Law covered in these questions
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 ss 1, 2(1), 2(2), 11(1), 11(5)
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 2(1)
- Canada Steamship Lines Ltd v R [1952] AC 192
- Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd [1980] AC 827
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 2(2) and s 11
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 3
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 6(1)
- Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 12
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 6(1A)
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 11(1) and (5)
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 11(4)
- George Mitchell (Chesterhall) Ltd v Finney Lock Seeds Ltd [1983] 2 AC 803
- Watford Electronics Ltd v Sanderson CFL Ltd [2001] EWCA Civ 317
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, s 64(1) and (2)
All 19 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Zeta Ltd, a manufacturer, engaged Orion Consulting Ltd to advise on a new production system. Orion's standard terms, which Zeta accepted, said: 'Orion accepts no liability for loss arising from negligent advice.' Orion advised negligently and Zeta suffered £80,000 of financial loss. Which statement best describes the effect of the clause?
- The clause is valid and enforceable, because both parties are businesses and are free to allocate risk between them.
- The clause is effective, because the 1977 Act does not apply to clauses excluding liability for pure economic loss.
- The clause is effective only to the extent that Orion shows it satisfies the requirement of reasonableness under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.Correct answer
- The clause is void, because the Consumer Rights Act 2015 makes any exclusion of negligence liability unenforceable.
- The clause is automatically void, because the 1977 Act makes any clause excluding liability for negligence void.
In a business contract, a clause excluding liability for negligence that causes loss other than death or personal injury is subject to the reasonableness test, and the burden is on the party relying on it. Only exclusion for death or personal injury caused by negligence is void outright, and the Consumer Rights Act does not govern business-to-business terms.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 ss 1, 2(1), 2(2), 11(1), 11(5) ↗Question 2 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Pax Events Ltd hired a marquee from Quay Hire Ltd for a corporate function. Quay's terms stated: 'Quay excludes all liability for death or personal injury caused by its negligence.' A guest employed by Pax was injured when a marquee pole fell, owing to Quay's negligent assembly. Pax is sued, and seeks to recover from Quay. Quay relies on the clause. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause is effective, because both parties were businesses of equal bargaining power.
- The clause is ineffective, as liability for negligent injury cannot be excluded.Correct answer
- The clause is effective only if it satisfies the requirement of reasonableness.
- The clause is ineffective, because exclusion clauses never apply between businesses.
- The clause is effective, because it expressly refers to Quay's negligence.
A person cannot, by reference to any contract term or notice, exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence. This applies to business-to-business contracts. The clause is therefore ineffective, regardless of the equal bargaining power of the parties or the clarity of its wording. The tempting answer applies the reasonableness test, which governs exclusion of liability for other loss or damage caused by negligence, but not death or personal injury, where the prohibition is absolute.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 2(1) ↗Question 3 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Rhea Ltd leased a warehouse from Sutt Properties under a lease containing a clause stating that 'the landlord shall not be liable for any damage to the tenant's goods howsoever caused'. Sutt's maintenance staff negligently caused a fire, destroying Rhea's goods. Sutt could also have been liable to Rhea on a ground other than negligence, namely strict liability under an express repair covenant. Which of the following best describes the likely construction of the clause?
- The clause covers negligence, because 'howsoever caused' covers every cause of loss.
- The clause is void, because exclusion of negligence in a lease must be made by deed.
- The clause covers negligence, because exclusion clauses are construed in the landlord's favour.
- The clause is unlikely to cover negligence, because it can apply to another head of liability.Correct answer
- The clause covers negligence, because the parties were commercial organisations.
Under the traditional approach, where a clause does not expressly refer to negligence, the court asks whether its words are wide enough to cover negligence, and if so whether it could cover some other kind of liability that is not too fanciful. If it could, it will usually be confined to that other liability. The clause could apply to Sutt's strict liability under the repair covenant, so it is unlikely to cover negligence. The tempting answer treats general words as conclusive, but modern courts still require clear words to exclude negligence liability.
Law basis: Canada Steamship Lines Ltd v R [1952] AC 192Question 4 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Titan Paper Ltd engaged Ultra Security Ltd to provide night patrols at its factory. Ultra's terms excluded liability for 'any injurious act or default by any employee of the company'. An Ultra patrolman deliberately lit a small fire, which spread and destroyed the factory. Titan argues that such a serious breach can never be covered by an exclusion clause. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ultra can rely on the clause if, properly construed, it covers the breach.Correct answer
- Titan succeeds, because a fundamental breach destroys any exclusion clause.
- Titan succeeds, because deliberate acts by employees can never be excluded.
- Ultra can rely on the clause only if Titan had insured against the fire.
- Titan succeeds, because security contracts cannot contain exclusion clauses.
There is no rule of law that a fundamental breach prevents reliance on an exclusion clause. Whether the clause applies is a question of construction of the contract as a whole. In a commercial contract between parties of equal bargaining power, who could allocate risks and insure, the clause clearly covered deliberate acts by Ultra's employees, so Ultra could rely on it. The tempting answer reflects the discredited doctrine of fundamental breach as a rule of law, which the House of Lords rejected. Statutory controls now apply separately.
Law basis: Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd [1980] AC 827Question 5 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ava Ltd stored its stock in a warehouse run by Bolt Storage Ltd under a negotiated contract. A clause excluded Bolt's liability for 'loss of or damage to goods caused by Bolt's negligence'. Bolt's staff negligently left a door open, and Ava's stock was stolen. Ava argues that the clause is automatically void. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause is void, because negligence liability can never be excluded.
- The clause is effective, because theft by a third party is not negligence.
- The clause is effective, because the contract was individually negotiated.
- The clause is void, because it was not drawn specifically to Ava's attention.
- The clause is valid only if it meets the reasonableness requirement.Correct answer
In the case of loss or damage other than death or personal injury, a person cannot exclude or restrict liability for negligence except in so far as the term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness. The theft resulted from Bolt's negligence, so the clause is valid only if Bolt proves it was reasonable. Unlike the separate control on written standard terms, this negligence control applies whether or not the contract was negotiated. The tempting answer treats all negligence exclusions as void, but the absolute bar is limited to death and personal injury.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 2(2) and s 11 ↗Question 6 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Cleo Ltd contracted on Delta Logistics Ltd's written standard terms for the delivery of machine parts. A clause stated that Delta 'may deliver at any time it considers convenient, and is not liable for any delay'. Delta delivered three weeks late, causing Cleo losses. No negligence was involved. Cleo argues that the clause is subject to statutory control. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause is not controlled, because it does not concern negligence.
- The clause is void, because a business cannot exclude liability for late delivery.
- The clause must be reasonable, as it is in Delta's standard terms.Correct answer
- The clause is not controlled, because statutory controls apply only to consumers.
- The clause is valid, because Cleo could have negotiated different terms.
Where one party deals on the other's written standard terms of business, the other cannot, by reference to any contract term, exclude or restrict liability for its own breach, or claim to be entitled to render performance substantially different from what was reasonably expected, except in so far as the term is reasonable. Cleo contracted on Delta's standard terms, so the clause is subject to the reasonableness test. The tempting answer limits statutory control to negligence, but this separate provision covers contractual liability in standard terms.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 3 ↗Question 7 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Elan Ltd bought a used forklift truck from Fern Plant Ltd for its warehouse. Fern's terms stated: 'The seller gives no undertaking that it has the right to sell the goods.' The forklift had been stolen before Fern acquired it, and the true owner recovered it. Fern relies on the clause. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause is effective, because both parties were businesses.
- The clause is ineffective only because Fern acted dishonestly.
- The clause is effective if it satisfies the test of reasonableness.
- The clause is ineffective, as the title term cannot be excluded.Correct answer
- The clause is effective, because Elan had the opportunity to check title.
Liability for breach of the implied term that the seller has the right to sell the goods cannot be excluded or restricted by reference to any contract term. This applies to all sales of goods, including business-to-business contracts. Fern's clause is therefore of no effect, and Elan can recover the price. The tempting answer applies the reasonableness test, but that test governs exclusion of the implied terms as to description, quality and fitness in non-consumer sales, not the term as to title, which is protected absolutely.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 6(1); Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 12 ↗Question 8 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Gaia Bakeries Ltd bought an industrial oven from Holt Equipment Ltd. Holt's terms excluded 'all conditions as to quality or fitness for purpose implied by statute'. The oven never reached its stated temperature. Gaia claims for breach of the implied term of satisfactory quality, and Holt relies on its clause. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause is effective only in so far as it is shown to be reasonable.Correct answer
- The clause is void, because quality terms can never be excluded in any contract.
- The clause is effective, because sales between businesses are not regulated.
- The clause is void, because Holt is a business and Gaia dealt as a consumer.
- The clause is effective, because it expressly refers to the statutory terms.
In a contract for the sale of goods where the buyer is not a consumer, liability for breach of the implied terms as to description, satisfactory quality and fitness for purpose can be excluded or restricted only in so far as the term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness. Gaia is a business buyer, so Holt's clause will be effective only if Holt proves it reasonable. The tempting answer that such terms can never be excluded applies only to consumer contracts, which are governed by the Consumer Rights Act 2015.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 6(1A) ↗Question 9 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Iris Ltd's contract with Jago Software Ltd contained a clause limiting Jago's liability to £10,000. Iris suffered losses of £250,000 when Jago's software failed. In the litigation, Jago argues that Iris must prove the clause is unreasonable, because Iris is the party attacking it. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Iris must prove the clause is unreasonable, as the party challenging it.
- Jago must prove the clause is reasonable, as the party relying on it.Correct answer
- Neither party bears a burden, because reasonableness is a question for the judge.
- Iris must prove unreasonableness, unless Iris is a small business.
- Jago must prove reasonableness, but only if the clause excludes negligence.
It is for the party claiming that a contract term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness to show that it does. Jago relies on the limitation clause, so Jago bears the burden of proving it is reasonable, judged by reference to the circumstances which were, or ought reasonably to have been, known to or in the contemplation of the parties when the contract was made. The tempting answer places the burden on the party challenging the clause, which reverses the statutory rule. The burden applies regardless of whether negligence is involved.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 11(1) and (5) ↗Question 10 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Kite Engineering Ltd, a small firm, agreed to service equipment for a large chemical company. Kite's terms limited its liability to £50,000. Kite could not obtain insurance cover above that sum at an affordable premium. A breach by Kite caused the chemical company losses of £2m. In deciding whether the limit is reasonable, which of the following is the court specifically required to consider?
- Whether Kite was at fault in causing the breach that led to the loss.
- The actual size of the loss suffered compared with the amount of the limit.
- Whether the chemical company's losses were within reasonable contemplation.
- Whether the chemical company has a claim in tort as well as in contract.
- Kite's likely resources and whether it could obtain insurance.Correct answer
Where a term seeks to restrict liability to a specified sum, the court must have regard in particular to the resources which the party relying on it could expect to be available to meet the liability, and how far it was open to it to cover itself by insurance. Kite's limited resources and the unavailability of affordable insurance above £50,000 support reasonableness. The tempting answer compares the size of the actual loss with the cap, but reasonableness is judged at the time the contract was made, not with hindsight.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 11(4) ↗Question 11 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Lark Farms bought cabbage seed from Mere Seeds Ltd for £200. Mere's standard conditions limited liability to replacing the seed or refunding the price. The seed was defective and Lark's crop failed, causing a loss of £60,000. Mere had negligently supplied the wrong variety. Evidence showed that Mere usually settled such claims by negotiation and could have insured cheaply. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The limitation is reasonable, because it was a standard term widely used in the trade.
- The limitation is reasonable, because Lark could have insured its own crop.
- The limitation is unreasonable in the circumstances of the case.Correct answer
- The limitation is unreasonable, because limitation clauses are void in seed sales.
- The limitation is reasonable, because it was clear and covered the loss caused.
The House of Lords held such a limitation clause to be unreasonable. The supplier's practice of negotiating settlements showed that it did not itself regard the clause as fair, the breach resulted from its own negligence, and it could have insured against crop failure without significantly increasing the price of seed. Although the clause was clear and covered the loss as a matter of construction, it failed the statutory test. The tempting answer relies on widespread use in the trade, which was one factor but was outweighed by the others.
Law basis: George Mitchell (Chesterhall) Ltd v Finney Lock Seeds Ltd [1983] 2 AC 803Question 12 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Nexa Ltd, a substantial business, bought a bespoke software system from Opus Ltd after lengthy negotiations, with both sides advised by lawyers. The contract limited Opus's liability to the price and excluded indirect losses. Nexa had insisted on a reciprocal limit on its own liability. When the system failed, Nexa argued that the limitation was unreasonable. Which of the following best describes the court's likely approach?
- The court will strike the clause down, because it leaves Nexa without a full remedy.
- The court will be slow to interfere with this allocation of risk.Correct answer
- The court will strike the clause down, because Opus was the stronger party.
- The court will uphold the clause only if Nexa had insured against the loss.
- The court will strike the clause down, because indirect losses cannot be excluded.
Where experienced businesses of comparable bargaining power, with legal advice, negotiate an agreement, they should be taken to be the best judges of whether its terms are reasonable. The Court of Appeal held that a court should be cautious about interfering with such a commercial allocation of risk unless one party took unfair advantage of the other. Nexa negotiated with advice and secured reciprocal protection, so the clause is likely to be reasonable. The tempting answer focuses on the effect on Nexa's remedy rather than on the circumstances in which the term was agreed.
Law basis: Watford Electronics Ltd v Sanderson CFL Ltd [2001] EWCA Civ 317Question 13 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Pia joined Quantum Gym, a trader, paying £120 a month on a 12-month membership. The monthly fee was set out clearly on the front page of the agreement in bold type. Pia later discovered that a nearby gym charged £40 a month for similar facilities. She argues that the fee is an unfair term under the Consumer Rights Act 2015. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The fee is unfair, because it causes a significant imbalance to Pia's detriment.
- The fee cannot be assessed, because all terms in signed agreements are binding.
- The fee is unfair, because it is much higher than the market rate locally.
- The fee cannot be assessed, as it is a transparent, prominent price term.Correct answer
- The fee is unfair unless Quantum shows it was individually negotiated.
A term in a consumer contract may not be assessed for fairness to the extent that it specifies the main subject matter of the contract, or the assessment is of the appropriateness of the price payable, provided the term is transparent and prominent. Pia's complaint is about the level of the price, which was clearly and prominently stated, so it falls outside the fairness test. The tempting answer applies the significant imbalance test, but price adequacy is excluded from that assessment. Individual negotiation is not relevant under the 2015 Act.
Law basis: Consumer Rights Act 2015, s 64(1) and (2) ↗Question 14 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Rex, a consumer, visited a trampoline park run by Spring Ltd. A notice at the entrance stated: 'Spring accepts no liability for any injury suffered on the premises, however caused.' Rex was injured when a trampoline collapsed because Spring's staff had negligently failed to secure it. Spring relies on the notice. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The notice is ineffective, as it cannot exclude this liability.Correct answer
- The notice is effective, because Rex saw it before he entered the premises.
- The notice is effective, provided it was fair and transparent.
- The notice is ineffective, because notices never have contractual effect.
- The notice is effective only if Rex signed a waiver form as well.
A trader cannot by a term of a consumer contract or by a consumer notice exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence. Rex's injury resulted from Spring's negligence, so the notice is of no effect in relation to it. The tempting answer applies the general fairness and transparency test, but personal injury caused by negligence is subject to an absolute prohibition rather than an assessment of fairness. Whether Rex saw the notice or signed anything does not matter.
Law basis: Consumer Rights Act 2015, s 65(1) ↗Question 15 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Tilly hired a holiday cottage from Unwin Lets Ltd, a trader. A term stated that the deposit was refundable 'unless the property is left in poor condition'. On departure the cottage was clean, but one cup was chipped. Unwin kept the whole deposit, arguing that 'poor condition' includes any damage at all. The term is capable of either meaning. Which of the following best describes how it should be interpreted?
- In Unwin's favour, because the trader drafted the term for its own protection.
- By asking which meaning the parties actually intended when they contracted.
- In the way most favourable to Tilly, as the consumer.Correct answer
- As void, because a term with two possible meanings is uncertain.
- In Unwin's favour, because any damage leaves the property in poorer condition.
If a term in a consumer contract could have different meanings, the meaning that is most favourable to the consumer is to prevail. This statutory form of the contra proferentem rule reflects the requirement that written terms in consumer contracts be transparent. The meaning most favourable to Tilly is that a single chipped cup does not leave the property in poor condition. The tempting answer construes the term in the trader's favour, which reverses the rule. The term is not void for uncertainty, because it can be given a meaning.
Law basis: Consumer Rights Act 2015, s 69(1) ↗Question 16 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Vale Finance Ltd sued Wyn, a consumer, for sums due under a loan agreement, relying on a clause allowing it to charge default interest at 30% a month. Wyn, who is acting in person, did not argue that the clause was unfair. The court has sufficient legal and factual material before it to consider the point. Which of the following best describes the court's duty?
- The court must not consider fairness, because Wyn did not raise it.
- The court must consider fairness, though Wyn did not raise it.Correct answer
- The court may consider fairness only if Vale consents to it doing so.
- The court must consider fairness only if Wyn files written submissions.
- The court must not consider fairness, because interest is a price term.
A court must consider whether a term in a consumer contract is fair even if none of the parties has raised the issue, provided it has sufficient legal and factual material before it to do so. A default interest rate of this size engages the fairness test, and the court has the relevant material, so it must consider the point of its own motion. The tempting answer treats fairness as a matter for the parties to raise, but the statute imposes a duty on the court. Default interest is not part of the core price exempt from assessment.
Law basis: Consumer Rights Act 2015, s 71 ↗Question 17 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Xeno Fishing Ltd engaged Yate Security Ltd to guard its fishing boats in harbour. Yate's terms limited its liability for any loss to £1,000. Through Yate's negligence a boat sank, causing a £55,000 loss. Xeno argues that the limitation clause should be construed as strictly as an exclusion clause and so does not cover negligence. Which of the following best describes the court's likely approach?
- The clause is construed as strictly as an exclusion clause, so negligence is not covered.
- The clause is construed in Yate's favour, because limitation clauses are always valid.
- The clause is void, because a limitation of liability is a penalty.
- The clause is construed less strictly and given its ordinary meaning.Correct answer
- The clause can only limit liability for breaches that do not involve negligence.
The strict approach applied to clauses that wholly exclude liability for negligence does not apply with the same rigour to clauses that merely limit liability. Limitation clauses are related to the risks the defendant is exposed to, the remuneration it receives and the possibility of insurance, so it is not inherently improbable that the parties intended them to apply. Such clauses must still be clearly expressed, but are given their ordinary meaning. Any statutory reasonableness test applies separately. The tempting answer applies the strict exclusion clause approach.
Law basis: Ailsa Craig Fishing Co Ltd v Malvern Fishing Co Ltd [1983] 1 WLR 964Question 18 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Zola Ltd engaged Aero Couriers Ltd, on Aero's standard terms, to deliver documents. A clause stated: 'Aero shall not be liable for any loss unless a written claim is received within 3 days of delivery.' Zola's documents were lost and it notified Aero on day 5. Aero says the clause does not exclude liability at all but merely sets a procedure. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause is outside statutory control, because it does not exclude liability.
- The clause is valid, because Zola agreed to the time limit when contracting.
- The clause is void, because time limits for claims are always unenforceable.
- The clause is outside control, because Zola is a business rather than a consumer.
- The clause is subject to the reasonableness test.Correct answer
Statutory controls on exclusion clauses extend to terms that make liability or its enforcement subject to restrictive or onerous conditions. A short time limit for claims restricts liability in this way. As Aero contracted on its standard terms, the clause must satisfy the requirement of reasonableness. The tempting answer accepts Aero's argument that a procedural condition is not an exclusion, but the anti-avoidance provision is aimed precisely at clauses which achieve exclusion indirectly. Such time limits are not automatically void.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, ss 3 and 13(1)(a) ↗Question 19 · Exclusion clauses and unfair termsDraft, pending solicitor review
Bex Ltd bought a franchise from Corin Franchising Ltd after Corin's director gave false profit figures, honestly but carelessly. The contract stated: 'No liability shall attach to Corin for any representation made before this agreement.' Bex sues for misrepresentation. Corin relies on the clause. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause is effective only if Corin proves it reasonable.Correct answer
- The clause is effective, because Bex is a business and agreed to it.
- The clause is void, because misrepresentation liability can never be excluded.
- The clause is effective, because the director's statement was made honestly.
- The clause is void, unless Bex was legally advised when entering the agreement.
A term excluding or restricting liability for misrepresentation, or any remedy for it, is of no effect except in so far as it satisfies the requirement of reasonableness, and the burden of showing that it does is on the party claiming that it does. Corin must therefore prove that the clause was reasonable in the circumstances. The tempting answer treats misrepresentation liability as incapable of exclusion. That is too absolute, although a clause purporting to exclude liability for fraud would not be upheld. Legal advice is a relevant factor but not a precondition.
Law basis: Misrepresentation Act 1967, s 3; Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 11(1) ↗More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.