Vera, who ran a café, signed an order form to buy a vending machine. The form contained, in small print, a clause excluding all express and implied warranties. Vera did not read the form, and nobody explained it to her. The machine never worked properly. She argues that she is not bound by the clause. Which of the following best describes the position at common law?
- Vera is not bound, because the clause was in small print and was not drawn to her attention.
- Vera is not bound, because exclusion clauses must be read aloud before signature.
- Vera is bound, because a person who signs a contractual document is bound by its terms.Correct answer
- Vera is bound only if she had dealt with the seller on the same terms before.
- Vera is not bound, because an unread document cannot form part of a contract.
At common law, a person who signs a document containing contractual terms is bound by them, whether or not she has read them, in the absence of fraud or misrepresentation. Vera signed the order form, so the exclusion clause was incorporated. Whether it is effective is a separate question, controlled now by statute. The tempting answer applies the reasonable notice test used for unsigned documents such as tickets, but that test does not apply where the document has been signed.
Law basis: L'Estrange v F Graucob Ltd [1934] 2 KB 394