Law covered in these questions
- Misrepresentation Act 1967 ss 2(1), 2(2)
- Derry v Peek (1889) 14 App Cas 337
- Royscot Trust Ltd v Rogerson [1991] 2 QB 297
- Bisset v Wilkinson [1927] AC 177
- Smith v Land and House Property Corp (1884) 28 Ch D 7
- Dimmock v Hallett (1866) LR 2 Ch App 21
- With v O'Flanagan [1936] Ch 575
- Edgington v Fitzmaurice (1885) 29 Ch D 459
- Redgrave v Hurd (1881) 20 Ch D 1
- Attwood v Small (1838) 6 Cl & F 232
- Misrepresentation Act 1967, s 2(1)
- Howard Marine and Dredging Co Ltd v A Ogden & Sons (Excavations) Ltd [1978] QB 574
- Misrepresentation Act 1967, s 2(2)
- Long v Lloyd [1958] 1 WLR 753
All 19 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Gareth bought a used van from Hana after Hana told him it had never been in an accident. Hana had not checked the van's history, but she had no reason to think the statement was untrue. The statement was false, and Gareth had to pay £2,500 for structural repairs. Which statement best describes Gareth's position under the Misrepresentation Act 1967?
- Gareth can only rescind the contract, because damages are unavailable for any non-fraudulent misrepresentation.
- Gareth can recover damages under s 2(1) only if he proves that Hana owed him a duty of care and was careless.
- Gareth has no remedy, because a statement about the history of goods is only an opinion.
- Gareth can recover damages only if he proves that Hana made the statement fraudulently.
- Gareth can claim damages under s 2(1) unless Hana proves she had reasonable grounds to believe, and did believe, the statement was true; he need not prove fraud or negligence.Correct answer
Question 2 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Dara bought a sheep farm in New Zealand from Ewan. Ewan, who had never farmed sheep on the land, told her that in his judgement it could carry 2,000 sheep. Both knew the land had never been used for sheep. In fact it could carry far fewer. Dara seeks to rescind for misrepresentation. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Dara cannot rescind, as the statement was an honest opinion.Correct answer
- Dara can rescind, because Ewan's statement about capacity was untrue.
- Dara can rescind, because a seller is presumed to have special knowledge.
- Dara cannot rescind, because statements about land are never actionable.
- Dara can rescind, but only if she can show that Ewan was negligent.
A misrepresentation must be a false statement of existing fact or law, not merely a statement of opinion. Whether a statement is one of fact or opinion depends on the circumstances, including the parties' relative knowledge. As both knew the land had never been used for sheep, Ewan was in no better position than Dara to judge, and his honest statement was only an opinion. The tempting answer focuses on the statement being untrue, but an honestly held opinion is not a misrepresentation merely because it proves wrong.
Law basis: Bisset v Wilkinson [1927] AC 177Question 3 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Fion sold a hotel to Gant, describing the current tenant as 'a most desirable tenant'. In fact the tenant had been in arrears for months and paid only under pressure. Fion knew this. Gant bought relying on the description. Fion argues that the statement was merely an opinion. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The statement was an opinion, so it cannot found a claim in misrepresentation.
- The statement implied facts Fion knew were untrue, so it is actionable.Correct answer
- The statement was a mere puff, which no reasonable buyer would rely upon.
- The statement was actionable only if Fion had expressly warranted its accuracy.
- The statement was an opinion, but Gant can claim breach of an implied warranty.
A statement of opinion may carry an implied statement of fact, particularly where the maker knows more than the other party. By describing the tenant as most desirable, Fion impliedly stated that he knew of no facts making the tenant undesirable. As he knew of serious arrears, his statement was a misrepresentation of fact. The tempting answer treats the statement as pure opinion, but an opinion given by a person with superior knowledge implies that he has reasonable grounds for it, and Fion had none.
Law basis: Smith v Land and House Property Corp (1884) 28 Ch D 7Question 4 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
When selling his country estate, Hari told Ines that the farms on it were 'fully let'. He did not mention that the tenants had given notice to quit and would leave shortly. Ines bought the estate relying on the statement. She later found the farms empty. Hari argues that his statement was literally true. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is no misrepresentation, because the statement was literally true.
- There is no misrepresentation, because silence can never amount to misrepresentation.
- There is a misrepresentation, because a misleading half-truth can be actionable.Correct answer
- There is a misrepresentation only if Ines asked a specific question about notices.
- There is no misrepresentation, because the tenants' notice was a matter of law.
Although there is generally no duty of disclosure in contract negotiations, a statement which is literally true but misleading because of what is left out can amount to a misrepresentation. By saying the farms were fully let without disclosing that the tenants were leaving, Hari gave a false impression that the farms would continue to be let. This half-truth was a misrepresentation. The tempting answer relies on literal truth, but the courts look at the overall impression created by what was said and omitted.
Law basis: Dimmock v Hallett (1866) LR 2 Ch App 21Question 5 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
In January, Jude, a doctor selling his practice, told Kim that it produced income of £20,000 a year, which was then true. Before contracts were signed in May, Jude fell seriously ill and the income fell sharply as patients left. Jude did not tell Kim. Kim bought the practice. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is no misrepresentation, because the statement was true when made.
- There is no misrepresentation, because the fall was caused by Jude's illness.
- There is no misrepresentation, because Jude was under no duty of disclosure.
- There is a misrepresentation only if Kim asked whether the income had changed.
- There is a misrepresentation, as Jude did not correct his statement.Correct answer
A statement which is true when made, but which becomes false before the contract is concluded, must be corrected if the maker knows of the change. A representation is treated as continuing until the contract is made. Jude's statement about income was continuing, and his failure to correct it after the income fell amounted to a misrepresentation, entitling Kim to rescind. The tempting answer focuses only on the truth of the statement when first made, but the courts treat the duty to correct as part of the representation.
Law basis: With v O'Flanagan [1936] Ch 575Question 6 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
The directors of Lomond plc issued a prospectus inviting the public to take debentures, stating that the money would be used to improve the company's buildings. In fact, the directors intended to use it to pay off pressing debts. Mira took debentures relying partly on this statement and partly on her own mistaken belief that she would have a charge over the property. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is no misrepresentation, because a statement of future intention is not fact.
- There is a misrepresentation only if the directors later spent the money badly.
- There is no misrepresentation, because Mira also relied on her own mistake.
- There is a misrepresentation, as the directors misstated their intention.Correct answer
- There is no misrepresentation, because prospectuses contain only opinions.
A statement of intention is not generally a statement of fact, but if the maker does not actually hold the stated intention, the statement misrepresents his present state of mind, which is a fact. The directors never intended to use the money for buildings, so their statement was a misrepresentation. It is enough that the misrepresentation was one of the inducing causes of the contract, even if the claimant also relied on her own mistake. The tempting answer treats all statements about the future as non-actionable.
Law basis: Edgington v Fitzmaurice (1885) 29 Ch D 459Question 7 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Nyle agreed to buy Odo's solicitor's practice after Odo told him it brought in about £300 a year. Odo offered Nyle the chance to inspect the accounts, which would have shown the true figure was much lower, but Nyle did not do so. Nyle refuses to complete. Odo argues that Nyle could have discovered the truth. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Odo succeeds, because Nyle had the means of discovering the truth.
- Nyle may rescind, as his failure to check the accounts is no bar.Correct answer
- Odo succeeds, because a buyer who fails to check documents is not induced.
- Nyle may rescind only if Odo knew that the statement about income was false.
- Odo succeeds, because Nyle was negligent in not checking the accounts.
Where a misrepresentation is made to induce a contract, it is no answer for the misrepresentor to say that the representee could have discovered the truth by reasonable diligence. Once a material misrepresentation has been made, inducement is readily inferred, and the representee is not required to check its accuracy. Nyle relied on Odo's statement, so he is entitled to rescind. The tempting answer treats the opportunity to check as fatal, but the Court of Appeal held that the representee need not test the truth of what he was told.
Law basis: Redgrave v Hurd (1881) 20 Ch D 1Question 8 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Pax Mining agreed to buy Quarr's mine after Quarr made exaggerated statements about its output. Before contracting, Pax appointed its own experts, who investigated the mine and reported that Quarr's statements were accurate. Pax bought relying on its experts' report. It later sought to rescind on the ground of misrepresentation. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Pax may not rescind, because it relied on its own experts, not on Quarr.Correct answer
- Pax may rescind, because Quarr's statements were false and material.
- Pax may rescind, because a buyer is entitled to rely on a seller's statements.
- Pax may not rescind, because statements about output are opinions.
- Pax may rescind, but only if its experts were also negligent.
A misrepresentation is actionable only if it induced the contract. Where the representee does not rely on the misrepresentation, but instead relies on its own investigation, it has not been induced by the statement and cannot rescind. Pax's experts checked the mine and Pax acted on their report, so Quarr's statements did not induce the contract. The tempting answer focuses on falsity and materiality, which are necessary but not sufficient. This is different from a representee who simply has the opportunity to check but does not do so.
Law basis: Attwood v Small (1838) 6 Cl & F 232Question 9 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
The directors of a tramway company issued a prospectus stating that the company had the right to use steam power. They honestly believed this, because they assumed the Board of Trade's consent, which was needed, would be a formality. Consent was refused. Shareholders who bought on the strength of the statement sued the directors in the tort of deceit. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The directors are liable, because their statement was false and careless.
- The directors are not liable, because the statement concerned a future event.
- The directors are liable, because they had no reasonable grounds for their belief.
- The directors are not liable in deceit, as their belief was honest.Correct answer
- The directors are liable, because the prospectus was a contractual document.
Fraudulent misrepresentation requires a false statement made knowingly, without belief in its truth, or recklessly, careless whether it be true or false. An honest belief, even if unreasonable, negates fraud. The directors honestly believed that they had the right to use steam power, so they were not liable in deceit. The tempting answers treat carelessness or the absence of reasonable grounds as enough, but those may support liability for negligent misrepresentation, not fraud. Under modern law a claim under the Misrepresentation Act 1967 would also be considered.
Law basis: Derry v Peek (1889) 14 App Cas 337Question 10 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Rafe bought a car on hire-purchase through a dealer, who innocently but carelessly overstated Rafe's deposit to the finance company, Sole Finance. Rafe sold the car unlawfully and defaulted. Sole claimed damages from the dealer for misrepresentation under statute. The dealer argues that the loss was not reasonably foreseeable. Which of the following best describes the measure of damages?
- Damages are limited to losses that were reasonably foreseeable, as in negligence.
- Damages are limited to the difference between the price and the car's actual value.
- Damages are assessed on the fraud measure, covering all direct losses.Correct answer
- Damages are limited to losses the parties contemplated when contracting.
- Damages are nominal, because the dealer acted innocently in making the statement.
Where a person has entered into a contract after a misrepresentation by the other party and has suffered loss, the misrepresentor is liable as if the statement were fraudulent unless he proves that he had reasonable grounds to believe, and did believe up to the time of contracting, that the facts represented were true. The Court of Appeal held that this 'fiction of fraud' means damages are assessed on the tort of deceit measure, covering all losses directly flowing, whether or not foreseeable. The tempting answer applies the negligence measure.
Law basis: Misrepresentation Act 1967, s 2(1); Royscot Trust Ltd v Rogerson [1991] 2 QB 297 ↗Question 11 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Tarn Ltd hired two barges from Unit Marine Ltd. During negotiations Unit's marine manager stated that each barge could carry 1,600 tonnes, relying on his memory of an entry in Lloyd's Register. In fact Unit's own shipping documents, which he had seen, showed that the capacity was 1,055 tonnes. Tarn claims damages under statute. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Unit is not liable, because the manager honestly believed what he said.
- Unit is not liable, because statements of capacity are opinions.
- Unit is not liable, because it relied on an authoritative published register.
- Unit is liable only if Tarn can prove the manager was negligent.
- Unit is liable, because it cannot show reasonable grounds for the belief.Correct answer
Under the statute, once a misrepresentation is shown, the burden is on the representor to prove that he had reasonable grounds to believe, and did believe, that the facts represented were true. Honest belief is not enough. The manager had seen Unit's own documents, which gave the correct capacity, so he could not show reasonable grounds for relying on his memory of the register. Unit was liable. The tempting answer focuses on honest belief, but this is a statutory claim in which the defendant must also prove reasonable grounds.
Law basis: Howard Marine and Dredging Co Ltd v A Ogden & Sons (Excavations) Ltd [1978] QB 574; Misrepresentation Act 1967, s 2(1) ↗Question 12 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Ash bought a flat from Bryn for £400,000. Bryn innocently and reasonably stated that the service charge was £1,200 a year; it was in fact £1,350. Property prices have since fallen sharply, and Ash, relying on the misstatement, seeks to rescind the purchase and recover the full price. Which of the following best describes the court's powers?
- The court must order rescission, because Ash has proved an operative misrepresentation.
- The court may refuse rescission and award damages in lieu if that would be equitable.Correct answer
- The court must refuse any remedy, because Bryn had reasonable grounds for his belief.
- The court may award damages in lieu only if Bryn agrees to that course being taken.
- The court must order rescission, but may also require Ash to pay for the fall in value.
Where a person entitled to rescind for a non-fraudulent misrepresentation claims rescission, the court may declare the contract subsisting and award damages in lieu if it would be equitable to do so, having regard to the nature of the misrepresentation, the loss that would be caused if the contract were upheld and the loss rescission would cause the other party. The misstatement was minor, while rescission would throw a large market loss onto Bryn, so damages in lieu are likely. The tempting answer treats rescission as automatic once misrepresentation is proved.
Law basis: Misrepresentation Act 1967, s 2(2) ↗Question 13 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Cole bought a lorry from Dent after Dent said it was 'in exceptional condition'. On Cole's first trip the dynamo failed and an oil seal leaked. Dent agreed to pay half the cost of a new dynamo. Cole then took the lorry on a second long trip, during which it broke down completely. Cole now seeks to rescind. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Cole can rescind, because Dent's statement was a misrepresentation.
- Cole can rescind, provided he returns the lorry in its present condition.
- Cole can rescind, because he only learned the full extent of defects later.
- Cole has lost the right to rescind, because he waited longer than seven days.
- Cole has lost the right to rescind, having affirmed the contract.Correct answer
The right to rescind for misrepresentation is lost if the representee, with knowledge of the misrepresentation, affirms the contract by words or conduct. After the first trip Cole knew of serious defects inconsistent with the description, yet he accepted Dent's offer to share repair costs and used the lorry again for a second trip. That conduct affirmed the contract, so he could no longer rescind. The tempting answer argues that he did not know the full extent of the defects, but knowledge of the falsity of the statement was enough.
Law basis: Long v Lloyd [1958] 1 WLR 753Question 14 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Eve bought a painting from Fine Galleries Ltd after the gallery innocently told her it was by Constable. Five years later, when she tried to sell it, she discovered it was not by Constable. She immediately claimed to rescind. No term of the contract was relied on. Which of the following best describes Eve's position?
- She can rescind, because she acted as soon as she discovered the truth.
- She can rescind, because the gallery is a business dealing with a consumer.
- She cannot rescind, because too much time has passed since the sale.Correct answer
- She cannot rescind, because the statement was a mere expression of opinion.
- She can rescind, provided she returns the painting in its original condition.
The right to rescind for innocent misrepresentation may be barred by lapse of time. In the leading case the Court of Appeal held that a buyer who discovered after five years that a painting was not by Constable could not rescind, because she had had ample opportunity to examine it and a reasonable time had passed. Lapse of time runs from the contract, not from discovery, in cases of innocent misrepresentation. The tempting answer focuses on prompt action after discovery, which would be more relevant in a case of fraud.
Law basis: Leaf v International Galleries [1950] 2 KB 86Question 15 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Gale sold his car to a rogue, Hix, who paid with a cheque that bounced. Gale discovered the fraud the next day but could not find Hix. He immediately told the police and the AA, asking them to recover the car. A week later Hix sold the car to Ida, who bought it in good faith. Which of the following best describes who owns the car?
- Ida, because she bought in good faith before Gale contacted Hix directly.
- Gale, because a contract induced by fraud is always void from the outset.
- Ida, because a contract induced by fraud remains valid until set aside by court.
- Gale, because he rescinded before the sale by notifying police and the AA.Correct answer
- Ida, because Gale's notification was not made in writing to Hix.
A contract induced by fraudulent misrepresentation is voidable, not void. Rescission normally requires notice to the other party, but where a rogue deliberately absconds so that notice cannot be given, the representee can rescind by taking all reasonable steps to show his intention, such as informing the police and a motoring organisation. Gale did this before Hix sold the car, so title had revested in Gale and Ida acquired none. The tempting answer insists on direct communication, which the rogue made impossible.
Law basis: Car and Universal Finance Co Ltd v Caldwell [1965] 1 QB 525Question 16 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Jae took a lease of premises to breed prize poultry after the landlord innocently told him they were in a sanitary condition. The drains were defective, Jae's manager fell ill and the poultry died. Under the lease Jae had to pay the rates and carry out repairs ordered by the local authority. He has rescinded and now seeks an indemnity for all his losses. Which of the following best describes what he can recover by way of indemnity?
- Only the rates and repair costs he incurred under the lease's terms.Correct answer
- All his losses, including the value of the poultry and lost profits.
- Nothing, because an indemnity is unavailable for innocent misrepresentation.
- Only the value of the poultry, as the loss flowing directly from the drains.
- All his losses, because indemnity follows the measure for fraud.
On rescission for innocent misrepresentation, the representee is entitled to an indemnity covering obligations necessarily created by the contract itself, but not to damages for consequential losses. Jae could recover the rates and repairs he was bound to pay under the lease, but not the value of the poultry, the loss of profit or medical expenses, which were not obligations created by the contract. The tempting answer gives full compensatory recovery, which would require a damages claim, for example under statute, rather than an indemnity.
Law basis: Whittington v Seale-Hayne (1900) 82 LT 49Question 17 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Kova Ltd, a band's management company, agreed a sponsorship deal with Lumi Scooters. Before the contract, the band took part in a commercial shoot for Lumi, conduct which implied that all five members would remain in the band for the contract term. Kova knew one member intended to leave and had told the others. She left soon after the contract was signed. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is no misrepresentation, because nothing false was actually said.
- There is no misrepresentation, because a statement of future intention is not fact.
- There is a misrepresentation by conduct, actionable by Lumi.Correct answer
- There is a misrepresentation only if the contract required all five to remain.
- There is no misrepresentation, because Kova owed Lumi no duty of disclosure.
A misrepresentation need not be made in words; it can be made by conduct. The Court of Appeal held that by participating in the commercial shoot, knowing a member intended to leave, the company represented that it did not know and had no reasonable grounds to believe that any member would leave during the term. This was false and induced the contract. The tempting answer looks only for an express statement, while the point about future intention fails because the representation concerned present knowledge.
Law basis: Spice Girls Ltd v Aprilia World Service BV [2002] EWCA Civ 15Question 18 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Mora bought shares in a company at 82p each, induced by a fraudulent misrepresentation by the seller's broker that other bidders were interested. Unknown to anyone, the company was itself the victim of a separate large fraud, which later came to light and caused the shares to fall to about 44p. Mora sold them at a loss. Which of the following best describes her damages for deceit?
- She recovers only the difference between 82p and the market value on the purchase date.
- She recovers all losses flowing directly from the purchase, including the later fall.Correct answer
- She recovers only losses that were reasonably foreseeable when she bought the shares.
- She recovers nothing beyond nominal damages, because the later fraud broke the chain.
- She recovers the price paid but must account for any dividends she received.
In the tort of deceit, the defendant is liable for all damage directly flowing from the fraudulently induced transaction, whether or not it was foreseeable. The date-of-transaction rule is not inflexible; where the claimant was locked into the property by the fraud, the court may assess loss by reference to the price later realised. The House of Lords held that the buyer could recover the difference between the price paid and the price at which she later sold. The tempting answer applies the usual date-of-transaction measure rigidly.
Law basis: Smith New Court Securities Ltd v Scrimgeour Vickers (Asset Management) Ltd [1997] AC 254Question 19 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Nita bought land at auction from a council. The council's particulars stated that the occupiers were licensees who could be removed. In fact, as a matter of law, they were protected business tenants whose occupation could not easily be ended. Nita seeks a remedy. The council argues that a misstatement of law cannot be a misrepresentation. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The council is right, because misrepresentations must concern facts, not law.
- The council is wrong, but only because it acted fraudulently in the sale.
- The council is right, because Nita could have taken her own legal advice.
- The council is wrong, because a misrepresentation of law is now actionable.Correct answer
- The council is right, because statements in auction particulars are opinions.
The old rule that a misrepresentation of law is not actionable has been abandoned. Following the House of Lords' recognition that money paid under a mistake of law can be recovered, the High Court held that a misrepresentation of law can found a claim. The statement that the occupiers were licensees was a false statement of law which induced the purchase, so Nita can claim. The tempting answer relies on the outdated fact/law distinction. It is irrelevant that she could have taken her own advice, and fraud is not required.
Law basis: Pankhania v Hackney LBC [2002] EWHC 2441 (Ch)More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.