Law covered in these questions
- Poussard v Spiers and Pond (1876) 1 QBD 410
- contrast Bettini v Gye (1876) 1 QBD 183
- Bettini v Gye (1876) 1 QBD 183
- Hongkong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd [1962] 2 QB 26
- Cehave NV v Bremer Handelsgesellschaft mbH (The Hansa Nord) [1976] QB 44
- Bunge Corp v Tradax Export SA [1981] 1 WLR 711
- L Schuler AG v Wickman Machine Tool Sales Ltd [1974] AC 235
- Lombard North Central plc v Butterworth [1987] QB 527
- Union Eagle Ltd v Golden Achievement Ltd [1997] AC 514
All 8 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Classification of termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Bria, a well-known singer, was engaged to sing the lead in an opera for a season. She fell ill and was unable to perform on the opening night and for the first few performances. The producers engaged a substitute for the whole season and told Bria her services were no longer required. Bria sues for wrongful dismissal. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Bria succeeds, because her illness was not her fault and so was not a breach.
- Bria fails, as her absence went to the root of the contract.Correct answer
- Bria succeeds, because her absence was a breach of warranty giving only damages.
- Bria fails, because a performer's absence for any reason ends the engagement.
- Bria succeeds, because the producers had to wait until she had recovered.
A condition is a term going to the root of the contract, breach of which entitles the innocent party to terminate. Failure to perform at the opening and the early performances of an opera was so serious that it went to the root of the contract, entitling the producers to treat it as at an end. In the leading case, the court held that the producers were justified in engaging a replacement. The contrast is with failing to attend preliminary rehearsals, which was held to be a breach of warranty only.
Law basis: Poussard v Spiers and Pond (1876) 1 QBD 410; contrast Bettini v Gye (1876) 1 QBD 183Question 2 · Classification of termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Cass, a singer, contracted to perform at concerts for a full season. The contract required her to attend rehearsals six days before the first concert. She arrived only two days before, but was ready to perform at every concert. The promoter refused to let her perform and treated the contract as ended. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The promoter was entitled to end the contract, because attendance at rehearsals was a condition.
- The promoter was entitled to end the contract, because any breach of a performer's contract is serious.
- The promoter was not entitled to end the contract, because the breach was of a warranty.Correct answer
- The promoter was not entitled to end the contract, because rehearsal terms are unenforceable.
- The promoter was entitled to end the contract, provided it paid her for the first concert.
The rehearsal clause was subsidiary to the main purpose of the contract, which was the performance of the concerts. Breach of it did not go to the root of the contract and could be compensated in damages, so it was a breach of warranty. The promoter was therefore not entitled to terminate and was itself in breach by refusing to allow her to perform. The tempting answer treats all terms about a performer's attendance as conditions, but the court distinguished the rehearsal obligation from performance itself.
Law basis: Bettini v Gye (1876) 1 QBD 183Question 3 · Classification of termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Dale Shipping chartered a ship to Eko Lines for two years. Because the engine room crew were incompetent, the ship spent about 20 weeks out of service for repairs during the first seven months. Eko terminated, claiming breach of the seaworthiness term. Repairs were complete and over 17 months of the charter remained. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Eko was not entitled to terminate, as it kept substantially the whole benefit.Correct answer
- Eko was entitled to terminate, because seaworthiness is always a condition.
- Eko was entitled to terminate, because the ship had been out of service for weeks.
- Eko was not entitled to terminate, because seaworthiness is always a warranty.
- Eko was entitled to terminate, because the owners failed to give notice of the delays.
Some terms cannot be classified in advance as conditions or warranties because they can be broken in ways that are trivial or serious. For such innominate terms, the right to terminate depends on whether the breach deprives the innocent party of substantially the whole benefit it was intended to obtain. The seaworthiness obligation was innominate, and with most of the charter still to run, the delay did not deprive Eko of substantially the whole benefit. Eko was not entitled to terminate and was liable for wrongful repudiation.
Law basis: Hongkong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd [1962] 2 QB 26Question 4 · Classification of termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Fen Feeds Ltd bought 3,000 tonnes of citrus pulp pellets from Gale Ltd, the contract requiring 'shipment to be made in good condition'. Part of the cargo arrived slightly damaged. The market price had fallen, and Fen rejected the whole cargo. It later bought the same pellets at a much lower price and used them for their intended purpose of making cattle feed. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Fen was entitled to reject, because the 'good condition' clause was a condition.
- Fen was not entitled to reject, as the term was innominate and the breach minor.Correct answer
- Fen was entitled to reject, because all express terms in a sale of goods are conditions.
- Fen was not entitled to reject, because it had already accepted the goods by inspection.
- Fen was entitled to reject, but only the damaged part of the shipment.
The Court of Appeal held that the innominate term approach applies to contracts for the sale of goods. The express 'good condition' clause was not a condition, but an innominate term. As the breach was not serious, the goods were still usable for their purpose and the buyers actually used them, Fen was not entitled to reject and was limited to damages. The tempting answer treats the clause as a condition, but there was no indication that the parties intended any breach, however slight, to permit rejection.
Law basis: Cehave NV v Bremer Handelsgesellschaft mbH (The Hansa Nord) [1976] QB 44Question 5 · Classification of termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Hale Ltd sold soya bean meal to Indus Ltd on a standard trade form under which Indus had to give at least 15 days' notice of readiness of a vessel to load. Indus gave notice four days late. Market prices had moved, and Hale treated the contract as terminated. Indus argues that the delay caused Hale little loss. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Hale was not entitled to terminate, because the late notice caused it little loss.
- Hale was not entitled to terminate, because a delay of four days is too short to matter.
- Hale was not entitled to terminate, because notice clauses are always innominate terms.
- Hale was entitled to terminate only after first giving Indus notice to make time of the essence.
- Hale was entitled to terminate, as the time clause was a condition.Correct answer
In mercantile contracts, stipulations as to time are generally treated as conditions, because certainty is of great importance and other obligations depend on them. The House of Lords held that the notice provision was a condition, so that any breach, however slight its consequences, entitled the seller to terminate. Hale was therefore entitled to treat the contract as ended. The tempting answer focuses on the seriousness of the consequences, which is relevant only for innominate terms, not conditions.
Law basis: Bunge Corp v Tradax Export SA [1981] 1 WLR 711Question 6 · Classification of termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Jet Tools Ltd appointed Kai as its sole distributor. Clause 7(b) said it was a 'condition' that Kai would visit six named customers every week. Another clause allowed either party to terminate for 'material breach' not remedied within 60 days. Kai missed a few visits. Jet terminated, saying that any breach of a 'condition' allowed termination. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Jet could terminate, because the parties had expressly labelled the term a condition.
- Jet could not terminate, because terms about visits are always mere warranties.
- Jet could terminate, because any breach of a distributor's obligations is repudiatory.
- Jet could not terminate, because the label was not conclusive in context.Correct answer
- Jet could terminate, but only after giving Kai 60 days to remedy every breach.
The use of the word 'condition' is an indication, but not conclusive, that the parties intended any breach to entitle termination. The court construes the contract as a whole. The House of Lords held that it was so unreasonable that missing a single visit out of many could permit termination that the parties could not have intended 'condition' in its technical sense, especially given the separate material breach clause. Jet was not entitled to terminate. The tempting answer gives the label conclusive effect.
Law basis: L Schuler AG v Wickman Machine Tool Sales Ltd [1974] AC 235Question 7 · Classification of termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Lumen Finance leased computer equipment to Mira under a contract stating that 'punctual payment of each instalment is of the essence of this agreement' and allowing termination on any late payment. Mira paid three instalments late. Lumen terminated and claimed damages for loss of all future instalments. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Lumen can terminate but recover only arrears, because late payment is not repudiatory.
- Lumen cannot terminate, because time of payment can never be made of the essence.
- Lumen cannot terminate, because three late payments do not deprive it of the benefit.
- Lumen can terminate, but the clause is an unenforceable penalty on Mira.
- Lumen can terminate and claim future instalments, as the term was a condition.Correct answer
Parties may expressly make a term a condition, including by stating that time of payment is of the essence. A breach of such a term, however minor, entitles the innocent party to terminate and claim damages for loss of the whole bargain, including future instalments. The Court of Appeal held that a clause making punctual payment of the essence had that effect. The tempting answer limits recovery to arrears, which would be right if the clause merely gave a right to terminate without making the term a condition.
Law basis: Lombard North Central plc v Butterworth [1987] QB 527Question 8 · Classification of termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Nova Ltd agreed to buy a flat from Orion Ltd. The contract made time of the essence and required completion by 5pm on a fixed date, failing which the deposit would be forfeited. Nova tendered the price at 5.10pm on that day. Orion rescinded and kept the deposit. Nova seeks specific performance, arguing that ten minutes made no difference. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Nova obtains specific performance, because a delay of ten minutes is trivial.
- Nova obtains relief, because equity always relieves against forfeiture of deposits.
- Nova fails, because time was of the essence and the deadline was missed.Correct answer
- Nova fails only because it had not paid the deposit in advance of completion.
- Nova obtains specific performance on payment of compensation for the delay.
Where time is of the essence, failure to complete on time, even by a few minutes, entitles the other party to terminate. The Privy Council refused relief against forfeiture or specific performance, emphasising the need for certainty in commercial contracts. Equity will not intervene to rewrite a clear time-of-the-essence clause simply because the delay was short. Orion was entitled to rescind and keep the deposit. The tempting answer assumes the court will overlook trivial delay, but certainty prevails where the parties made time essential.
Law basis: Union Eagle Ltd v Golden Achievement Ltd [1997] AC 514More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.