Law covered in these questions
- Taylor v Caldwell (1863) 3 B & S 826
- Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 s 1(2)
- Krell v Henry [1903] 2 KB 740
- Herne Bay Steam Boat Co v Hutton [1903] 2 KB 683
- Davis Contractors Ltd v Fareham UDC [1956] AC 696
- Tsakiroglou & Co Ltd v Noblee Thorl GmbH [1962] AC 93
- Maritime National Fish Ltd v Ocean Trawlers Ltd [1935] AC 524
- J Lauritzen AS v Wijsmuller BV (The Super Servant Two) [1990] 1 Lloyd's Rep 1
- Condor v The Baron Knights Ltd [1966] 1 WLR 87
- Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 1(2)
- Gamerco SA v ICM/Fair Warning (Agency) Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 1226
- Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 1(3)
- BP Exploration Co (Libya) Ltd v Hunt (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 783
- Canary Wharf (BP4) T1 Ltd v European Medicines Agency [2019] EWHC 335 (Ch)
All 13 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Mina hired a concert hall from Hall Ltd for 1 June at a fee of £5,000 and paid a £2,000 deposit in advance. On 1 May, without fault on either side, the hall was destroyed by fire. Which statement best describes the position?
- The contract was void from the outset, so each party must return everything received under it.
- The contract was frustrated and automatically discharged from the date of the fire, and the deposit is recoverable subject to the court's power to allow Hall Ltd to retain expenses.Correct answer
- Hall Ltd is in breach of contract, and Mina can recover damages for the profit she expected from the concert.
- The contract is voidable at Mina's option, and Hall Ltd must provide an alternative venue.
- The contract remains binding until either party terminates it by notice, and the deposit is forfeited.
Question 2 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Ola hired a music hall from Pip for four concerts. Before the first concert, and through no fault of either party, the hall was destroyed by fire. Ola had spent money advertising the concerts and sues Pip for breach of contract. The contract contained no express provision about destruction of the hall. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Pip is not liable, as the contract was frustrated by the hall's destruction.Correct answer
- Pip is liable, because the contract imposed an absolute duty to supply the hall.
- Pip is liable, because he bore the risk of fire as owner of the hall.
- Pip is not liable, because the contract was void for common mistake.
- Pip is liable for Ola's costs, but not for her lost profits.
A contract is frustrated where, without default of either party, a supervening event makes performance impossible or radically different from what was undertaken. Where performance depends on the continued existence of a specific thing, the contract is subject to an implied condition that it will be discharged if the thing perishes without fault. The hall was essential to performance, and its destruction discharged both parties. Pip is not liable. The tempting answer treats the obligation as absolute, but the court rejected that approach. Mistake does not apply because the hall existed when the contract was made.
Law basis: Taylor v Caldwell (1863) 3 B & S 826Question 3 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Quin hired a flat overlooking the route of a coronation procession for two days, for £75. The contract did not mention the procession, but both parties knew that viewing it was the reason for the hire. The procession was cancelled because of the king's illness. Rhian, the owner, claims the balance of the price. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Quin must pay, because the flat was still available for the two days.
- Quin must pay, because the procession was not mentioned in the contract.
- Quin need not pay the balance, as the contract was frustrated.Correct answer
- Quin need not pay, because Rhian misrepresented that the procession would occur.
- Quin must pay, but may claim damages for the cancellation from Rhian.
A contract may be frustrated where the event that is the foundation of the contract, recognised by both parties, fails to occur, even if literal performance remains possible. Both parties knew that viewing the coronation procession was the foundation of the hire, so the cancellation of the procession frustrated the contract. The tempting answer focuses on the continued availability of the flat, but the court looked at the shared purpose, which could be inferred from the surrounding circumstances even though it was not stated in the contract.
Law basis: Krell v Henry [1903] 2 KB 740Question 4 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Sol chartered a steamboat from Tug Ltd for two days 'for the purpose of viewing the naval review and for a day's cruise round the fleet'. The naval review was cancelled, but the fleet remained at anchor and the cruise round it could still take place. Sol refused to pay the hire, arguing that the contract was frustrated. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Sol need not pay, because the main purpose of the hire had failed.
- Sol need not pay, because the cancellation was outside both parties' control.
- Sol need not pay, because the naval review was expressly mentioned.
- Sol must pay half the hire, reflecting the part of the purpose remaining.
- Sol must pay, as the contract's foundation had not wholly failed.Correct answer
Frustration of purpose applies only where the common foundation of the contract has entirely failed. The Court of Appeal held that the cancellation of the naval review did not frustrate the hire of a steamboat, because the cruise round the fleet could still take place and the viewing of the review was only Sol's purpose, not the shared foundation of the contract. The risk was Sol's. The tempting answer treats the loss of the main purpose as sufficient, but some purpose remained and the contract was essentially a hire of a boat.
Law basis: Herne Bay Steam Boat Co v Hutton [1903] 2 KB 683Question 5 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Uno Builders agreed to build 78 houses for a council in eight months for a fixed price. Owing to unexpected shortages of skilled labour, the work took 22 months and cost far more than expected. Uno argued that the contract had been frustrated and claimed a reasonable sum for the work instead of the contract price. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The contract was frustrated, because performance became much more expensive.
- The contract was not frustrated, as it had merely become more onerous.Correct answer
- The contract was frustrated, because the delay was nearly three times longer.
- The contract was not frustrated, because building contracts cannot be frustrated.
- The contract was frustrated, because the labour shortage was not foreseeable.
Frustration occurs only where, without default of either party, a supervening event makes performance radically different from what was undertaken. It is not enough that performance becomes more onerous or expensive than expected. The House of Lords held that the labour shortage and delay, although unexpected, did not make the job of building the houses a fundamentally different thing from that contracted for. Uno was bound by the fixed price. The tempting answer treats increased cost and delay as enough, but hardship alone does not frustrate a contract.
Law basis: Davis Contractors Ltd v Fareham UDC [1956] AC 696Question 6 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Vela Ltd agreed to sell groundnuts to Wing Ltd, shipment from Port Sudan to Hamburg in November. The contract did not specify the route. The usual route was via the Suez Canal, which was then closed by military action. Shipment via the Cape of Good Hope was possible but would take more than twice as long and cost twice as much. Vela refused to ship. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The contract was frustrated, because the agreed route had become impossible.
- The contract was not frustrated, because frustration never applies to sales of goods.
- The contract was frustrated, because the cost of shipment had doubled.
- The contract was not frustrated, as the Cape route was not radically different.Correct answer
- The contract was frustrated, because the parties had both assumed the canal route.
A contract is not frustrated merely because performance becomes more expensive or takes longer than expected. The House of Lords held that the closure of the Suez Canal did not frustrate a contract for the sale of goods where no route was specified, because shipment via the Cape was still possible and was not fundamentally different from what was agreed: the goods would still arrive in a usable condition and the date of arrival was not critical. Vela was liable for non-delivery. The tempting answers focus on the parties' assumption and the increased cost.
Law basis: Tsakiroglou & Co Ltd v Noblee Thorl GmbH [1962] AC 93Question 7 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Xeno Fishing chartered a trawler, the Yale, from Zeal Ltd for use with an otter trawl, which required a government licence. Xeno operated five trawlers and applied for five licences, but was granted only three. It chose to allocate the three licences to its own trawlers rather than to the Yale, and claimed the charter of the Yale was frustrated. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The charter was not frustrated, as the impossibility resulted from Xeno's own choice.Correct answer
- The charter was frustrated, because the licensing decision was outside Xeno's control.
- The charter was frustrated, because Xeno acted reasonably in favouring its own ships.
- The charter was not frustrated, because licensing changes are always foreseeable.
- The charter was frustrated, but Xeno must pay hire up to the date of the refusal.
A party cannot rely on frustration where the supervening event is self-induced, that is, results from its own act or election. Xeno received three licences and chose to allocate them to other trawlers, so the inability to use the Yale resulted from its own choice. The contract was not frustrated, and Xeno remained liable for the hire. The tempting answer focuses on the government's licensing decision, but the decisive factor was Xeno's election about how to use the licences it did receive.
Law basis: Maritime National Fish Ltd v Ocean Trawlers Ltd [1935] AC 524Question 8 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Ark Transport contracted to carry Bex's drilling rig using one of two vessels it owned, Ark choosing which. One vessel sank, without Ark's fault. Ark had already allocated its other vessel to other contracts and so told Bex that it could not perform. Ark claims the contract with Bex was frustrated. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The contract was frustrated, because the sinking occurred without Ark's fault.
- The contract was frustrated only in part, so Ark must pay half the price.
- The contract was frustrated, because Ark had to honour its other contracts.
- The contract was not frustrated, because carriage contracts cannot be frustrated.
- The contract was not frustrated, as Ark's own choice caused non-performance.Correct answer
Frustration must arise from an event outside the control of the party relying on it. Where a party has a choice of how to allocate its resources among several contracts, and its own election causes the non-performance of one of them, the frustration is self-induced. The Court of Appeal held that the carrier's decision to use its remaining vessel for other contracts was the cause of non-performance, so the contract was not frustrated. The tempting answer focuses on the faultless sinking, which was not the operative cause.
Law basis: J Lauritzen AS v Wijsmuller BV (The Super Servant Two) [1990] 1 Lloyd's Rep 1Question 9 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Cy, a drummer, agreed to play for a band on seven nights a week for five years. He became seriously ill, and his doctors advised that he could play no more than four nights a week, or he would risk a breakdown. The band dismissed him. Cy claims damages for wrongful dismissal. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The band is liable, because Cy's illness was temporary and he could still play.
- The band is not liable, as Cy's illness frustrated the contract.Correct answer
- The band is liable, because it should have reduced Cy's nights to four.
- The band is not liable, because Cy was in repudiatory breach by falling ill.
- The band is liable, because illness can never frustrate an employment contract.
A contract for personal services can be frustrated by illness of the person who is to perform, where the illness makes performance radically different from what was contemplated. The court held that a drummer who could safely play only four nights a week, when the commercial success of the band required seven, could not perform the contract in the way contemplated, and the contract was frustrated. The tempting answer argues that partial performance remained possible, but the band could not be expected to organise its engagements around his limited availability.
Law basis: Condor v The Baron Knights Ltd [1966] 1 WLR 87Question 10 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Dax Promotions agreed to promote a concert by a rock group at a stadium and paid the group an advance of £200,000. Before the concert, the stadium's safety licence was revoked and the concert could not go ahead. The contract was frustrated. The group had spent £40,000 on preparations. Dax claims repayment of the advance. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Dax recovers nothing, because losses lie where they fall on frustration.
- Dax recovers half the advance, because the losses are shared equally.
- Dax recovers the advance, subject to a discretionary allowance for expenses.Correct answer
- Dax recovers the advance less £40,000, because expenses must always be deducted.
- Dax recovers the advance only if there was a total failure of consideration.
Under the statute, money paid before the time of discharge is recoverable, and sums payable cease to be payable. If the payee incurred expenses before discharge in performing the contract, the court may, if it considers it just, allow it to retain or recover a sum up to the amount of those expenses. Deduction is discretionary, not automatic, and there is no rule of equal division. In a case on similar facts the judge exercised the discretion by making no deduction. The tempting answer makes the expenses deduction compulsory.
Law basis: Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 1(2); Gamerco SA v ICM/Fair Warning (Agency) Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 1226Question 11 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Elk Oil agreed to explore and develop an oilfield owned by Fern, in return for a share of the oil produced. Elk spent heavily and brought the field into production. Fern's government then expropriated the field, frustrating the contract. Fern had received some oil and compensation. Elk seeks a sum for the benefit it conferred. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Elk may recover a just sum, capped at the value of Fern's benefit.Correct answer
- Elk recovers nothing, because the contract was frustrated before it was paid.
- Elk recovers all the money it spent, regardless of any benefit to Fern.
- Elk recovers the value of its work as a quantum meruit at market rates.
- Elk recovers half its expenditure, because the risk is shared equally.
Where a party has, by an act done in performance of the contract, obtained a valuable benefit before discharge, the court may order it to pay a just sum, not exceeding the value of that benefit. The court first identifies and values the benefit, usually the end product of the work, taking account of the effect of the frustrating event, and then assesses a just sum. Elk conferred a valuable benefit on Fern in the oil and compensation received. The tempting answer allows recovery of all expenditure, but the award is capped by the value of the benefit.
Law basis: Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s 1(3); BP Exploration Co (Libya) Ltd v Hunt (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 783Question 12 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Gala, an EU agency, held a 25-year lease of London offices. After the UK left the EU, Gala was required by EU law to relocate to Amsterdam and argued that the lease had been frustrated. The lease contained provisions for assignment and subletting, and Gala's relocation was a matter it could have anticipated to some extent. Which of the following best describes the court's likely view?
- The lease was frustrated, because Gala could no longer lawfully use the premises.
- The lease was frustrated, because leases are automatically ended by changes in law.
- The lease was not frustrated, as performance was not radically different.Correct answer
- The lease was not frustrated, because leases of land can never be frustrated.
- The lease was frustrated only for the remainder after Gala moved out.
In a case on similar facts, the High Court held that the UK's departure from the EU did not frustrate a long lease of offices taken by an EU agency. The tenant could still use the premises or assign or sublet them under the lease, and the parties had foreseen the possibility of relocation to some extent by including those provisions. The change did not make performance radically different. Leases are capable of being frustrated in principle, so the answer that they never can be is wrong, but the threshold is very high.
Law basis: Canary Wharf (BP4) T1 Ltd v European Medicines Agency [2019] EWHC 335 (Ch)Question 13 · FrustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Hix Ltd held a 10-year lease of a warehouse. In year five, the council closed the only access road for 20 months because of a dangerous building nearby, preventing Hix from using the warehouse. Hix stopped paying rent, arguing that the lease had been frustrated. About three years of the lease would remain after the road reopened. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The lease was frustrated, because Hix could not use the warehouse at all.
- The lease was frustrated, but Hix must pay rent once the road reopened.
- The lease was frustrated, because the closure was caused by a public authority.
- The lease was not frustrated, because a lease of land can never be frustrated.
- The lease was not frustrated, given the length of the remaining term.Correct answer
The House of Lords held that the doctrine of frustration is capable of applying to a lease, but that it will rarely do so. Whether it applies depends on whether the event makes performance radically different, judged against the whole term. An interruption of 20 months in a 10-year lease, with years of the term remaining after access was restored, did not frustrate it, so the tenant remained liable for rent. The tempting answer treats total temporary inability to use as enough. The view that leases can never be frustrated was rejected.
Law basis: National Carriers Ltd v Panalpina (Northern) Ltd [1981] AC 675More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.