Law covered in these questions
- Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341
- Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd [1949] 2 KB 528
- Transfield Shipping Inc v Mercator Shipping Inc (The Achilleas) [2008] UKHL 48
- Koufos v C Czarnikow Ltd (The Heron II) [1969] 1 AC 350
- H Parsons (Livestock) Ltd v Uttley Ingham & Co Ltd [1978] QB 791
- Wellesley Partners LLP v Withers LLP [2015] EWCA Civ 1146
- British Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd [1912] AC 673
- Payzu Ltd v Saunders [1919] 2 KB 581
- Pilkington v Wood [1953] Ch 770
- Banco de Portugal v Waterlow & Sons Ltd [1932] AC 452
- Quinn v Burch Bros (Builders) Ltd [1966] 2 QB 370
- Barclays Bank plc v Fairclough Building Ltd [1995] QB 214
- Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945, s 1
- Lambert v Lewis [1982] AC 225
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Vector Ltd, a printing business, contracted to buy a specialised machine from Ruka Ltd for £40,000, to be delivered on 1 June. Ruka delivered six weeks late, in breach. Ruka knew Vector was a printing business but did not know that Vector had won a one-off, unusually lucrative contract that depended on the machine. Vector lost its normal profits from ordinary printing work during the delay, and also the exceptional profit on the one-off contract. Which statement best describes the recoverable loss?
- Vector can recover neither loss, because lost profits are always too remote in contract.
- Vector can recover neither loss unless Ruka expressly agreed in the contract to be liable for lost profits.
- Vector can recover both losses if they were foreseeable at the date of the breach, rather than at the date of the contract.
- Vector can recover both losses, because both were factually caused by the breach.
- Vector can recover its normal lost profits, but can recover the exceptional profit only if the special circumstances were within the parties' contemplation when the contract was made.Correct answer
Under the rule in Hadley v Baxendale, loss recoverable is that arising naturally from the breach or in the reasonable contemplation of both parties at the time of contracting. Normal profits meet that test, but an unusually lucrative contract not made known to the defendant does not.
Law basis: Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341; Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd [1949] 2 KB 528; Transfield Shipping Inc v Mercator Shipping Inc (The Achilleas) [2008] UKHL 48Question 2 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Kip's mill was stopped because its crankshaft broke. He sent it with a carrier to engineers in Greenwich to be copied, but did not tell the carrier that the mill could not work without it. The carrier delayed delivery by several days, and Kip lost profits during that time. Which of the following best describes Kip's claim for lost profits?
- He recovers lost profits, because the delay was a breach of contract.
- He recovers half his lost profits, reflecting the carrier's partial fault.
- He recovers lost profits, because mills ordinarily stop without crankshafts.
- He cannot recover lost profits, because carriers are never liable for delay.
- He cannot recover lost profits, as they were too remote.Correct answer
Damages are recoverable for losses arising naturally, according to the usual course of things, from the breach, or which may reasonably be supposed to have been in the contemplation of both parties when they made the contract as the probable result of the breach. Mills usually had spare crankshafts, so lost profits did not arise naturally from the delay, and the carrier had not been told of the special circumstances. The loss was too remote. The tempting answer assumes the mill's stoppage was the ordinary consequence of delay, but that was not the usual course of things.
Law basis: Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341Question 3 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Lark Laundries bought a large boiler from Mint Engineering for its expanding business, Mint knowing Lark wanted it for immediate use. Mint delivered five months late. Lark lost ordinary profits during the delay and also lost exceptionally lucrative dyeing contracts with a government department, of which Mint knew nothing. Which of the following best describes Lark's recovery?
- Lark recovers all its lost profits, because Mint knew of the need for immediate use.
- Lark recovers nothing, because lost profits are always too remote.
- Lark recovers ordinary lost profits, but not the dyeing contract profits.Correct answer
- Lark recovers the dyeing contract profits only, as they were the main loss.
- Lark recovers only the difference in value of the boiler at the two dates.
A defendant is liable for losses within its reasonable contemplation at the time of contracting, which depends on its knowledge. Mint knew Lark was a laundry wanting the boiler for immediate use, so it was liable for the ordinary loss of profits Lark would suffer from the delay. It was not liable for the especially lucrative dyeing contracts, of which it had no knowledge, because that loss was not within its contemplation. The tempting answer allows all profits to be recovered because of the general knowledge of immediate use.
Law basis: Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd [1949] 2 KB 528Question 4 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Nova chartered Oslo's ship to carry sugar to Basrah, where Nova intended to sell it. In breach, Oslo deviated and arrived nine days late. In the meantime, the market price of sugar at Basrah fell. Oslo did not know Nova intended to sell immediately, but knew there was a sugar market at Basrah. Nova claims the fall in price. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Nova cannot recover, because market price falls are inherently unpredictable.
- Nova recovers the fall in price, as it was a not unlikely result of delay.Correct answer
- Nova cannot recover, because Oslo did not know Nova meant to sell on arrival.
- Nova recovers the fall in price, but only if it was reasonably foreseeable.
- Nova cannot recover, because the deviation was not a breach of contract.
In contract, a loss is not too remote if it was within the reasonable contemplation of the parties at the time of contracting as not unlikely to result from the breach. This requires a higher degree of probability than the tort test of reasonable foreseeability. The House of Lords held that a carrier who knew there was a market for sugar at the port must have contemplated that, if delivery was delayed, a fall in the market price was not unlikely. Nova could recover. The tempting answer applies the tort test, which the House distinguished.
Law basis: Koufos v C Czarnikow Ltd (The Heron II) [1969] 1 AC 350Question 5 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Pip, a pig farmer, bought a bulk food hopper from Quay Ltd, which installed it with the ventilator sealed. As a result, the pig nuts went mouldy. Many pigs fell ill with a rare intestinal infection and 254 died. Quay argues that, although some illness was foreseeable, it could not have contemplated such a serious infection. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Quay is not liable, because the extent of the illness was not contemplated.
- Quay is not liable, because the infection was rare and unpredictable.
- Quay is not liable, because death of livestock is always too remote.
- Quay is liable only for the cost of the mouldy food, not the pigs.
- Quay is liable, as illness of the pigs was the type of loss contemplated.Correct answer
For remoteness in contract, it is sufficient that the type or kind of loss was within the parties' reasonable contemplation as a serious possibility; the precise manner or extent of the loss need not have been contemplated. The parties would have contemplated that feeding mouldy nuts to pigs gave rise to a serious possibility of illness, so the deaths from infection were within the type of loss contemplated. The Court of Appeal held the supplier liable. The tempting answer focuses on the unforeseeable severity, but extent is not the test.
Law basis: H Parsons (Livestock) Ltd v Uttley Ingham & Co Ltd [1978] QB 791Question 6 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Rho Shipping chartered its vessel to Sigma Lines, with redelivery due by 2 May. Sigma redelivered nine days late. Because of the delay, Rho lost a lucrative follow-on charter it had fixed with another charterer, at a time when market rates were falling sharply. Rho claims the loss on the follow-on charter. Market understanding was that charterers were liable only for the difference between market and charter rates during the overrun. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Rho recovers the full loss on the follow-on charter, as it was foreseeable.
- Rho recovers nothing, because late redelivery is not a breach of charter.
- Rho recovers only the overrun loss, as Sigma did not assume more.Correct answer
- Rho recovers the follow-on loss, because Sigma knew of Rho's other fixture.
- Rho recovers half the follow-on loss, reflecting the volatile market.
The House of Lords held that a contract-breaker is liable only for loss of a type for which it can reasonably be regarded as having assumed responsibility. Although loss of a follow-on fixture was foreseeable, the general understanding in the shipping market was that a charterer's liability for late redelivery was limited to the difference between the market and charter rates for the overrun period. Sigma had not assumed responsibility for the wider, unquantifiable loss. The tempting answer applies foreseeability alone, but the assumption of responsibility approach excluded the larger claim.
Law basis: Transfield Shipping Inc v Mercator Shipping Inc (The Achilleas) [2008] UKHL 48Question 7 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Tilia Partners, an executive recruitment firm, was formed in reliance on negligent advice from its solicitors about its partnership agreement, which forced it to buy out a partner early. Tilia claims lost profits, including profits on a very lucrative contract with a large bank that the solicitors could not have contemplated. The solicitors owed duties in both contract and tort. Which remoteness test applies?
- The tort test of reasonable foreseeability, as it is more generous to Tilia.
- The contractual test of reasonable contemplation.Correct answer
- Whichever test Tilia chooses, because it may elect between contract and tort.
- The tort test, because the solicitors' breach consisted of negligent advice.
- No remoteness test, because professional negligence is strictly liable.
Where a defendant owes concurrent duties in contract and tort, the Court of Appeal held that the contractual test of remoteness applies to a claim for pure economic loss, whichever cause of action is pleaded. This prevents a claimant from escaping the contractual allocation of risk by framing its claim in tort. The test is whether the type of loss was within the reasonable contemplation of the parties at the time of contracting as a not unlikely result. The tempting answer allows Tilia to choose the more generous tort test.
Law basis: Wellesley Partners LLP v Withers LLP [2015] EWCA Civ 1146Question 8 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Ulla bought turbines from Vega Engineering for her power station. They were defective and inefficient, in breach of contract. Ulla reasonably replaced them with new turbines of a more efficient type, which saved her more in running costs than the new turbines cost. She claims the cost of the replacements from Vega. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Ulla recovers the full replacement cost, because the breach caused her to buy them.
- Ulla recovers the replacement cost, but only after the original turbines failed.
- Ulla recovers nothing, because she chose to buy more efficient turbines.
- Ulla's damages are reduced by the savings that flowed from her mitigation.Correct answer
- Ulla recovers the difference between the old and new turbine prices.
Where a claimant takes reasonable steps to mitigate a loss, and those steps produce benefits arising out of the breach, the benefits must be taken into account in assessing damages. The House of Lords held that the savings from the more efficient replacement turbines exceeded the loss caused by the defective ones, so the claimant could not recover the cost of the replacements. The tempting answer allows full recovery, which would leave the claimant better off than if the contract had been performed. The replacement itself was reasonable mitigation.
Law basis: British Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd [1912] AC 673Question 9 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Wix Ltd agreed to buy silk from Yarn Ltd in instalments, payment within one month of delivery. After Wix paid one instalment late, Yarn wrongly refused to deliver further instalments except for cash with each order, but offered to supply at the contract price on that basis. Wix refused, bought silk elsewhere at a higher price and claimed the difference. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Wix's damages are limited, as it unreasonably refused Yarn's offer.Correct answer
- Wix recovers the difference, because Yarn was not entitled to demand cash.
- Wix recovers nothing, because its late payment justified Yarn's demand.
- Wix recovers the difference, because it need not deal with the party in breach.
- Wix recovers the difference plus interest on the money it would have paid.
A claimant cannot recover loss it could reasonably have avoided. A reasonable offer from the party in breach may be one the claimant should accept in mitigation, particularly in a commercial context where there is no reason to distrust it. Yarn offered the silk at the contract price, subject only to cash payment, and Wix had the means to pay, so it acted unreasonably in refusing. Its damages were limited to the loss it would have suffered had it accepted. The tempting answer assumes a claimant need never deal again with the contract-breaker.
Law basis: Payzu Ltd v Saunders [1919] 2 KB 581Question 10 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Zoe bought a house relying on her solicitor, Abe, who negligently failed to notice that the vendor's title was defective. As a result the house was worth less. Abe argues that Zoe should have mitigated her loss by suing the vendor under the covenants for title, a claim of uncertain outcome that would involve complex litigation. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Zoe's damages are reduced, because she failed to sue the vendor first.
- Zoe recovers nothing until she has exhausted her claim against the vendor.
- Zoe need not undertake complex, uncertain litigation to mitigate.Correct answer
- Zoe's damages are reduced by the value of her claim against the vendor.
- Zoe must sue the vendor, because a claimant must take every possible step.
The duty to mitigate requires the claimant to take only reasonable steps. It does not require her to embark on complicated and uncertain litigation against a third party to reduce the loss caused by the defendant's breach. The court held that the claimant was not obliged to sue the vendor before recovering from her negligent solicitor. The tempting answer imposes an obligation to take every possible step, which goes beyond what is reasonable. The standard of mitigation is not a high one, given that the defendant is the wrongdoer.
Law basis: Pilkington v Wood [1953] Ch 770Question 11 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Bel Bank's banknote printer, Cole Ltd, in breach of contract, allowed a fraudster to obtain a large number of notes. The bank, to maintain confidence in its currency, decided to honour all the fake notes presented, exchanging them for genuine notes. Cole argues that this was an excessive response and that the bank's loss was only the cost of printing replacement notes. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The bank recovers only the printing cost, because that was its true loss.
- The bank recovers the value of the notes honoured, as it acted reasonably.Correct answer
- The bank recovers nothing, because honouring fake notes was voluntary.
- The bank recovers only half its loss, because it chose an expensive response.
- The bank recovers the value only if it was legally obliged to honour them.
A claimant who acts reasonably in attempting to mitigate its loss can recover the costs of doing so, even if, with hindsight, a different course would have produced a smaller loss. The defendant, whose breach created the difficulty, cannot insist on fine judgements. The House of Lords held that the bank had acted reasonably in honouring the notes to maintain confidence in the currency, and could recover their face value. The tempting answer limits the bank to the printing cost, but that ignores the reasonable steps taken in the crisis caused by the breach.
Law basis: Banco de Portugal v Waterlow & Sons Ltd [1932] AC 452Question 12 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Dov, a subcontractor, was entitled under his contract with Eves Builders to be supplied with a stepladder. Eves failed to supply one. Dov chose instead to stand on an unfooted trestle, which slipped, and he was injured. He sues Eves for breach of contract, claiming damages for his injuries. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Eves is not liable, as its breach merely gave Dov the occasion.Correct answer
- Eves is liable, because its breach of contract led to Dov's injury.
- Eves is liable, but damages are reduced for Dov's contributory negligence.
- Eves is not liable, because personal injury cannot be claimed in contract.
- Eves is liable, because it should have foreseen Dov using unsafe equipment.
A claimant must show that the breach was an effective cause of the loss, not merely the occasion for it. The Court of Appeal held that the failure to supply a stepladder merely gave the claimant the opportunity to injure himself; the effective cause of the injury was his own voluntary decision to use an unsafe trestle. Eves was not liable. The tempting answer treats the breach as a cause simply because the injury would not have happened without it, but 'but for' causation is not enough. Foreseeability alone does not establish effective causation.
Law basis: Quinn v Burch Bros (Builders) Ltd [1966] 2 QB 370Question 13 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Fen Bank contracted with Gale Builders to clean and repair the roof of its warehouse, under a strict contractual obligation, not a duty of care. Gale's workers used a method that released asbestos dust, contaminating the building. Gale argues that Fen's damages should be reduced because Fen was itself careless in failing to supervise the work. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Fen's damages are reduced, because contributory negligence applies to all contracts.
- Fen's damages are reduced only if Fen's carelessness caused the release of dust.
- Fen's damages are reduced by half, because both parties were at fault.
- Fen's damages are not reduced, because a bank owes no duty to supervise.
- Fen's damages are not reduced, as Gale breached a strict obligation.Correct answer
The statutory power to reduce damages for contributory negligence applies to a contract claim only where the defendant's liability in contract is the same as its liability in the tort of negligence. Where the defendant is in breach of a strict contractual obligation, not dependent on negligence, apportionment is not available. The Court of Appeal held that a builder in breach of a strict obligation could not rely on the employer's contributory negligence. The tempting answer applies apportionment to every contract claim, which is too broad.
Law basis: Barclays Bank plc v Fairclough Building Ltd [1995] QB 214; Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945, s 1Question 14 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Hari, a farmer, bought a towing hitch from a dealer, who warranted it was fit for use. The hitch's locking mechanism broke, and Hari, knowing it was broken, kept using it for several months. The trailer came loose and caused a fatal accident. Hari was held liable to the victims and sues the dealer for an indemnity for breach of warranty. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Hari recovers in full, because the hitch was not fit for use when sold.
- Hari recovers in full, because the warranty continued while he used the hitch.
- Hari recovers half, because both he and the dealer were at fault.
- Hari recovers nothing, as his knowing continued use broke the chain.Correct answer
- Hari recovers nothing, because warranties never cover liability to third parties.
A warranty of fitness relates to the goods at the time of sale and, while it may extend to their continued fitness for a reasonable time, it does not cover a period after the buyer knows they are defective. Once Hari knew the hitch was broken and continued to use it, his own conduct, not the breach of warranty, was the cause of his liability to the victims. The House of Lords held that his claim failed. The tempting answer assumes the warranty continued regardless of his knowledge.
Law basis: Lambert v Lewis [1982] AC 225Question 15 · Damages: remoteness, causation and mitigationDraft, pending solicitor review
Ida was employed as managing director of Jet Ltd on a five-year contract. Jet told her in advance that it would remove her from office in three months' time, in breach of contract. Ida did not accept the repudiation and insisted the contract continued. In the meantime she turned down another job offer. Jet argues that her damages should be reduced for failure to mitigate during that period. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Her damages are reduced, because she unreasonably refused the other job.
- Her damages are reduced, because she should have accepted the repudiation.
- Her damages are reduced, because mitigation applies from the date of the threat.
- No duty to mitigate ever arises for directors under fixed-term contracts.
- No duty to mitigate arose until she accepted the repudiation.Correct answer
Where a party commits an anticipatory breach and the innocent party does not accept it, the contract remains alive and there is no duty to mitigate loss before the breach is accepted or the time for performance arrives. Ida was entitled to refuse to accept the repudiation and to keep the contract alive, so declining another offer during that period was not a failure to mitigate. Once the actual breach occurs and she claims damages, she must then take reasonable steps to mitigate. The tempting answer imposes a duty from the date of the threat.
Law basis: Shindler v Northern Raincoat Co Ltd [1960] 1 WLR 1038More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.