Law covered in these questions
- Re McArdle [1951] Ch 669
- Roscorla v Thomas (1842) 3 QB 234
- Lampleigh v Brailsford (1615) Hob 105 (exception, not met)
- Williams v Roffey Bros & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd [1991] 1 QB 1
- Stilk v Myrick (1809) 2 Camp 317
- Re Selectmove Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 474 (limit: part payment of debts)
- Thomas v Thomas (1842) 2 QB 851
- Chappell & Co Ltd v Nestlé Co Ltd [1960] AC 87
- Pao On v Lau Yiu Long [1980] AC 614
- Lampleigh v Brathwait (1615) Hob 105
- Collins v Godefroy (1831) 1 B & Ad 950
- Glasbrook Bros Ltd v Glamorgan CC [1925] AC 270
- Scotson v Pegg (1861) 6 H & N 295
- Foakes v Beer (1884) 9 App Cas 605
All 16 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Carl, without being asked, cleared the gutters of his neighbour Dee's house while she was on holiday. When she returned, Dee orally promised to pay him £100 for his trouble but later refused to pay. Which statement best describes whether Carl can enforce Dee's promise?
- Carl can enforce it, because Dee received a real benefit from his work.
- Carl can enforce it, because a voluntary promise to pay for services already rendered is always binding.
- Carl cannot enforce it, because his work was done before the promise and was not requested by Dee, so the consideration is past.Correct answer
- Carl cannot enforce it, because contractual promises are enforceable only if made in writing.
- Carl cannot enforce it, because a promise to pay money is enforceable only if made in a deed.
Consideration must move from the promisee in exchange for the promise. Work done earlier and without request is past consideration, and the narrow exception for services requested beforehand does not apply. A deed or writing is not the issue, and benefit to the promisor is not enough.
Law basis: Re McArdle [1951] Ch 669; Roscorla v Thomas (1842) 3 QB 234; Lampleigh v Brailsford (1615) Hob 105 (exception, not met)Question 2 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Bright Builders Ltd had a main contract to refurbish 20 flats and sub-contracted the carpentry to Tom for £20,000. After finishing 10 flats Tom ran into financial difficulty. Bright, fearing Tom would not finish and that it would face a penalty under its main contract, promised him an extra £4,000 to complete. Tom did not threaten Bright, and there was no duress or fraud. Tom completed the work. Bright refuses to pay the extra £4,000. Which statement best describes the position?
- Bright is not bound, because performing an existing contractual duty can never amount to consideration.
- Bright is not bound, unless Tom did something beyond his existing obligation that gave Bright a legal benefit.
- Bright is bound only if its promise to pay the extra £4,000 was made in a deed.
- Bright is bound, because a promise to pay more in a commercial contract needs no consideration.
- Bright is bound, because it obtained a practical benefit from Tom's performance and there was no duress or fraud, so its promise is supported by consideration.Correct answer
A promise to pay more for performance of an existing duty can be supported by a practical benefit to the promisor, where there is no economic duress or fraud and the promisor had reason to doubt the other party's performance. The rigid rule that existing duty is never consideration no longer governs this situation.
Law basis: Williams v Roffey Bros & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd [1991] 1 QB 1; Stilk v Myrick (1809) 2 Camp 317; Re Selectmove Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 474 (limit: part payment of debts)Question 3 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Before he died, Arthur told his executors he wanted his widow Bea to live in the family home for life. The executors agreed in writing to let her stay, in consideration of Arthur's wishes and her promise to pay £1 a year towards the ground rent and keep the house in repair. The executors later sought possession, saying her promise was inadequate consideration. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The agreement is unenforceable, because £1 a year is far below the house's market rent.
- The agreement is enforceable only if Bea can show the executors acted in bad faith.
- The agreement is unenforceable, because Arthur's wishes were the true reason for it.
- The agreement is enforceable, because Bea's promises were sufficient consideration.Correct answer
- The agreement is unenforceable, because a lease for life must be made by deed.
Consideration must be sufficient in law but need not be adequate: the court will not weigh whether the bargain is a good one. Bea's promise to pay £1 a year and keep the house in repair had economic value and was given in return for the executors' promise, so it was sufficient consideration. Arthur's wishes were the motive, not the consideration, and motive is irrelevant. The tempting answer measures the payment against market rent, but the law does not require consideration to match the value of what is received.
Law basis: Thomas v Thomas (1842) 2 QB 851Question 4 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Crisp Ltd ran a promotion offering a music single for 75p plus three wrappers from its chocolate bars. The wrappers themselves were thrown away on receipt. In a dispute about royalties, it became relevant whether the wrappers formed part of the consideration for the sale of the records. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The wrappers were consideration, because they were part of what was bargained for.Correct answer
- The wrappers were not consideration, because they had no value and were discarded.
- The wrappers were not consideration, because consideration must be money or money's worth.
- The wrappers were consideration only if the buyer bought the chocolate bars personally.
- The wrappers were not consideration, because they benefited Crisp only indirectly.
Consideration need not be adequate and can consist of something of trivial value, provided it is what the promisor has asked for in exchange for its promise. Crisp required the wrappers because the promotion was designed to increase chocolate sales, so they were part of the bargain and part of the consideration. That Crisp threw them away did not matter. The tempting answer equates consideration with economic value to the promisor, but the House of Lords held that a contracting party can stipulate for what it likes.
Law basis: Chappell & Co Ltd v Nestlé Co Ltd [1960] AC 87Question 5 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
At the request of Dorian, the owner of a recording studio, Elsa, a sound engineer, worked three weekends repairing Dorian's mixing desks. Both understood she would be paid, but no amount was agreed. A month after the work was finished, Dorian promised to pay Elsa £1,500. He has now refused to pay. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Elsa cannot recover, because her work was past consideration for Dorian's promise.
- Elsa cannot recover, because there was no agreement on price when she did the work.
- Elsa can recover, because her work was requested and both expected payment.Correct answer
- Elsa can recover, but only a reasonable sum rather than the £1,500 promised.
- Elsa cannot recover, because Dorian's later promise was a gratuitous gift.
Past consideration is generally no consideration, but an act done before a promise can support it where the act was done at the promisor's request, both parties understood it would be paid for, and payment would have been legally enforceable had it been promised in advance. Elsa worked at Dorian's request, both expected payment and a payment promise would have been enforceable, so the later promise fixes the amount. The tempting answer applies the general past consideration rule without considering this established exception.
Law basis: Pao On v Lau Yiu Long [1980] AC 614; Lampleigh v Brathwait (1615) Hob 105Question 6 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Faisal was served with a witness summons to give evidence in a civil trial. The claimant, Greta, worried that Faisal might not turn up, promised to pay him £500 for attending court. Faisal attended and gave evidence as required by the summons, but Greta refused to pay. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Faisal can recover, because attending court cost him time and was a detriment.
- Faisal cannot recover, because he was already under a public duty to attend.Correct answer
- Faisal can recover, because Greta obtained a practical benefit from his attendance.
- Faisal cannot recover, because promises relating to litigation are always void.
- Faisal can recover only his travel expenses, because the £500 was excessive.
Performing a duty that one is already bound by law to perform is not good consideration for a promise. Faisal was legally compelled to attend court by the witness summons, so his attendance gave Greta nothing beyond what the law already required of him. He cannot enforce her promise. The practical benefit principle is tempting, but it was developed for existing contractual duties owed to the promisor, not public duties imposed by law. Had Faisal done more than the summons required, the result might differ.
Law basis: Collins v Godefroy (1831) 1 B & Ad 950Question 7 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
During a miners' strike, Hollin Collieries asked the police to station officers on its premises rather than provide mobile patrols, which the police considered adequate to keep the peace. The police agreed, and the colliery promised to pay for the extra cover. It later refused to pay, arguing the police were only doing their public duty. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The colliery is not liable, because the police were acting under a public duty.
- The colliery is not liable, because the promise to pay was made under duress.
- The colliery is not liable, because public bodies cannot contract for their services.
- The colliery is liable only if the extra officers prevented actual damage to property.
- The colliery is liable, because the police provided more than their duty required.Correct answer
Performing an existing public duty is not consideration, but doing more than the duty requires is. The police were under a duty to protect the colliery but had judged that mobile patrols were enough. By stationing officers on site at the colliery's request, they went beyond their public duty, so that extra service was good consideration for the promise to pay. The tempting answer treats all police protection as part of the public duty, but the House of Lords focused on what the duty actually required.
Law basis: Glasbrook Bros Ltd v Glamorgan CC [1925] AC 270Question 8 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Ira Shipping had contracted with Jago Ltd to deliver a cargo of coal to Kirk. Kirk, who wanted the coal unloaded quickly, promised Ira that if it delivered the coal to him he would unload it at a fixed rate. Ira delivered as it was already bound to do under its contract with Jago. Kirk failed to unload at the agreed rate and argues Ira gave no consideration. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ira gave no consideration, because it was already bound to deliver the coal to Kirk.
- Ira gave consideration only if it incurred extra cost in delivering to Kirk.
- Ira gave no consideration, because Kirk received no practical benefit from delivery.
- Ira gave consideration, as performing a duty owed to a third party can suffice.Correct answer
- Ira gave no consideration, because Kirk was not a party to the contract with Jago.
Performance of, or a promise to perform, an existing contractual duty owed to a third party is good consideration for a fresh promise from another person. Ira's delivery was due under its contract with Jago, but it provided Kirk with a benefit and gave him a direct right, so it was consideration for Kirk's promise. The tempting answer applies the rule about existing duties owed to the promisor, but that rule does not apply where the duty is owed to someone else. Extra cost is not required.
Law basis: Scotson v Pegg (1861) 6 H & N 295; Pao On v Lau Yiu Long [1980] AC 614Question 9 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Lena obtained judgment against Mo for £20,000. They agreed in writing that if Mo paid £5,000 immediately and the rest by instalments, Lena would 'take no proceedings whatsoever on the judgment'. Mo paid everything. Lena now claims the interest that accrues on judgment debts, which the agreement did not mention. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Lena cannot claim interest, because her written promise to take no proceedings binds her.
- Lena can claim interest, because Mo gave no consideration for her promise to forgo it.Correct answer
- Lena cannot claim interest, because she received a practical benefit from instalment payment.
- Lena can claim interest only if she gave Mo reasonable notice before suing for it.
- Lena cannot claim interest, because judgment debts carry interest only if agreed.
Payment of a smaller sum than is due does not discharge the whole debt, because the debtor provides no consideration for the creditor's promise to accept less. Mo paid only what he already owed and nothing more, so Lena's promise not to claim interest was unsupported by consideration and she may recover it. The tempting answer relies on practical benefit, but the House of Lords' rule on part payment of debts has not been displaced by that principle, which the Court of Appeal has refused to extend to debts.
Law basis: Foakes v Beer (1884) 9 App Cas 605Question 10 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Nico owed Ola £6,000, due on 30 June at Ola's office in Leeds. At Ola's request, Nico paid her £5,000 on 1 May at her holiday home in Cornwall, and Ola agreed in writing to accept it in full satisfaction. Ola now sues for the remaining £1,000. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ola cannot recover, since early payment elsewhere was good consideration.Correct answer
- Ola can recover £1,000, because her promise was not made in the form of a deed.
- Ola can recover £1,000, because part payment never discharges a debt in full.
- Ola cannot recover, because she received a practical benefit from the payment.
- Ola can recover £1,000, because the change of place was for Nico's convenience.
Part payment of a debt does not discharge the whole, but the rule does not apply where, at the creditor's request, the debtor provides something different, such as payment before the due date or at a different place. That new element is consideration for the creditor's promise to accept less. Ola asked for early payment in Cornwall, so her promise is binding and she cannot sue for the balance. The tempting answer states the part payment rule absolutely and ignores these recognised exceptions.
Law basis: Pinnel's Case (1602) 5 Co Rep 117a; Foakes v Beer (1884) 9 App Cas 605Question 11 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Pellow Ltd owed HMRC substantial arrears of tax. Its managing director proposed paying future tax as it fell due and clearing the arrears by monthly instalments. An HMRC officer said he would revert if the proposal was unacceptable, but did not do so. HMRC later demanded the arrears in full. Pellow argues that HMRC obtained a practical benefit, so the agreement is binding. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The agreement binds HMRC, because receiving payment is a practical benefit to a creditor.
- The agreement binds HMRC, because its silence amounted to acceptance of the proposal.
- The agreement does not bind HMRC, because tax debts can never be paid by instalments.
- The agreement binds HMRC, because a public body must honour its officers' statements.
- The agreement does not bind HMRC, because practical benefit does not extend to debts.Correct answer
The Court of Appeal has held that the practical benefit principle, which allows a promise to pay more for existing performance to be enforced, cannot be extended to a promise to accept less than the amount of a debt. To do so would leave the House of Lords' rule on part payment of debts without effect. A promise to pay a debt by instalments is therefore not consideration for a creditor's promise to forgo its right to immediate payment. The officer also lacked authority to accept, but the consideration point is decisive.
Law basis: Re Selectmove Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 474Question 12 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Pia owed Quentin £1,200. Pia's father, Raj, offered Quentin £700 in full settlement of his daughter's debt, and Quentin accepted the cheque on that basis. Quentin now sues Pia for the remaining £500, arguing that part payment does not discharge a debt. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Quentin can recover £500, because Pia gave no consideration for his promise.
- Quentin can recover £500, because the rule in Pinnel's Case applies to all part payments.
- Quentin cannot recover, because suing would be a fraud on the third party who paid.Correct answer
- Quentin can recover £500, but only from Raj as the person who settled the debt.
- Quentin cannot recover, because Raj's payment was a gift which reduced the debt to nil.
Where a third party pays part of a debt on the basis that it is accepted in full settlement, and the creditor accepts it on that basis, the creditor cannot then sue the debtor for the balance. To allow the creditor to do so would be a fraud on the third party who paid on that understanding. Quentin's claim against Pia fails. The tempting answer applies the ordinary rule that part payment by the debtor does not discharge the debt, but the courts treat payment by a third party differently.
Law basis: Hirachand Punamchand v Temple [1911] 2 KB 330Question 13 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Sela believed in good faith that Tomas owed her £8,000 under a loan, though Tomas disputed it. Sela agreed not to sue Tomas in return for Tomas's promise to pay £5,000 in three months. Tomas did not pay. He now argues that the original loan claim would have failed, so Sela's forbearance was worthless. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Tomas need not pay, because the compromise was not recorded in a court order.
- Tomas need not pay, because forbearance to sue is valid only if the claim was sound.
- Tomas need not pay, because a promise not to sue is never sufficient consideration.
- Tomas must pay, but only the sum that Sela could have recovered on the loan.
- Tomas must pay, because forbearing to pursue a genuine claim is good consideration.Correct answer
A promise not to pursue a claim, or the compromise of a claim, is good consideration if the claim is made honestly and is not vexatious or frivolous, even if it would ultimately have failed. Sela believed in good faith that she was owed the money, so her forbearance was sufficient consideration for Tomas's promise. The tempting answer requires the claim to be legally sound, but that would undermine the settlement of disputes. A settlement is a binding contract without any need for a court order.
Law basis: Callisher v Bischoffsheim (1870) LR 5 QB 449Question 14 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Una and Victor separated, leaving their young daughter with Victor. Victor wrote to Una that she could have the child and £1 a week 'providing you can prove she will be well looked after and happy and allowed to decide for herself whether to live with you'. The child moved in with Una, who looked after her well, but Victor stopped paying. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Una can recover, but only if she took the child at Victor's request in writing.
- Una cannot recover, because she was already under a statutory duty to maintain her child.
- Una cannot recover, because arrangements between parents are not intended to be binding.
- Una can recover, because her conduct went beyond her legal duty and was consideration.Correct answer
- Una cannot recover, because a promise about a child's welfare is void for public policy.
Performance of an existing legal duty is not normally consideration, but doing more than that duty requires can be. Although Una had a duty to maintain the child, her promise to ensure the child was well looked after and happy and was allowed to choose where to live went beyond that duty, and was good consideration for Victor's promise. The tempting answer focuses on the existing statutory duty. The parties had separated, so the presumption against intention in domestic arrangements was not decisive.
Law basis: Ward v Byham [1956] 1 WLR 496Question 15 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
Wil had repeatedly complained to his father that he was treated less favourably than his siblings. His father promised to release Wil from a debt of £3,000 if Wil stopped complaining. Wil stopped complaining. After his father's death, the executors sued Wil for the debt. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Wil is liable, because giving up complaints he had no right to make is not consideration.Correct answer
- Wil is not liable, because his father's promise was a binding release of the debt.
- Wil is not liable, because he gave up something of value by ceasing to complain.
- Wil is not liable, because his father obtained a practical benefit of family peace.
- Wil is liable, because a promise to release a debt is only effective in his father's lifetime.
Consideration must have some value in the eye of the law. A son had no legal right to complain to his father, so his promise to stop complaining was not good consideration for the father's promise to release the debt. The executors can recover. The tempting answer treats any detriment or forgone conduct as consideration, but a promise to refrain from conduct one has no entitlement to pursue does not count. A release of a debt without consideration is ineffective unless made by deed.
Law basis: White v Bluett (1853) 23 LJ Ex 36Question 16 · ConsiderationDraft, pending solicitor review
A ship's crew of 36 signed on for a voyage. After 17 men deserted, the ship continued with only 19, making the voyage seriously dangerous. The master promised the remaining crew extra wages to sail the ship home. On arrival, the owners refused to pay the extra wages, relying on the rule that performing an existing contractual duty is not consideration. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The crew cannot recover, because they only did what their contract already required.
- The crew can recover, as the changed situation released them from their duties.Correct answer
- The crew cannot recover, because the master had no authority to vary their wages.
- The crew can recover, but only for the days after the desertions took place.
- The crew cannot recover, because the promise was made under economic duress.
Performing an existing contractual duty owed to the promisor is not normally consideration. However, where circumstances change so fundamentally that the original contract no longer binds, or performance becomes so different, the crew are free to refuse and their agreement to continue is good consideration. The reduction of the crew to about half made the voyage dangerous and discharged the sailors from their original obligations, so they could recover the extra wages. The tempting answer applies the existing duty rule without asking whether the duty still applied.
Law basis: Hartley v Ponsonby (1857) 7 E & B 872; contrast Stilk v Myrick (1809) 2 Camp 317More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.