Law covered in these questions
- Balfour v Balfour [1919] 2 KB 571
- Merritt v Merritt [1970] 1 WLR 1211
- Jones v Padavatton [1969] 1 WLR 328
- Simpkins v Pays [1955] 1 WLR 975
- Edwards v Skyways Ltd [1964] 1 WLR 349
- Rose and Frank Co v JR Crompton & Bros Ltd [1925] AC 445
- Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Malaysia Mining Corp Bhd [1989] 1 WLR 379
- RTS Flexible Systems Ltd v Molkerei Alois Müller GmbH & Co KG [2010] UKSC 14
All 8 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Intention to create legal relationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Omar, who worked overseas, was home on leave with his wife Petra. When he returned to work, he promised to send her £400 a month while he was away. Their relationship later broke down and he stopped paying. Petra sues for the unpaid instalments. When the promise was made, the couple were living together happily. Which of the following best describes Petra's position?
- She will succeed, because a promise of regular payments is a commercial arrangement.
- She will succeed, because her agreement to remain at home was good consideration.
- She will succeed, because the later breakdown makes the original promise enforceable.
- She will fail, because promises of money between spouses must be made by deed.
- She will fail, as a domestic agreement between spouses is presumed not binding.Correct answer
There is a rebuttable presumption that domestic and social agreements, particularly between spouses living together amicably, are not intended to create legal relations. Nothing here rebuts it: the arrangement was made while the marriage was happy and was not formalised. Petra's claim fails. The later breakdown does not retrospectively change the parties' intention when they agreed. The answer based on consideration is tempting, but even if consideration existed the absence of intention would be fatal.
Law basis: Balfour v Balfour [1919] 2 KB 571Question 2 · Intention to create legal relationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Quinn and his wife Rosa had separated, and he had moved out. Sitting in his car, they agreed in writing that if Rosa paid off the mortgage on the jointly owned home, Quinn would transfer his share of it to her. Rosa paid off the mortgage, but Quinn refused to transfer his share. Which of the following best describes Rosa's position?
- She will fail, because agreements between spouses are always presumed not to be binding.
- She will succeed, as the presumption against intention does not apply here.Correct answer
- She will fail, because the agreement was made informally in a car and not in a deed.
- She will succeed, but only to recover the mortgage payments she made as restitution.
- She will fail, because a promise to transfer a share of a home is unenforceable.
The presumption that spouses do not intend to create legal relations applies to couples living together amicably. Where spouses have separated or are about to separate, they are presumed to bargain at arm's length and to intend legal consequences. Rosa and Quinn had separated and recorded their deal in writing, so the agreement was binding and Rosa is entitled to Quinn's share. The tempting answer applies the domestic presumption without asking whether the spouses were still living together.
Law basis: Merritt v Merritt [1970] 1 WLR 1211Question 3 · Intention to create legal relationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Sana persuaded her adult daughter Tara to give up a well-paid job in Washington and study for the Bar in London, promising to pay her an allowance of £200 a month. Later, Sana bought a house in London where Tara lived, letting out rooms. After a quarrel, Sana sought possession. Tara relied on the agreement. Which of the following best describes the court's likely view?
- The agreement was binding, because Tara gave consideration by changing her career.
- The agreement was binding, because a parent's promise of support is a commercial promise.
- The agreement was binding, because it was acted upon for several years.
- The agreement was not binding, because it was a family arrangement lacking intention.Correct answer
- The agreement was not binding, because Tara was an adult when it was made.
Family arrangements are presumed not to be intended to have legal consequences. In the leading case the Court of Appeal held that an arrangement between a mother and daughter for maintenance and housing while the daughter studied was a family arrangement, too vague and informal to be contractually binding. The tempting answer points to consideration in the daughter's career change, but consideration does not supply intention. Adulthood alone is not the test, and long reliance did not convert the family understanding into a contract.
Law basis: Jones v Padavatton [1969] 1 WLR 328Question 4 · Intention to create legal relationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Uma, her granddaughter Vi and their lodger Will entered a weekly fashion competition in a newspaper in Uma's name. All three contributed answers and shared the cost of entry fees, agreeing to split any winnings. One week the entry won £750, but Uma kept it all. Will sues for his share. Which of the following best describes Will's position?
- He will succeed, as the arrangement showed an intention to be legally bound.Correct answer
- He will fail, because agreements within a household are presumed not to be binding.
- He will fail, because a competition entry is a wager and is therefore unenforceable.
- He will succeed only if the agreement to share winnings was recorded in writing.
- He will fail, because the entry was in Uma's name and so the winnings are hers alone.
The presumption against intention in social and domestic agreements can be rebutted by evidence. Where members of a household pool money for a joint venture and agree to share any winnings, the mutuality of the arrangement shows an intention to be legally bound. Will contributed to a joint enterprise, so he is entitled to one-third. The tempting answer applies the household presumption without considering that it was rebutted. Entering in one person's name does not make the winnings hers, and no writing was required.
Law basis: Simpkins v Pays [1955] 1 WLR 975Question 5 · Intention to create legal relationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Xeno Airlines agreed with a union, while making pilots redundant, that pilots who left would receive an 'ex gratia payment approximating to' their pension contributions. Yann left relying on this. The airline later refused to pay, arguing that the words 'ex gratia' showed no legal obligation was intended. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The airline is not bound, because 'ex gratia' clearly means no legal liability is accepted.
- The airline is not bound, because agreements with trade unions are never legally enforceable.
- The airline is bound, as it has not rebutted the strong commercial presumption.Correct answer
- The airline is bound only if Yann can prove he gave separate consideration for the payment.
- The airline is not bound, because the payment was described as only approximate.
In commercial agreements there is a strong presumption that the parties intend to create legal relations, and the party asserting otherwise bears a heavy burden. The words 'ex gratia' merely indicated that the payment was not an admission of a pre-existing liability; they did not show that the promise itself was not to be binding. The airline was therefore bound. The tempting answer gives 'ex gratia' a meaning it did not have in context. The word 'approximating' did not make the obligation too uncertain to enforce.
Law basis: Edwards v Skyways Ltd [1964] 1 WLR 349Question 6 · Intention to create legal relationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Zephyr Ltd agreed to act as UK distributor for Atlas Paper Ltd's products. Their written agreement stated: 'This arrangement is not entered into as a formal or legal agreement and shall not be subject to legal jurisdiction in the courts, but is only a record of the parties' intentions.' Atlas terminated without notice, and Zephyr sued for breach of the distribution agreement. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The agreement is binding, because commercial agreements are conclusively presumed to be enforceable.
- The agreement is binding, because a clause ousting the courts' jurisdiction is void.
- The agreement is not binding, because the parties expressly excluded legal relations.Correct answer
- The agreement is not binding, because distribution agreements must be made by deed.
- The agreement is binding, because Zephyr had already incurred costs in reliance on it.
The commercial presumption of intention to create legal relations is rebuttable, and an express 'honour clause' stating that the arrangement is not to be legally binding is effective. The overall distribution agreement was therefore not enforceable. However, individual orders actually placed and accepted under it could be binding contracts in their own right. The tempting answer treats the clause as a void ouster of jurisdiction, but the House of Lords held that the parties were free to agree that no legal relations were intended.
Law basis: Rose and Frank Co v JR Crompton & Bros Ltd [1925] AC 445Question 7 · Intention to create legal relationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Beacon Bank lent £10m to a subsidiary of Cobalt Mining plc. Cobalt refused to give a guarantee but provided a letter stating: 'It is our policy to ensure that the business of our subsidiary is at all times in a position to meet its liabilities to you.' The subsidiary became insolvent. Cobalt had changed its policy. Beacon sues Cobalt. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Cobalt is liable, because statements in commercial documents are presumed to be binding.
- Cobalt is liable, because the letter was in substance a guarantee of the loan.
- Cobalt is liable, because the letter was a misrepresentation inducing the loan.
- Cobalt is not liable, because a parent company is never liable for a subsidiary's debts.
- Cobalt is not liable, because the letter stated present policy rather than a promise.Correct answer
Even in a commercial context, a document must be construed to see whether it contains a contractual promise. A comfort letter stating the parent's current policy is a statement of present fact, not a promise as to future conduct. Cobalt had refused a guarantee, which supported the view that it was not undertaking legal liability. As the statement was true when made, it was not a misrepresentation either. The tempting answer applies the commercial presumption, but that presumption does not turn a non-promissory statement into a promise.
Law basis: Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Malaysia Mining Corp Bhd [1989] 1 WLR 379Question 8 · Intention to create legal relationsDraft, pending solicitor review
Dyna Ltd agreed to supply automated equipment to Ebor Dairies Ltd. A draft contract stated it would not become effective until signed by both parties. The parties never signed it, but Dyna started work, the parties agreed significant variations, and Ebor paid 70% of the price. Ebor now argues that no contract exists because the 'subject to contract' condition was never satisfied. Which of the following best describes the court's likely view?
- No contract exists, because a 'subject to contract' condition can never be waived by conduct.
- A contract exists, but on terms implied by statute rather than the draft's terms.
- No contract exists, because the variations agreed meant there was never final agreement.
- A contract exists, because by their conduct the parties waived the signing requirement.Correct answer
- No contract exists, so Dyna's only remedy is a claim for damages in misrepresentation.
Whether parties intended to be bound despite a 'subject to contract' or signature requirement depends on an objective assessment of their words and conduct. Such a requirement can be waived where the conduct shows that they agreed all essential terms and intended to be bound without signature. Dyna's performance, the agreed variations and the substantial payments showed exactly that, so a binding contract existed on the agreed terms. The tempting answer treats the condition as incapable of waiver, but the Supreme Court held otherwise.
Law basis: RTS Flexible Systems Ltd v Molkerei Alois Müller GmbH & Co KG [2010] UKSC 14More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.