Law covered in these questions
- Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130
- Combe v Combe [1951] 2 KB 215
- D & C Builders Ltd v Rees [1966] 2 QB 617
- Tool Metal Manufacturing Co Ltd v Tungsten Electric Co Ltd [1955] 1 WLR 761
- Hughes v Metropolitan Railway Co (1877) 2 App Cas 439
- Woodhouse AC Israel Cocoa Ltd SA v Nigerian Produce Marketing Co Ltd [1972] AC 741
- Société Italo-Belge pour le Commerce et l'Industrie SA v Palm and Vegetable Oils (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd (The Post Chaser) [1982] 1 All ER 19
- Thorner v Major [2009] UKHL 18
All 8 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Promissory estoppelDraft, pending solicitor review
In 1940 Xavier let a block of flats to Yarrow Ltd at £2,500 a year. Because many flats were empty during wartime, Xavier agreed in writing to reduce the rent to £1,250. Yarrow paid the reduced rent. In 1945, when the flats were full again, Xavier's receiver claimed the full rent for the last two quarters of 1945 and also for the war years. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The receiver can recover the full rent for all periods, because the reduction was unsupported by consideration.
- The receiver cannot recover any extra rent, because the reduction was permanent.
- The receiver can recover the full rent only from when the wartime conditions ended.Correct answer
- The receiver can recover the full rent for the war years, but not for 1945.
- The receiver cannot recover, because the reduced rent was agreed in writing.
Promissory estoppel prevents a party who has made a clear promise not to enforce its strict rights, intending it to be relied on, from going back on that promise where it would be inequitable to do so. The reduction was intended to apply while wartime conditions lasted. Once the flats were fully let, the reason for the promise ended and full rent was again payable, but Xavier could not claim arrears for the period during which the promise operated. The tempting answer ignores the estoppel because the reduction lacked consideration.
Law basis: Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130Question 2 · Promissory estoppelDraft, pending solicitor review
On their divorce, Zack promised his former wife Amy £100 a year maintenance. She did not apply to the court for maintenance, but that was her own choice and not at his request. Zack never paid. Amy, who had a higher income than Zack, sued to enforce his promise, relying on promissory estoppel. Which of the following best describes the position?
- She will succeed, because she relied on the promise by not applying for maintenance.
- She will fail, because promissory estoppel cannot be used to found a cause of action.Correct answer
- She will succeed, because a promise made on divorce is presumed to be legally binding.
- She will fail, because a promise of maintenance must always be made in a deed.
- She will succeed, but only for the arrears accrued before she remarried.
Promissory estoppel operates as a shield and not as a sword: it may prevent a party from enforcing existing rights, but it cannot create a new cause of action where none exists. Amy gave no consideration, since she did not refrain from applying to court at Zack's request, so she had no contract on which to sue. Her claim, which relied on estoppel to found the action, fails. The tempting answer focuses on reliance, but reliance cannot replace consideration where the claimant is suing on the promise.
Law basis: Combe v Combe [1951] 2 KB 215Question 3 · Promissory estoppelDraft, pending solicitor review
Builders Ben and Cal completed work for Dora worth £482. Dora knew they were in financial difficulty and told them she would pay only £300, adding that if they refused they would get nothing. Desperate, they accepted a cheque for £300 'in completion of the account'. They now sue for the balance. Dora relies on promissory estoppel. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Dora's defence fails, because it would not be inequitable for the builders to resile.Correct answer
- Dora's defence succeeds, because the builders voluntarily accepted the cheque in settlement.
- Dora's defence succeeds, because payment by cheque is different from payment in cash.
- Dora's defence fails, because promissory estoppel never applies to the payment of debts.
- Dora's defence succeeds, because the builders' promise was put in writing.
Promissory estoppel is an equitable doctrine, so the promisee must have acted equitably. Dora deliberately exploited the builders' financial difficulty, and their agreement to take less was obtained by intimidation. It was therefore not inequitable for them to go back on their promise, and Dora cannot rely on estoppel. The builders can recover the balance. The suggestion that payment by cheque was different consideration was rejected: a cheque is treated like cash for this purpose. Estoppel can apply to debts, but not on these facts.
Law basis: D & C Builders Ltd v Rees [1966] 2 QB 617Question 4 · Promissory estoppelDraft, pending solicitor review
Ess Ltd licensed its patents to Fax Ltd, which agreed to pay compensation on certain sales. During the war Ess agreed to suspend the compensation. After the war, Ess gave Fax clear notice that compensation would again be payable, and Fax was given time to adjust its business. Ess now claims compensation for sales after the notice period. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ess cannot claim, because its waiver of compensation was permanent once relied upon.
- Ess cannot claim, because it gave no consideration for resuming its rights.
- Ess cannot claim, because promissory estoppel extinguishes rights it covers forever.
- Ess can claim both the future sums and those waived during the war years.
- Ess can claim, because a promisor may resume strict rights after reasonable notice.Correct answer
Promissory estoppel is generally suspensory in relation to continuing obligations. A promisor who has suspended its rights can resume them for the future by giving reasonable notice, giving the promisee a reasonable opportunity to resume its position. Ess gave clear notice and Fax had time to adjust, so Ess can claim compensation for sales after the notice period, but not for the suspended period. The tempting answer treats estoppel as extinguishing the rights permanently, which is not the usual effect for periodic payments.
Law basis: Tool Metal Manufacturing Co Ltd v Tungsten Electric Co Ltd [1955] 1 WLR 761Question 5 · Promissory estoppelDraft, pending solicitor review
A landlord served notice on a tenant requiring repairs within six months, failing which the lease could be forfeited. A month later the landlord began negotiations to buy the tenant's lease, and the tenant held off repairs while talks continued. When the talks failed, the landlord sought forfeiture as soon as the six months had expired. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The landlord can forfeit, because the six-month period was fixed and had expired.
- The landlord can forfeit, because the tenant gave no consideration for any extension.
- The landlord cannot forfeit, because the repair period was suspended during negotiations.Correct answer
- The landlord cannot forfeit, because notice to repair can never be followed by forfeiture.
- The landlord can forfeit, but only after obtaining the tenant's agreement in writing.
Where one party, by its conduct, leads the other to believe that strict rights will not be enforced, or will be held in suspense, it cannot enforce them where it would be inequitable to do so, having regard to the dealings between them. The landlord's entry into negotiations led the tenant to believe that the repairs requirement was suspended. The six months therefore ran only from the end of the negotiations, and forfeiture was premature. The tempting answer insists on consideration for any extension, which the doctrine does not require.
Law basis: Hughes v Metropolitan Railway Co (1877) 2 App Cas 439Question 6 · Promissory estoppelDraft, pending solicitor review
Gula Ltd agreed to sell cocoa to Harl Ltd, the price payable in Nigerian pounds. Harl later wrote that it would accept payment 'in sterling', which was ambiguous because it could mean either currency of account or currency of payment. When sterling was devalued, Harl claimed the difference. Gula relied on promissory estoppel. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Gula succeeds, because it relied on Harl's letter in making payment in sterling.
- Gula fails, because promissory estoppel never applies to payment of a contract price.
- Gula succeeds, because estoppel applies to any statement made in commercial dealings.
- Gula fails, because a promise relied on for estoppel must be clear and unequivocal.Correct answer
- Gula succeeds, because Harl's letter was a contractual variation of the price term.
For promissory estoppel to arise, the promise or representation must be clear and unequivocal. A statement capable of two reasonable meanings will not suffice. Harl's letter was ambiguous as to whether sterling was to replace the currency of account or merely the currency of payment, so it could not found an estoppel. Gula's defence fails. The tempting answer focuses on Gula's reliance, but reliance on an ambiguous statement does not make it binding. The letter was not a variation because no consideration was given.
Law basis: Woodhouse AC Israel Cocoa Ltd SA v Nigerian Produce Marketing Co Ltd [1972] AC 741Question 7 · Promissory estoppelDraft, pending solicitor review
Jett Ltd, sellers of palm oil, were required to declare a ship to their buyer, Ian, within a reasonable time. Jett declared late, and Ian made no complaint. Two days later Jett presented shipping documents to Ian, who then rejected them on the basis of the late declaration. Jett argues Ian is estopped by his silence from relying on the lateness. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ian is estopped, because his silence was a clear representation that he waived lateness.
- Ian is estopped, because estoppel arises from any reliance however short in time.
- Ian is not estopped, because the brief reliance did not make it inequitable to resile.Correct answer
- Ian is not estopped, because estoppel requires the promisee to suffer financial loss.
- Ian is estopped, because a buyer's failure to object to a late declaration is a waiver.
Promissory estoppel requires a clear and unequivocal representation and reliance making it inequitable for the representor to go back on it. Detriment in a strict sense is not essential, but the promisee must have altered its position so that it would be inequitable to allow the promisor to resile. In the leading case, reliance for only two days did not cause any real prejudice, so there was no inequity. Ian's silence may have been a representation, but Jett's reliance for two days caused no real prejudice. The tempting answer treats any reliance as enough.
Law basis: Société Italo-Belge pour le Commerce et l'Industrie SA v Palm and Vegetable Oils (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd (The Post Chaser) [1982] 1 All ER 19Question 8 · Promissory estoppelDraft, pending solicitor review
For 30 years, Kip worked unpaid on his cousin Lev's farm. Lev never expressly promised the farm, but by repeated conduct and remarks led Kip to believe it would pass to him, and Kip relied on that belief. Lev died without a will. Kip wants to claim the farm. He is told that promissory estoppel cannot be used as a cause of action. Which of the following best describes Kip's position?
- He has no claim, because estoppel can only ever be raised as a defence.
- He may claim through proprietary estoppel, which can found a cause of action.Correct answer
- He has no claim, because Lev never made an express promise about the farm.
- He may claim under promissory estoppel, because his reliance lasted for many years.
- He has no claim, because any promise relating to land must be made in writing.
Promissory estoppel cannot found a cause of action, but proprietary estoppel, which concerns assurances about interests in land, can. It requires an assurance, reasonable reliance and detriment. An assurance need not be express; it must be clear enough in context and may be inferred from conduct and remarks over time. Kip's long unpaid work in reliance on Lev's assurances could support a claim. The tempting answer applies the 'shield not sword' rule, which belongs to promissory estoppel. The statutory formality rule for land contracts does not bar proprietary estoppel.
Law basis: Thorner v Major [2009] UKHL 18More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.