Law covered in these questions
- Cutter v Powell (1795) 6 TR 320
- Hoenig v Isaacs [1952] 2 All ER 176
- Bolton v Mahadeva [1972] 1 WLR 1009
- Sumpter v Hedges [1898] 1 QB 673
- Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 30(1)
- Planché v Colburn (1831) 8 Bing 14
- Hochster v De la Tour (1853) 2 E & B 678
- Avery v Bowden (1855) 5 E & B 714
- White and Carter (Councils) Ltd v McGregor [1962] AC 413
- Clea Shipping Corp v Bulk Oil International Ltd (The Alaskan Trader) [1984] 1 All ER 129
- Vitol SA v Norelf Ltd (The Santa Clara) [1996] AC 800
- Woodar Investment Development Ltd v Wimpey Construction UK Ltd [1980] 1 WLR 277
- Charles Rickards Ltd v Oppenhaim [1950] 1 KB 616
- Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 11(4) and 35
All 16 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Kurt agreed to serve as second mate on a voyage from Jamaica to Liverpool, to be paid 30 guineas 'provided he proceeds, continues and does his duty' until arrival. He served for seven weeks but died before the ship reached Liverpool. His widow claims a proportion of the wages for the time he served. Which of the following best describes the position?
- She can recover a proportion, because Kurt's death was not his fault.
- She cannot recover, as payment depended on complete performance.Correct answer
- She can recover a reasonable sum for the work Kurt actually did.
- She can recover the full 30 guineas, because death frustrated the contract.
- She cannot recover, because seamen's wages are payable only at sea.
Where a contract is an entire contract, complete performance is a condition of payment, and nothing is due for partial performance. The contract stated that the wages were payable only if Kurt continued his duty until the ship arrived in Liverpool, so his death part way through meant nothing was payable. The tempting answer seeks to apportion the price, but at common law no apportionment was possible under an entire obligation. Modern legislation now addresses frustrated contracts and wages differently, but the case illustrates the entire obligations rule.
Law basis: Cutter v Powell (1795) 6 TR 320Question 2 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Liam agreed to decorate Mona's flat and supply furniture for £750, payable 'net cash, as the work proceeds; and balance on completion'. He completed the work, but a wardrobe door needed replacing and a bookshelf was too short, costing about £56 to put right. Mona refused to pay the £350 balance, arguing that the work had not been completed. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Mona need pay nothing more, because the work was not fully completed.
- Liam can recover only a reasonable sum for the work done.
- Liam can recover the full balance, because the defects were minor.
- Mona need pay nothing more until Liam has fixed every defect.
- Liam can recover the balance less the cost of fixing the defects.Correct answer
Where a contract is not an entire contract and has been substantially performed, the party performing can recover the contract price less a deduction for the cost of remedying the defects. Liam's work was substantially complete, and the defects could be fixed for a small fraction of the price, so he could recover the balance less £56. The tempting answer treats completion as an entire obligation. Recovery of the full balance is also wrong, because Mona is entitled to set off the cost of remedying the defects.
Law basis: Hoenig v Isaacs [1952] 2 All ER 176Question 3 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Nell agreed to install a central heating system in Ola's house for £560. The system, when installed, gave out fumes that made the living room uncomfortable and heated the house unevenly, with temperatures varying by up to 15%. It would cost £174 to put right. Nell claims the price less £174. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Nell can recover the price less £174, under the substantial performance doctrine.
- Nell can recover the full price, because the system was installed and working.
- Nell cannot recover anything, as she did not substantially perform the contract.Correct answer
- Nell can recover a reasonable sum for the materials she supplied.
- Nell can recover half the price, as the system was half effective.
The doctrine of substantial performance allows recovery of the price less the cost of remedying defects only where the contract has been substantially performed. Whether it has depends on the nature of the defects and the cost of remedying them relative to the price. A heating system that emitted fumes and heated unevenly, with remedial costs of nearly a third of the price, had not been substantially performed. Nell could recover nothing. The tempting answer applies the doctrine without asking whether substantial performance was achieved.
Law basis: Bolton v Mahadeva [1972] 1 WLR 1009Question 4 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Pete agreed to build two houses on Quinn's land for £565. When he had done work worth about £333, he ran out of money and abandoned the job. Quinn finished the houses himself, using building materials Pete had left on site. Pete claims payment for the work done and the materials. Which of the following best describes Pete's position?
- He can recover for the materials used, but not for the work he did.Correct answer
- He can recover a reasonable sum for all the work done before he stopped.
- He can recover nothing, because Quinn completed the houses himself.
- He can recover the contract price less the cost of completing the houses.
- He can recover for the work done, but not for the materials left behind.
Where a party abandons an entire contract, he cannot recover for partial performance. A claim in quantum meruit for work done requires evidence that the other party had a genuine choice whether to accept the partial performance. A landowner has no real choice about work already built into his land, so finishing the building is not acceptance. However, Quinn chose to use the loose materials left on site, so Pete could recover their value. The tempting answer allows recovery for the work, but Quinn had no choice about that.
Law basis: Sumpter v Hedges [1898] 1 QB 673Question 5 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Raya Wholesale ordered 500 cases of olive oil from Sami Ltd at £20 a case. Sami delivered only 420 cases and could supply no more. Raya kept the 420 cases and sold most of them. Sami now claims payment for 420 cases. Raya argues that, as Sami failed to deliver the full quantity, it is not obliged to pay anything. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Raya need pay nothing, because the contract was for an entire quantity.
- Raya need pay nothing, unless it agreed to the short delivery in writing.
- Raya must pay a reasonable price for the 420 cases it kept.
- Raya must pay for the 420 cases at the contract rate.Correct answer
- Raya must pay the full price for 500 cases, less its damages.
Where the seller delivers a quantity of goods less than he contracted to sell, the buyer may reject them, but if the buyer accepts the goods so delivered, he must pay for them at the contract rate. Raya kept and sold the 420 cases, so it accepted them and must pay at £20 a case, while retaining its claim for damages for the shortfall. The tempting answer treats the contract as entire so that nothing is payable, but the statute gives the buyer the choice and the consequences of accepting.
Law basis: Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 30(1) ↗Question 6 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Tara was engaged by a publisher to write a book for a series on armour, for £100 on completion. After she had researched and written part of the book, the publisher abandoned the series. Tara had not offered the partial manuscript and the publisher had not accepted it. Which of the following best describes Tara's position?
- She can recover nothing, because she did not complete the book.
- She can recover nothing, because the contract was frustrated.
- She can recover the full £100, because the publisher repudiated the contract.
- She can recover only if the publisher used the work she had done.
- She can recover a reasonable sum for the work done, on a quantum meruit.Correct answer
Where one party is prevented from completing performance by the other party's breach or repudiation, the innocent party may either claim damages or recover a reasonable sum for the work done on a quantum meruit. The publisher abandoned the series, preventing Tara from completing the book, so she could recover a reasonable sum for her work even though the contract was entire and she had not completed it. The tempting answer applies the entire obligations rule, which does not protect a party who prevents performance.
Law basis: Planché v Colburn (1831) 8 Bing 14Question 7 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
In April, Uma agreed to employ Vic as a tour courier from 1 June for three months. In May, Uma wrote to Vic saying she had changed her mind and would not need his services. Vic issued proceedings for damages on 22 May. Uma argues that Vic could not sue before 1 June, when performance was due. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Vic must wait until 1 June, because there can be no breach before performance is due.
- Vic may sue at once, as Uma's renunciation was an anticipatory breach.Correct answer
- Vic must wait until the end of the three months to know his loss.
- Vic may sue at once, but only for the first month's wages.
- Vic must first give Uma a reasonable opportunity to withdraw her letter.
Where one party renounces the contract before the time for performance, the innocent party may accept the renunciation as an anticipatory breach and sue immediately for damages, without waiting for the time for performance to arrive. Uma's letter was a clear refusal to perform, so Vic was entitled to sue on 22 May. The tempting answer insists that no breach can occur before performance is due, which the court rejected. Damages are assessed by reference to Vic's loss of the whole contract, subject to mitigation.
Law basis: Hochster v De la Tour (1853) 2 E & B 678Question 8 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Wren chartered Xan's ship to load cargo at Odessa within 45 days. Before the 45 days expired, Wren's agent told the ship's master that no cargo would be provided and advised him to leave. The master stayed, hoping a cargo might still come. Before the 45 days were up, war broke out, making loading illegal. Xan sues for breach. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Xan succeeds, because Wren's refusal was an anticipatory breach.
- Xan succeeds, because the master's decision to stay was reasonable.
- Xan fails, as he affirmed the contract and it was then frustrated.Correct answer
- Xan fails, because a charterer's refusal is never repudiatory.
- Xan succeeds, but only for the days the ship waited at Odessa.
On an anticipatory breach, the innocent party may accept it and sue, or affirm the contract and await performance. If he affirms, the contract remains alive for both parties, and he takes the risk of any later event that discharges it. By keeping the ship at Odessa, Xan affirmed the contract. The outbreak of war then frustrated it, discharging both parties before any actual breach, so Xan had no claim. The tempting answer treats the refusal as a completed breach, but it was never accepted.
Law basis: Avery v Bowden (1855) 5 E & B 714Question 9 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Yell Ads agreed to display advertisements for Zed's garage on litter bins for three years. On the same day, before Yell had done anything, Zed cancelled. Yell refused to accept the cancellation, displayed the adverts for three years without needing Zed's cooperation, and sued for the full price under the contract. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Yell can recover only damages, because it should have mitigated its loss.
- Yell can recover only the price for the first year of advertising.
- Yell can recover nothing, because Zed had cancelled before performance began.
- Yell can recover the full price, having affirmed and performed.Correct answer
- Yell can recover the price only if Zed had expressly agreed to pay in advance.
An innocent party faced with a repudiation may affirm the contract, perform its own obligations and claim the agreed price, if it can perform without the other party's cooperation. The duty to mitigate applies to damages claims and does not arise where the claimant sues for the price. Yell could display the adverts without Zed's help, so it was entitled to the full price. The House of Lords noted a possible limit where the innocent party has no legitimate interest in performing rather than claiming damages, which was not shown here.
Law basis: White and Carter (Councils) Ltd v McGregor [1962] AC 413Question 10 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Ark Shipping chartered a vessel to Bale Oil for 24 months. Halfway through, the engine failed and the charterers said they had no further use for the ship. Ark nonetheless spent £800,000 repairing the vessel and kept it fully crewed at anchor, unused, for the rest of the term, then claimed hire. Ark had no reason to keep the charter alive other than to claim hire. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ark cannot recover hire, as it had no legitimate interest in affirming.Correct answer
- Ark can recover hire, because an innocent party may always affirm the contract.
- Ark can recover hire, because the charterers did not make a counter-offer.
- Ark cannot recover hire, because the engine failure frustrated the charter.
- Ark can recover hire, but only for the period the ship needed repairs.
The right of an innocent party to affirm a contract and claim the price after repudiation is not unlimited. Where the innocent party has no legitimate interest in performing rather than claiming damages, and insisting on performance would be wholly unreasonable, the court will not allow it to do so. Ark spent large sums and kept a crewed ship idle purely to earn hire, so it had no legitimate interest, and it was limited to damages. The tempting answer states the right to affirm too absolutely, ignoring this qualification.
Law basis: Clea Shipping Corp v Bulk Oil International Ltd (The Alaskan Trader) [1984] 1 All ER 129Question 11 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Cova sold propane to Dart, delivery to be made in March. Dart wrongly told Cova that it was cancelling the contract. Cova said nothing in reply, but did not take the steps needed to deliver, such as issuing a bill of lading. Cova later sued for damages. Dart argued that Cova had never accepted its repudiation because Cova had not told Dart so. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Cova did not accept the repudiation, because acceptance must be in words.
- Cova did not accept the repudiation, because silence is never acceptance.
- Cova accepted the repudiation by its failure to perform.Correct answer
- Cova accepted the repudiation only once it issued legal proceedings.
- Cova did not accept the repudiation, so the contract remains in force.
Acceptance of a repudiation requires no particular form. It is sufficient that the innocent party's communication or conduct clearly and unequivocally conveys that it is treating the contract as at an end. In some circumstances, a failure to perform, such as not taking the next step required, may itself signify acceptance, provided the repudiating party learns of it. Cova's failure to issue the bill of lading conveyed its election to Dart. The tempting answer insists on words, but the House of Lords held that conduct or even inaction can suffice.
Law basis: Vitol SA v Norelf Ltd (The Santa Clara) [1996] AC 800Question 12 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Elm Developers agreed to buy land from Fir Estates. Elm, relying in good faith on its reasonable interpretation of a clause, served notice purporting to rescind the contract under that clause. A court later held that the clause did not in fact apply. Fir argues that Elm's notice was itself a repudiation entitling Fir to terminate and claim damages. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Elm repudiated, because wrongly purporting to rescind is always repudiatory.
- Elm did not repudiate, because land contracts cannot be repudiated.
- Elm repudiated, because a party must be certain before invoking a clause.
- Elm did not repudiate, as it relied on the clause in good faith.Correct answer
- Elm repudiated, but Fir may recover only nominal damages.
Whether a party has repudiated depends on whether, viewed objectively, it has shown an intention not to perform the contract. The House of Lords held that a party who in good faith relies on a contractual provision, even if mistakenly, and intends to abide by the contract as properly construed, does not thereby repudiate it. Elm was invoking the contract, not abandoning it, so there was no repudiation. The tempting answer states that a wrongful purported termination is always repudiatory, which is too broad.
Law basis: Woodar Investment Development Ltd v Wimpey Construction UK Ltd [1980] 1 WLR 277Question 13 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Gus ordered a custom car body from Hale Coachworks, to be delivered by 20 March. Hale missed the date. Gus continued to press for delivery for three months. In late June he wrote that, if the car was not ready within four weeks, he would cancel. It was not ready in time, and he cancelled. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Gus could not cancel, because he waived the original delivery date.
- Gus could cancel, having made time essential by notice.Correct answer
- Gus could not cancel, because time is never of the essence in a sale.
- Gus could cancel only if he paid for the work already done.
- Gus could not cancel, because four weeks was too short a period.
Where time of delivery was originally of the essence but the buyer waived the date by continuing to press for delivery, he could not then terminate immediately for lateness. He could, however, make time of the essence again by giving reasonable notice fixing a new date. Gus's four weeks' notice was reasonable, and Hale failed to deliver within it, so Gus was entitled to cancel. The tempting answer treats waiver as permanent, but the waiver could be ended by reasonable notice making time essential again.
Law basis: Charles Rickards Ltd v Oppenhaim [1950] 1 KB 616Question 14 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Ion Ltd bought a batch of steel pipes for its business from Jax Ltd. They were delivered in January. Ion inspected them, stored them and used some in its own projects. In September it discovered that they did not meet the required standard and sought to reject the entire batch. Which of the following best describes Ion's position?
- Ion may reject, because the breach of quality was a breach of condition.
- Ion may reject, provided it returns any unused pipes promptly.
- Ion may reject, because it discovered the defect only in September.
- Ion may not reject, because business buyers can never reject goods.
- Ion may not reject, as it is deemed to have accepted the goods.Correct answer
A non-consumer buyer loses the right to reject goods once it has accepted them. It is deemed to have accepted them when it intimates acceptance, does an act inconsistent with the seller's ownership after delivery, or retains them beyond a reasonable time without intimating rejection, having had a reasonable opportunity to examine them. Ion inspected and used the pipes and kept them for many months, so it has accepted them and is limited to damages. The tempting answer relies on the late discovery, but Ion had a reasonable opportunity to examine.
Law basis: Sale of Goods Act 1979, ss 11(4) and 35 ↗Question 15 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Kay and Lin entered into a partnership agreement containing a clause referring all disputes 'in respect of this agreement' to arbitration. Lin later repudiated the agreement, and Kay accepted the repudiation. When Kay sued for damages in court, Lin applied to stay the proceedings in favour of arbitration. Kay argued that the arbitration clause ended with the contract. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The clause survives, as it governs disputes arising from the breach.Correct answer
- The clause ended, because acceptance of repudiation discharges every term.
- The clause ended, because Lin cannot rely on a contract he repudiated.
- The clause survives, but only if Kay consents to arbitration.
- The clause ended, because the contract was treated as void from the outset.
When a repudiation is accepted, the contract is not rescinded from the beginning. The parties are discharged from further performance of their primary obligations, but the contract continues to govern the consequences of the breach. An arbitration clause, whose purpose is to settle disputes arising under the contract, survives termination. Lin could therefore rely on it. The tempting answer equates termination for breach with rescission ab initio, which would wipe out the clause, but that is the effect of rescission for misrepresentation, not of termination for breach.
Law basis: Heyman v Darwins Ltd [1942] AC 356Question 16 · Discharge by performance and breachDraft, pending solicitor review
Mio sold a consignment of rice to Nox Ltd for its business, payment due 30 days after delivery. Nox paid five days late. Market prices had risen, and Mio claimed to be entitled to treat the contract as repudiated and to recover the rice. The contract said nothing about whether time of payment was of the essence. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Mio may terminate, because prompt payment is always a condition.
- Mio may not terminate, unless the delay exceeded 30 days.
- Mio may terminate, because the market price had risen since delivery.
- Mio may not terminate, as time of payment is not essential.Correct answer
- Mio may terminate, because every late payment is a breach of warranty.
Unless a different intention appears from the terms of the contract, stipulations about the time of payment are not of the essence of a contract of sale. A short delay in payment is therefore a breach giving rise to damages, such as interest, but does not entitle the seller to terminate unless the delay is so prolonged that it amounts to repudiation, or time has been made of the essence. Nox's five-day delay did not have that effect. The tempting answer treats prompt payment as a condition, which requires express agreement.
Law basis: Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 10(1) ↗More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.