On 1 March Anna wrote to Ben offering to sell him her van for £8,000. On 2 March Ben replied offering £7,000. Anna did not respond. On 5 March Ben emailed: 'I accept your offer at £8,000.' Anna refuses to sell. Which statement best describes the position?
- A contract was formed on 2 March at £7,000, because Anna did not reject Ben's reply within a reasonable time.
- No contract was formed, because Ben's reply of 2 March was a request for information which suspended Anna's offer until she responded.
- A contract was formed on 5 March, because Ben accepted the terms of Anna's original offer while it was still open.
- No contract was formed, because Anna's original offer lapsed on 2 March through the passage of time.
- No contract was formed, because Ben's reply of 2 March was a counter-offer which terminated Anna's original offer.Correct answer
A counter-offer rejects and destroys the original offer, so it cannot later be accepted. Ben's email of 5 March is a fresh offer which Anna may refuse. Silence cannot amount to acceptance, and a one-day gap does not make the offer lapse.
Law basis: Hyde v Wrench (1840) 3 Beav 334; Stevenson, Jaques & Co v McLean (1880) 5 QBD 346 (request for information, contrasted); Felthouse v Bindley (1862) 11 CBNS 869