Law covered in these questions
- Bell v Lever Brothers Ltd [1932] AC 161
- Great Peace Shipping Ltd v Tsavliris Salvage (International) Ltd [2002] EWCA Civ 1407
- Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 6
- Couturier v Hastie (1856) 5 HLC 673
- Raffles v Wichelhaus (1864) 2 H & C 906
- Smith v Hughes (1871) LR 6 QB 597
- Hartog v Colin & Shields [1939] 3 All ER 566
- Shogun Finance Ltd v Hudson [2003] UKHL 62
- Lewis v Averay [1972] 1 QB 198
- Phillips v Brooks Ltd [1919] 2 KB 243
- Cundy v Lindsay (1878) 3 App Cas 459
- Saunders v Anglia Building Society [1971] AC 1004
All 10 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
Orla, chair of Pyx Ltd, agreed to retire early in return for a £30,000 compensation payment. Pyx later discovered that, while chair, Orla had committed breaches of duty that would have allowed it to dismiss her without compensation. Neither party had thought about this when the agreement was made. Pyx seeks to recover the payment. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The agreement is valid, as the mistake did not make it essentially different.Correct answer
- The agreement is void, because Pyx would never have paid had it known the truth.
- The agreement is voidable, because Orla should have remembered her breaches.
- The agreement is void, because both parties made the same fundamental mistake.
- The agreement is valid only if Orla can show she acted in good faith throughout.
A common mistake as to quality renders a contract void only if it makes the subject matter essentially and radically different from what the parties believed it to be. The House of Lords held that a compensation agreement with employees who could have been dismissed was not void, because Pyx obtained what it bargained for, namely the termination of the service agreement. The mistake made the deal worse for Pyx but did not change its essential identity. The tempting answer focuses on what Pyx would have done had it known.
Law basis: Bell v Lever Brothers Ltd [1932] AC 161Question 2 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
Quest Salvage needed a ship to stand by a stricken vessel. Believing a ship called Rover to be about 35 miles away, it chartered her for five days. Rover was in fact about 400 miles away, a journey of 39 hours. Quest found a nearer ship and cancelled, refusing to pay the hire. Rover's owners sue. Quest argues the contract is void or voidable for common mistake. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The contract is void, because both parties were mistaken about a significant fact.
- The contract is voidable, so Quest may cancel on paying a reasonable fee.
- The contract is voidable in equity, because the mistake was fundamental.
- The contract is void, because Quest would not have chartered a distant ship.
- The contract is not void, as performance was not rendered essentially different.Correct answer
A common mistake makes a contract void only if, without fault, it renders performance impossible or essentially different from what the parties contemplated. Rover could still have reached the stricken vessel in time to provide useful assistance, and Quest did not cancel until it found a nearer ship, so performance was not essentially different. The Court of Appeal also held that there is no separate equitable jurisdiction to rescind a contract for a common mistake that does not render it void. Quest must pay the hire.
Law basis: Great Peace Shipping Ltd v Tsavliris Salvage (International) Ltd [2002] EWCA Civ 1407Question 3 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
Raj agreed to sell Sana a specific cargo of corn which both believed to be at sea. Unknown to both, the cargo had already overheated and been sold off at a port by the ship's master before the contract was made, so it no longer existed as a cargo. Sana refuses to pay. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The contract is valid, and the risk of loss passed to Sana on contracting.
- The contract is valid, but Sana may claim damages for non-delivery.
- The contract is void, as the goods had perished before it was made.Correct answer
- The contract is voidable at Sana's option, as the mistake was fundamental.
- The contract is valid, because Raj impliedly warranted that the goods existed.
Where there is a contract for the sale of specific goods, and the goods without the knowledge of the seller have perished at the time the contract is made, the contract is void. This reflects the common law rule that a contract is void where the subject matter does not exist at the time of contracting. The cargo had ceased to exist as a commercial entity before contracting, so the contract was void and Sana need not pay. The tempting answer allocates the risk to Sana, but risk cannot pass under a contract that never came into existence.
Law basis: Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 6; Couturier v Hastie (1856) 5 HLC 673 ↗Question 4 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
Tom agreed to buy from Una a cargo of cotton 'to arrive ex Peerless from Bombay'. Unknown to either, two ships called Peerless were sailing from Bombay, one in October and one in December. Tom meant the October ship; Una meant the December ship. When the December cargo arrived, Tom refused it. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a contract for the October cargo, as that ship sailed first.
- There is no contract, because the ambiguity prevented any agreement.Correct answer
- There is a contract for the December cargo, because Una was the seller.
- There is a contract, but Tom may claim damages for late delivery.
- There is no contract, because Una was under a duty to identify the ship.
Agreement is assessed objectively, but where the terms are so ambiguous that a reasonable person could not say which meaning was intended, there is no agreement. There were two ships called Peerless, each party meant a different one, and nothing pointed objectively to either. There was therefore no binding contract. The tempting answers pick one party's meaning on arbitrary grounds, such as which ship sailed first. The court cannot impose a meaning where the objective evidence is equally consistent with both.
Law basis: Raffles v Wichelhaus (1864) 2 H & C 906Question 5 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
Vito, a racehorse trainer, inspected a sample of oats offered by Wade, a farmer, and agreed to buy them. Vito wanted old oats and believed these were old, but Wade said nothing about their age and made no representation. The oats were new and unsuitable for Vito's horses. Wade knew Vito might think they were old. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The contract is binding, as Vito's mistake was only about quality.Correct answer
- The contract is void, because Vito was mistaken about a fundamental quality.
- The contract is void, because Wade knew of Vito's mistake and kept silent.
- The contract is voidable for Wade's misrepresentation by silence.
- The contract is binding only if the sample matched the bulk delivered.
A unilateral mistake as to the quality of the subject matter does not affect the validity of a contract, even if the other party knows of it, provided he has not caused it by misrepresentation. There is no general duty to disclose facts. Vito bought the oats he inspected, and Wade did not represent that they were old. The contract is binding. The position would be different if Vito had believed that Wade was promising the oats were old, and Wade knew this, because that would be a mistake as to the terms.
Law basis: Smith v Hughes (1871) LR 6 QB 597Question 6 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
Xia offered to sell Yale 30,000 hare skins 'at 10d per pound'. All previous negotiations had been on a price per piece, which was the trade custom, and per-pound pricing would have given the skins away at about a third of their value. Yale accepted at once and sued when Xia refused to deliver. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a contract at the price per pound, because Yale accepted the offer as made.
- There is no contract, because a mistake as to price always prevents agreement.
- There is a contract at the price per piece, under the trade's custom.
- There is a contract, but Xia may claim the difference in price as damages.
- There is no contract, as Yale must have known that the offer was a mistake.Correct answer
Where one party is mistaken about the terms of the offer and the other party knows, or must reasonably have known, of the mistake, the offeree cannot snap up the offer and hold the offeror to it. All negotiations had been per piece, and the price per pound was absurdly low, so Yale must have realised the offer did not reflect Xia's intention. There was no binding contract. The tempting answer applies objective agreement without the exception for known mistakes as to terms. The court does not rewrite the price per piece.
Law basis: Hartog v Colin & Shields [1939] 3 All ER 566Question 7 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
A rogue, using a stolen driving licence, posed as Mr Patel and agreed in a dealer's showroom to buy a car on hire-purchase from Zest Finance. Zest checked Mr Patel's credit by reference to the licence and approved the written agreement in Mr Patel's name, which the rogue signed. The rogue sold the car to Abe, who bought in good faith. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Abe gets good title, because the dealings were face to face in the showroom.
- Abe gets no title, because a hire-purchase agreement can never pass title.
- Abe gets good title, because Zest's contract was merely voidable for fraud.
- Abe gets no title, as the written agreement was with Mr Patel.Correct answer
- Abe gets good title, because Zest failed to check the rogue's identity in person.
Where a contract is made in writing, the identity of the parties is determined by construing the document. The House of Lords held that the hire-purchase agreement was with the person named in it, Mr Patel, who had not authorised it, so there was no contract with the rogue. The rogue therefore had nothing to pass, and the statutory protection for private purchasers of vehicles on hire-purchase did not apply. The tempting answer applies the face-to-face presumption, but that presumption does not govern a written agreement.
Law basis: Shogun Finance Ltd v Hudson [2003] UKHL 62Question 8 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
Bea advertised her car for sale. A man came to her flat, said he was a well-known actor and, when asked for proof, produced a studio pass bearing that name. Bea let him take the car in exchange for a cheque, which bounced. He was a rogue, and he sold the car to Cal, a student who bought in good faith. Bea sues Cal. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Bea succeeds, because the contract was void for mistake as to identity.
- Cal keeps the car, because Bea was negligent in accepting a cheque.
- Bea succeeds, because she asked for and relied on proof of identity.
- Cal keeps the car, as the contract with the rogue was only voidable.Correct answer
- Bea succeeds, because a contract induced by fraud is always void.
Where parties deal face to face, there is a strong presumption that each intends to contract with the person in front of them, whatever name that person gives. A mistake as to the attributes or identity of that person therefore makes the contract voidable for fraud, not void. As Bea had not rescinded before the rogue sold the car, Cal acquired good title as a good faith purchaser. The tempting answer treats the request for proof as showing that identity was crucial, but the Court of Appeal held the presumption was not rebutted.
Law basis: Lewis v Averay [1972] 1 QB 198; Phillips v Brooks Ltd [1919] 2 KB 243Question 9 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
A rogue named Blenk, writing from 37 Wood Street, ordered handkerchiefs by post from Dove Ltd, signing in a way that looked like 'Blenkiron & Co', a reputable firm at 123 Wood Street known to Dove. Dove sent the goods to 'Blenkiron & Co, 37 Wood Street'. Blenk sold them to Eli, who bought in good faith. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Eli gets no title, because Dove's contract was void for mistake as to identity.Correct answer
- Eli gets good title, because Dove intended to deal with whoever wrote the letter.
- Eli gets good title, because Dove sent the goods to the address given.
- Eli gets no title, because the rogue's fraud made the contract voidable.
- Eli gets good title, because a contract by post is always with the writer.
Where parties contract at a distance, a mistake as to identity can render the contract void if the mistaken party intended to deal with a specific, existing third party and the other party knew it. Dove intended to deal only with the reputable firm Blenkiron & Co, and Blenk knew this, so there was no contract with Blenk. As the contract was void, Blenk had no title to pass and Eli acquired none. The tempting answer treats the rogue's fraud as making the contract merely voidable, which would have protected Eli.
Law basis: Cundy v Lindsay (1878) 3 App Cas 459Question 10 · MistakeDraft, pending solicitor review
Fay, aged 78, wanted to help her nephew raise money on her house. Her nephew's business partner gave her a document to sign, saying it was a deed of gift to the nephew. She did not read it because her glasses were broken. It was in fact a sale of the house to the partner, who mortgaged it to a building society. Fay pleads non est factum. Which of the following best describes the position?
- She succeeds, because she did not read the document she signed.
- She succeeds, because she was induced to sign by a fraudulent misrepresentation.
- She succeeds, because she was elderly and her glasses were broken.
- She fails, because non est factum is only available to persons who are illiterate.
- She fails, because the document was not radically different and she was careless.Correct answer
Non est factum is available only where the signer was, through no fault of her own, unable to understand the document, and the document was radically different from what she believed it to be. Fay knew she was signing a document dealing with her house to help raise money for her nephew, so it was not radically different in character, and she was careless in signing without reading it. The House of Lords refused the plea. The tempting answer treats failure to read as enough, but that is precisely the carelessness that defeats the plea.
Law basis: Saunders v Anglia Building Society [1971] AC 1004More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.