Law covered in these questions
- Fisher v Bell [1961] 1 QB 394
- Pharmaceutical Society of GB v Boots Cash Chemists [1953] 1 QB 401
- Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256
- Partridge v Crittenden [1968] 1 WLR 1204
- Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 57(2)
- Payne v Cave (1789) 3 TR 148
- Barry v Davies (t/a Heathcote Ball & Co) [2000] 1 WLR 1962
- Harvela Investments Ltd v Royal Trust Co of Canada (CI) Ltd [1986] AC 207
- Blackpool and Fylde Aero Club Ltd v Blackpool BC [1990] 1 WLR 1195
- Dickinson v Dodds (1876) 2 Ch D 463
- Byrne & Co v Van Tienhoven & Co (1880) 5 CPD 344
- Adams v Lindsell (1818) 1 B & Ald 681
- Routledge v Grant (1828) 4 Bing 653
- Ramsgate Victoria Hotel Co Ltd v Montefiore (1866) LR 1 Ex 109
All 17 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
A clothing shop displays a coat in its window with a price ticket of £50. A customer enters the shop and offers £50 for the coat. The manager refuses, saying the ticket was a mistake and the real price is £150. Which statement best describes the legal position?
- The shop is bound, because a seller's mistake as to price can never prevent a contract from being formed.
- The shop is not bound, because the window display is an invitation to treat and the customer's tender is the offer, which the shop may refuse.Correct answer
- The shop is not bound, because any offer made by display lapses automatically once a customer enters the shop.
- The shop is bound, because the priced window display is an offer which the customer accepted by tendering the stated price.
- The shop is bound, because the display is a unilateral offer to the world which the customer accepted by entering the shop.
Goods displayed with a price are normally an invitation to treat, not an offer. The customer makes the offer at the till or when tendering payment, and the shop is free to accept or refuse it. The wrong options treat the display as an offer, or invent a rule that mistakes as to price never matter.
Law basis: Fisher v Bell [1961] 1 QB 394; Pharmaceutical Society of GB v Boots Cash Chemists [1953] 1 QB 401Question 2 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Vitalis Ltd advertised its new air purifier in a national newspaper: 'We will pay £1,000 to anyone who uses our purifier daily for three months and still catches the flu. £50,000 is deposited with Barclays to show our sincerity.' Ruth bought a purifier, used it daily as directed and caught flu ten weeks later. Vitalis says Ruth never told it she was taking up the offer. Which of the following best describes Ruth's position?
- She has no claim, because a newspaper advertisement is an invitation to treat rather than an offer.
- She has no claim, because acceptance of an offer must always be communicated to the offeror.
- She has no claim, because the advertisement was a mere puff not intended to be legally binding.
- She can claim £1,000 only if she bought the purifier directly from Vitalis rather than a retailer.
- She can claim £1,000, because the advertisement was a unilateral offer accepted by performance.Correct answer
An advertisement can be a unilateral offer to the world where it is clear and shows an intention to be bound, as the bank deposit does here. In a unilateral contract the offeror impliedly waives the need for notification of acceptance; the offeree accepts by performing the stipulated act. Ruth performed, so she is entitled to £1,000. The 'mere puff' argument fails because the deposit shows seriousness, and the usual rule that adverts are invitations to treat does not apply to unilateral offers of this kind.
Law basis: Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256Question 3 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Owen placed an advertisement in a specialist magazine: 'Rare Bengal cats, kittens available, £600 each.' Priya telephoned Owen, said she wanted to buy one at £600 and that she would collect it on Saturday. Owen told her he had decided not to sell to anyone outside his breeders' club. Priya argues that Owen is in breach of contract. Which of the following best describes the legal position?
- There is a contract, because Owen's advertisement stated a clear price and Priya accepted it.
- There is a contract, because an advertisement in a specialist publication is a unilateral offer.
- There is no contract, because the advert was an invitation to treat and Priya made the offer.Correct answer
- There is no contract, because acceptance of an offer for goods must be made in writing.
- There is a contract, because Owen can only refuse to sell to a buyer on reasonable grounds.
Advertisements of goods for sale in a periodical are generally invitations to treat, because the advertiser has limited stock and cannot sensibly be bound to sell to everyone who replies. Priya's telephone call was therefore an offer to buy, which Owen was free to reject. The suggestion that the clear price makes the advert an offer is tempting, but the courts treat price-stating adverts for goods the same way. There is no general writing requirement for sales of goods and no duty to give reasons for refusing an offer.
Law basis: Partridge v Crittenden [1968] 1 WLR 1204Question 4 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
At an auction of vintage watches, the auction was advertised as being subject to a reserve on some lots. Kamal bid £4,200 for a watch. Before the auctioneer brought the hammer down, Kamal shouted that he was withdrawing his bid. The auctioneer ignored him and knocked the lot down to Kamal at £4,200. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Kamal is bound, because a bid at auction is an irrevocable offer once the bidding has opened.
- Kamal is not bound, because a bid may be retracted at any time until the fall of the hammer.Correct answer
- Kamal is bound, because the auctioneer accepted his bid by continuing to call for higher bids.
- Kamal is not bound, because no contract arises at an auction until the buyer signs a sale note.
- Kamal is bound, because withdrawal of a bid is only effective if made in writing to the auctioneer.
At an auction the bidder makes the offer and the auctioneer accepts it by the fall of the hammer or in another customary manner. Until that moment no contract exists, and the bidder may retract the bid. Kamal withdrew before the hammer fell, so his offer was revoked and the later knock-down accepted nothing. The idea that a bid becomes irrevocable is wrong because revocation is permitted at any time before acceptance. No writing is needed for either the bid or its withdrawal.
Law basis: Sale of Goods Act 1979, s 57(2); Payne v Cave (1789) 3 TR 148 ↗Question 5 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
An auction house advertised that a set of industrial machines would be sold 'without reserve'. At the sale Hassan made the only bid, of £1,500, for the machines, which were worth about £14,000. The auctioneer refused to accept the bid and withdrew the lot. Hassan seeks damages from the auctioneer. Which of the following best describes Hassan's position?
- He can claim the difference in value, because the auctioneer breached a collateral contract.Correct answer
- He has no claim, because an advertisement of an auction is merely an invitation to treat.
- He can claim, but only for his wasted travel costs, because no contract of sale was formed.
- He has no claim, because an auctioneer may always withdraw a lot before the fall of the hammer.
- He can claim specific performance against the seller, because the sale contract was complete.
When an auction is held without reserve, the auctioneer makes a collateral offer to sell to the highest bona fide bidder, which is accepted by making the highest bid. Withdrawing the lot breaches that collateral contract, and the bidder may recover the difference between the bid and the value of the goods. Although no contract of sale with the owner arose, so specific performance is unavailable, the auctioneer is personally liable. The general rule that a lot may be withdrawn before the hammer falls applies to auctions with a reserve.
Law basis: Barry v Davies (t/a Heathcote Ball & Co) [2000] 1 WLR 1962Question 6 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Delta Holdings invited two parties, Rana and Silas, to submit sealed bids for its shares, promising to accept the highest offer. Rana bid £2.1m. Silas bid '£2.05m or £100,000 more than any other offer, whichever is higher'. Delta accepted Silas's bid as being £2.2m. Rana challenges this. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Silas's bid is valid, because a bidder may frame an offer in any terms the invitation does not forbid.
- Delta may choose either bid, because an invitation to tender is always only an invitation to treat.
- Neither bid is valid, because an invitation to tender can never create any binding obligation.
- Rana is entitled to the shares, because Silas's referential bid was invalid in a fixed bidding sale.Correct answer
- Silas's bid is valid only for £2.05m, so Delta must accept Rana's higher bid of £2.1m instead.
Here the invitation, by promising to accept the highest bid, was itself an offer of a unilateral contract to sell to the highest bidder. The purpose of a sealed fixed bidding sale is that each party makes a single definite bid; a referential bid defeats that purpose and is invalid. Rana's bid was the highest valid bid, so Delta was bound to accept it. Arguing that Silas's bid should be read at £2.05m reaches the same result for a different, incorrect reason: the referential bid is not cut down, it is ineffective.
Law basis: Harvela Investments Ltd v Royal Trust Co of Canada (CI) Ltd [1986] AC 207Question 7 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Northshire Council invited seven named operators to tender for a pleasure-flight concession, stating that tenders must be in the official envelope and received by noon on 17 March. Skyline Ltd delivered its tender to the council's letterbox at 11am on that day, but the box was not emptied and the council wrongly treated the tender as late and did not consider it. Which of the following best describes Skyline's position?
- It has no claim, because an invitation to tender is only an invitation to treat with no obligations.
- It is entitled to the concession, because its tender was received in time and met every condition.
- It has a claim, because the council impliedly undertook to consider conforming tenders.Correct answer
- It has no claim, because a council acting in a public role cannot be liable in contract.
- It has a claim in misrepresentation, because the council's invitation was a false statement.
Although an invitation to tender is normally an invitation to treat, the circumstances may show an implied unilateral contract that any conforming tender will be opened and considered. Factors include a small number of known invitees, a clear procedure and a fixed deadline. Skyline's tender complied, so failure to consider it was a breach. The council did not, however, promise to award the concession to any particular tenderer, so Skyline is not entitled to the contract itself; it may recover for the loss of a chance of being chosen.
Law basis: Blackpool and Fylde Aero Club Ltd v Blackpool BC [1990] 1 WLR 1195Question 8 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
On Monday Ivor offered in writing to sell his flat to Jess for £240,000, saying the offer would remain open until Friday. On Thursday Jess heard from a reliable mutual friend that Ivor had agreed to sell the flat to Kit. On Thursday evening Jess delivered a written acceptance to Ivor. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a binding contract, because Ivor promised to keep the offer open until Friday.
- There is a binding contract, because a revocation must be communicated by the offeror personally.
- There is no contract, because an offer to sell land lapses once the property is sold to another.
- There is no contract, because Jess reliably learned of the revocation before accepting.Correct answer
- There is no contract, because acceptance of an offer for land must be in a deed to be effective.
An offer may be revoked at any time before acceptance, and a promise to keep it open is not binding unless supported by consideration. Revocation must be communicated, but it need not come from the offeror: it is enough that the offeree learns from a reliable source that the offeror no longer intends to sell. Jess knew this before she accepted, so the offer was revoked. The tempting answer relying on Ivor's promise to keep the offer open fails because Jess gave nothing for that promise.
Law basis: Dickinson v Dodds (1876) 2 Ch D 463Question 9 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
On 1 October Lars posted a letter to Mei offering to sell her 500 tonnes of steel. On 8 October Lars posted a letter revoking the offer. On 11 October Mei received the offer and immediately posted an acceptance. On 20 October she received the revocation. Which of the following best describes whether a contract was formed?
- No contract was formed, because the revocation was posted before Mei's acceptance was posted.
- No contract was formed, because an offer made by post lapses after seven days if not accepted.
- No contract was formed, because the postal rule applies equally to revocations and acceptances.
- A contract was formed on 20 October, because acceptance takes effect when the offeror reads it.
- A contract was formed on 11 October, because the revocation took effect only when received.Correct answer
The postal rule applies to acceptances but not to revocations. A revocation is effective only when it is actually communicated to the offeree. Mei's acceptance was complete when posted on 11 October, at which point she had not received the revocation, so a contract was formed then. The suggestion that the postal rule also covers revocations is the classic misconception: posting a revocation does nothing until it arrives. There is no fixed seven-day lapse rule; an offer lapses after a reasonable time, and three days was well within that.
Law basis: Byrne & Co v Van Tienhoven & Co (1880) 5 CPD 344; Adams v Lindsell (1818) 1 B & Ald 681Question 10 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Nadia offered to sell her yacht to Oscar for £60,000 and said: 'I will keep this offer open for 14 days so you can arrange finance.' Oscar paid nothing for this. On day 5 Nadia told Oscar she was withdrawing the offer. On day 9 Oscar told Nadia he accepted. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a contract, because Nadia's promise to keep the offer open bound her for 14 days.
- There is no contract, because Nadia validly revoked the offer before Oscar accepted it.Correct answer
- There is a contract, because Oscar relied on the promise by arranging finance.
- There is no contract, because an offer to sell a yacht must be accepted within 7 days.
- There is a contract, because an offer stated to be open for a fixed period is a deed.
An offeror may revoke an offer at any time before it is accepted, even if she has promised to keep it open, unless the offeree has given consideration for that promise and so created a separate option contract. Oscar provided nothing in return for the 14-day promise, so Nadia was free to revoke on day 5 and Oscar's later acceptance came too late. Reliance alone does not make a gratuitous promise to keep an offer open binding in English law, and there is no fixed 7-day rule.
Law basis: Routledge v Grant (1828) 4 Bing 653; Dickinson v Dodds (1876) 2 Ch D 463Question 11 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
In June Pavel applied in writing to buy 500 shares in Quill Hotels plc, a newly formed company, paying a deposit. He heard nothing until late November, when the company allotted him the shares and demanded the balance. Share values had fallen sharply. Pavel refuses to pay. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Pavel is not bound, because his offer lapsed after a reasonable time had passed.Correct answer
- Pavel is bound, because his payment of a deposit made the offer irrevocable.
- Pavel is bound, because an offer remains open until it is expressly withdrawn by the offeror.
- Pavel is not bound, because an offer to buy shares must be accepted within 28 days.
- Pavel is bound, because silence by the offeror for a period amounts to acceptance.
Where an offer states no time limit, it lapses after a reasonable time, judged by the subject matter and the circumstances. Shares are a fluctuating commodity, and a delay of five months was unreasonable, so Pavel's offer had lapsed before the company purported to accept it. The idea that an offer stays open until expressly withdrawn ignores lapse. Paying a deposit with an application does not make the offer irrevocable, and there is no fixed statutory 28-day period for acceptance of such an offer.
Law basis: Ramsgate Victoria Hotel Co Ltd v Montefiore (1866) LR 1 Ex 109Question 12 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Bayview Properties told Arun: 'If you obtain planning permission and finance and are ready to pay £3m by 30 June, we will sell you the warehouse.' Arun spent £40,000 on planning work and obtained permission and finance. On 20 June, before Arun could tender payment, Bayview said it had changed its mind. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Bayview may withdraw, because a unilateral offer can be revoked at any time before completion.
- Bayview may not withdraw, as it impliedly agreed not to revoke once Arun began performing.Correct answer
- Bayview may withdraw, but must reimburse Arun's planning costs as restitution.
- Bayview may not withdraw, because a promise to sell land is binding once it is made orally.
- Bayview may withdraw, because Arun had not yet communicated his acceptance in writing.
In a unilateral contract the offeree accepts by performance, so no acceptance needs to be communicated. Once the offeree has embarked on performance, the courts imply an obligation on the offeror not to revoke or prevent completion. Arun had begun, and almost finished, performing, so Bayview could not withdraw. The orthodox rule that an offer may be revoked before acceptance is the tempting wrong answer, but it is displaced by this implied collateral obligation. A restitutionary claim for costs is not the governing analysis.
Law basis: Daulia Ltd v Four Millbank Nominees Ltd [1978] Ch 231; Errington v Errington and Woods [1952] 1 KB 290Question 13 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Selina sent Tom a message: 'Will you sell me your cottage? Send your lowest price.' Tom replied: 'Lowest price for the cottage is £180,000.' Selina replied: 'I agree to buy the cottage for £180,000.' Tom then sold to someone else. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a contract, because Tom's reply stated a price and Selina accepted it unconditionally.
- There is a contract, because a price quoted in response to a request is a firm offer.
- There is no contract, because Tom's reply merely supplied information about his price.Correct answer
- There is no contract, because contracts for land can only be formed through solicitors.
- There is a contract, because Selina's first message was an offer that Tom accepted.
A statement of the lowest price a party would accept, given in response to a request for information, is not an offer. It answers a question but shows no intention to be bound on acceptance. Selina's final message was therefore an offer, which Tom never accepted. The tempting answer treats the stated price as an offer, but the courts distinguish supplying information from making a commitment. Selina's first message asked two questions and was not itself an offer either.
Law basis: Harvey v Facey [1893] AC 552Question 14 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Umar offered to supply Vera with 2,000 bricks for £1,200, delivery within 30 days. Vera replied: 'Before deciding, can you tell me whether you could deliver in two instalments?' Umar did not reply. Two days later Vera wrote: 'I accept your offer as made.' Umar refuses to supply, saying Vera rejected his offer. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a contract, because Vera's inquiry left the offer open for her to accept.Correct answer
- There is no contract, because Vera's reply introduced a new term and was a counter-offer.
- There is no contract, because any response other than acceptance terminates an offer.
- There is a contract, but only on the basis that delivery is made in two instalments.
- There is no contract, because Umar's silence after the inquiry amounted to revocation.
A counter-offer rejects and destroys the original offer, but a mere request for information or inquiry about whether terms might be varied does not. Vera did not propose new terms; she asked a question while leaving the offer open. Her later unqualified acceptance therefore created a contract on Umar's original terms. The tempting answer treats the inquiry as a counter-offer, but the courts ask whether the reply was intended to reject the offer, and an inquiry is not. Umar's silence revoked nothing.
Law basis: Stevenson, Jaques & Co v McLean (1880) 5 QBD 346Question 15 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
A charity offered a £2,000 reward for information leading to the conviction of whoever vandalised its premises. Wyn knew of the reward. She gave the information to the police mainly because she feared her own arrest, not to obtain the reward. The vandal was convicted. Which of the following best describes Wyn's entitlement?
- She is entitled, but only to a proportion reflecting her motive in giving the information.
- She is not entitled, because her main motive was self-protection rather than the reward.
- She is not entitled, because a reward offer is an invitation to treat, not an offer.
- She is entitled, because she performed the act requested while aware of the offer.Correct answer
- She is not entitled, because she did not notify the charity before giving the information.
A reward offer is a unilateral offer to the world, accepted by performing the stated act. The offeree must know of the offer, but her motive for performing is irrelevant. Wyn knew of the reward and supplied the information, so she is entitled. The tempting answer focuses on her self-protective motive, but English law does not inquire into why the act was done once the offeree knew of the offer. No prior notification is needed, and there is no apportionment by motive.
Law basis: Williams v Carwardine (1833) 5 C & P 566Question 16 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
Zara offered by telex, sent at 5.30pm on a Friday during the recipient's normal office hours, to withdraw a charter offer previously made to Gallo Shipping. Gallo's staff did not read the telex until Monday morning. At 9am on Monday, before reading it, Gallo's manager sent an acceptance of the charter offer. Which of the following best describes the position?
- A contract was formed, because a revocation is effective only when actually read by the offeree.
- A contract was formed, because an acceptance takes priority over a revocation sent by telex.
- A contract was formed, because revocations sent outside 9am to 5pm are ineffective until Monday.
- No contract was formed, because revocation is effective as soon as the offeror sends it.
- No contract was formed, as the revocation took effect on arrival in office hours.Correct answer
A revocation must be communicated, but where it is sent by instantaneous means to an office during normal business hours it is generally effective on arrival, even if no one reads it. The offeree cannot rely on its own failure to read its messages. Gallo received the revocation on Friday within its office hours, so the offer was withdrawn before the Monday acceptance. The answer requiring actual reading is tempting but ignores this business-hours principle, and the rule is not that revocation is effective on sending.
Law basis: The Brimnes [1975] QB 929Question 17 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
A council sent Harry, a tenant, a letter stating that it 'may be prepared to sell the house to you at £3,600' and inviting him to apply on an enclosed form. Harry completed and returned the form. Before the sale went further, the council changed policy and refused to sell. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a contract, because the letter named a price and Harry accepted it in the required form.
- There is a contract, because the council is estopped from changing its housing policy.
- There is a contract, because the parties' conduct showed full agreement on all essential terms.
- There is no contract, because a public body cannot be bound by a contract to sell land.
- There is no contract, because the council's letter was not an offer capable of acceptance.Correct answer
To be an offer, a statement must show an intention to be bound on acceptance. Words such as 'may be prepared to sell' are tentative and indicate only an invitation to treat. Harry's application was therefore an offer to buy, which the council never accepted, so there was no contract. The tempting answer treats the stated price as decisive, but courts look for a firm commitment. The House of Lords refused to look at the whole course of dealings to find agreement where there was no clear offer.
Law basis: Gibson v Manchester City Council [1979] 1 WLR 294More Contract Law topics
Back to all Contract Law questions, or sit a timed mock.