems to develop software, with liquidated damages of £1,000 for each day of delay until the work was accepted. Zinc fell behind, and after 150 days of delay, Yael lawfully terminated the contract. The work was never completed or accepted. Zinc argues that the liquidated damages clause does not apply because the work was never accepted. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause does not apply, because it was triggered only by acceptance.
- The clause does not apply, so Yael must prove all its losses as general damages.
- Liquidated damages accrue up to termination, with general damages thereafter.Correct answer
- Liquidated damages accrue until a replacement contractor completes the work.
- The clause applies only if the contractor completes the work for another party.
The Supreme Court held that, unless the contract clearly provides otherwise, liquidated damages for delay accrue up to the date of termination, even though the work is never completed or accepted. After termination, the employer recovers general damages for losses caused by the contractor's failure to complete. It would be commercially unrealistic to deny the employer the liquidated damages that had already accrued for delay. Yael therefore recovers liquidated damages for the 150 days. The tempting answer, which reflected the Court of Appeal's view, was rejected.
Law basis: Triple Point Technology Inc v PTT Public Co Ltd [2021] UKSC 29Question 10 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
In July, Ari, a Polish company, ordered machinery from Bo Ltd, an English company, paying £1,000 in advance. In September, war broke out and Poland was occupied, frustrating the contract before any machinery was made. Bo had done some work. Ari claims return of the £1,000. The case arose before the Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ari recovers nothing, because losses on frustration lie where they fall.
- Ari recovers the £1,000, as there was a total failure of consideration.Correct answer
- Ari recovers the £1,000 less the value of the work Bo had done.
- Ari recovers nothing, because the contract was frustrated, not breached.
- Ari recovers half the £1,000, reflecting the equal sharing of loss.
Money paid under a contract can be recovered where there has been a total failure of consideration, meaning the payer has received none of the performance it bargained for. The House of Lords held that, although the contract had been frustrated, the buyer had received nothing it bargained for, as no machinery had been delivered, so it could recover the advance. Work done by the seller did not count, because the consideration was delivery of the machines, not work on them. The rule that losses lie where they fall was rejected for this situation. Statute now applies.
Law basis: Fibrosa Spolka Akcyjna v Fairbairn Lawson Combe Barbour Ltd [1943] AC 32Question 11 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Cal bought a property at auction from Dojo Bank, paying a 25% deposit as required by the conditions. The customary deposit in the local market was 10%. Cal failed to complete on time and the bank forfeited the whole deposit, although its actual loss was much smaller. Cal claims the deposit back. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The bank keeps the whole deposit, because deposits can always be forfeited.
- The bank keeps 25%, because Cal agreed to the auction conditions.
- The deposit is repayable, subject to the bank's actual loss.Correct answer
- The deposit is repayable in full, with no allowance for the bank's loss.
- The bank keeps the whole deposit, because Cal was in breach of a condition.
A true deposit, being an earnest of performance, can be forfeited on the purchaser's default without being treated as a penalty. But this exception applies only to reasonable deposits. The Privy Council held that a deposit above the customary 10% must be justified by special circumstances, otherwise it is a penalty. As no such justification existed, the 25% deposit was not a true deposit, and the purchaser was entitled to its return, subject to the vendor's claim for damages for its actual loss. The tempting answer treats deposits as always forfeitable.
Law basis: Workers Trust and Merchant Bank Ltd v Dojap Investments Ltd [1993] AC 573Question 12 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Eko Group entered into a deed of accession to a security arrangement. Both parties believed, mistakenly, that the deed was required to fulfil an existing obligation, but in fact it created new and onerous obligations that neither intended. Their shared understanding was evident from their correspondence. Eko seeks rectification. Which of the following best describes the test for rectification for common mistake?
- Whether the document fails to record what the parties actually intended to agree.Correct answer
- Whether a reasonable observer would have thought the parties had agreed something else.
- Whether the outcome is commercially unreasonable for one party.
- Whether one party knew the document contained a mistake when it signed.
- Whether the document contains an obvious typographical error.
The Court of Appeal held that rectification for common mistake requires proof that, when the document was executed, it failed to give effect to a prior concluded contract, or that both parties had a common intention, subjectively held and outwardly expressed, which the document failed to record. An objective test of what a reasonable observer would have understood was rejected. In the case itself, rectification was granted on that basis. The tempting answer adopts the objective approach suggested in earlier obiter dicta. The unilateral mistake test, involving knowledge, is different.
Law basis: FSHC Group Holdings Ltd v GLAS Trust Corp Ltd [2019] EWCA Civ 1361Question 13 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Fia contracted with Gil, in a simple written contract not made as a deed, to install industrial flooring. The flooring was defective from installation in March 2018, but the defect only became apparent in June 2023. Fia issued a claim for breach of contract in May 2025. Gil argues that the claim is time-barred. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The claim is in time, because time runs from when Fia discovered the defect.
- The claim is time-barred, because three years ran from discovery in 2023.
- The claim is in time, because the limitation period for contract is 12 years.
- The claim is time-barred, as six years ran from the date of breach in 2018.Correct answer
- The claim is in time, because latent defects extend time for all contract claims.
An action founded on simple contract cannot be brought after six years from the date on which the cause of action accrued. In contract, the cause of action accrues on breach, not when loss is discovered. The breach occurred on installation in March 2018, so the period expired in March 2024 and the claim is time-barred. The 12-year period applies to actions on a specialty such as a deed. The special latent damage provisions extend time for negligence actions, not for claims framed in contract, which is why the discovery-based answers are wrong.
Law basis: Limitation Act 1980, ss 5 and 8 ↗Question 14 · Equitable and other remediesDraft, pending solicitor review
Hale Steel sent a letter of intent to Ion Engineering asking it to start making steel nodes urgently, pending a formal contract. Ion made and delivered the nodes, but the parties never agreed key terms such as price and liability for late delivery, and no contract was concluded. Ion claims payment. Hale counterclaims damages for late delivery. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ion recovers nothing, because there was no contract under which payment was due.
- Ion recovers nothing, because the letter of intent was not an offer.
- Ion recovers the price stated in its last quotation under the letter of intent.
- Ion recovers a reasonable sum, but less Hale's damages for late delivery.
- Ion recovers a reasonable sum, and Hale's counterclaim fails.Correct answer
Where work is done at the request of another in anticipation of a contract that is never concluded, the party doing the work may recover a reasonable sum on a quantum meruit, a restitutionary claim, rather than under a contract. The court held that no contract had been formed because essential terms were never agreed, so the steel company was liable to pay a reasonable sum for the nodes. Because there was no contract, there were no contractual obligations as to delivery dates, and the counterclaim for late delivery failed.
Law basis: British Steel Corp v Cleveland Bridge and Engineering Co Ltd [1984] 1 All ER 504More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.