Gil, a company chairman, executed documents agreeing to buy Hal's shares on terms favourable to Hal. Hal had threatened to have Gil killed if he did not sign. Gil also had commercial reasons for wanting the deal, and might have signed anyway. Gil now seeks to set the documents aside. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Gil fails, because he would probably have signed for commercial reasons anyway.
- Gil fails, because he must show the threats were the main reason for signing.
- Gil succeeds, as the threats need only be a reason for his decision.Correct answer
- Gil succeeds only if the threats were reported to the police at the time.
- Gil fails, because duress makes a contract void rather than voidable.
Where duress takes the form of threats to the person, the victim can avoid the contract if the threats were a reason for entering into it, even if he would or might have entered into it anyway. The burden is on the party making the threats to show they contributed nothing to the decision. Hal's threats to kill were a reason for Gil's decision, so Gil could set the documents aside. The tempting answer imposes a 'but for' or main-reason test, which applies to economic duress rather than threats of violence.
Law basis: Barton v Armstrong [1976] AC 104